Concept of Environment

Dr. V.K.Maheshwari, M.A. (Socio, Phil) B.Sc. M. Ed, Ph.D. Former Principal, K.L.D.A.V.(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

Mrs Sudha Rani Maheshwari, M.Sc (Zoology), B.Ed. Former Principal. A.K.P.I.College, Roorkee, India

 

The word environment is derived from the French word “environ”. The meaning of the French word is somewhat related to “encompass” “encircle” etc. It is believed to have been introduced into the subject by biologist Jacob Van Erkul in the early 1900s.

Environment is the computation of all existing factors and non living factors that compile the surroundings of man. The external factors affecting an organism are also called as Environment Literary environment means the surrounding external conditions influencing development or growth of people, animal or plants; living or working conditions etc. Everything which surrounds us may collectively be termed as the Environment. This involves three questions
1. What is surrounded
The answer to this question is living objects in general and man in particular.
2. By what surrounded
The physical attributes are the answer to this question, which become environment. In fact, the concern of all education is the environment of man. However, man cannot exist or be understood in isolation from the other forms of life and from plant life. Hence, environment refers to the sum total of condition, which surrounds point in space and time. The scope of the term Environment has been changing and widening by the passage of time. In the primitive age, the environment consisted of only physical aspects of the planted earth’ land, air and water as biological communities. As the time passed on man extended his environment through his social, economic and political functions.
3. Where Surrounded
It is in nature that physical component of the plant earth, viz land, air, water etc., support and affect life in the biosphere. Environment is the representative of physical components of the earth where in man is an important factor affecting the environment.
Definitions of Environment:
‘Environment’, this word has a great importance in our life. The simple definition of environment is the ‘surrounding’. It is what surrounds a thing. We can also define it as “environment is the combination of all of physical and organic factors that act on a living being, residents, or ecological society and power its endurance and growth”.
Some important definitions of environment are as under:
1. Boring: ‘A person’s environment consists of the sum total of the stimulation which he receives from his conception until his death.’ It can be concluded from the above definition that Environment comprises various types of forces such as physical, intellectual, economic, political, cultural, social, moral and emotional. Environment is the sum total of all the external forces, influences and conditions, which affect the life, nature, behaviour and the growth, development and maturation of living organisms.
2. Douglas and Holland: ‘The term environment is used to describe, in the aggregate, all the external forces, influences and conditions, which affect the life, nature, behaviour and the growth, development and maturity of living organisms.’
Thus our environment can be defined as the physical, chemical and biological world that surround us as well as the complex of social and cultural conditions affecting an individual or community. This broad definition includes the natural world and the technological environment as well as the cultural and social contexts that shape human lives. It includes all factors living and nonliving that affect an individual organism or population at any point in the life cycle; set of circumstances surrounding a particular occurrence and all the things that surrounds us.
Thus we can conclude:
1)That environment can be defined as the natural surroundings of that organism which directly or indirectly influences the growth and development of the organism.
2)That environment is defined as the surroundings in which an organization operates including air, water, land and natural resources, flora, fauna, humans and their inter relations
3) That environment is the sum total of all living and non living factors that compose the surroundings of man
Importance of Environment Studies
The environment studies enlighten us, about the importance of protection and conservation of our indiscriminate release of pollution into the environment. At present a great number of environment issues, have grown in size and complexity day by day, threatening the survival of mankind on earth. We study about these issues besides and effective suggestions in the Environment Studies. Environment studies have become significant for the following reasons:
1. Environment Issues Being of International Importance
It has been well recognised that environment issues like global warming and ozone depletion, acid rain, marine pollution and biodiversity are not merely national issues but are global issues and hence must be tackled with international efforts and cooperation.
2. Problems Cropped in the Wake of Development
Development, in its wake gave birth to Urbanization, Industrial Growth, Transportation Systems, Agriculture and Housing etc. However, it has become phased out in the developed world. The North, to cleanse their own environment has, fact fully, managed to move ‘dirty’ factories of South. When the West developed, it did so perhaps in ignorance of the environmental impact of its activities. Evidently such a path is neither practicable nor desirable, even if developing world follows that.
3. Explosively Increase in Pollution
World census reflects that one in every seven persons in this planted lives in India. Evidently with 16 per cent of the world’s population and only 2.4 per cent of its land area, there is a heavy pressure on the natural resources including land. Agricultural experts have recognized soils health problems like deficiency of micronutrients and organic matter, soil salinity and damage of soil structure.
4. Need for an Alternative Solution
It is essential, especially for developing countries to find alternative paths to an alternative goal. We need a goal as under:
(1) A goal, which ultimately is the true goal of development an environmentally sound and sustainable development.
(2) A goal common to all citizens of our earth.
(3) A goal distant from the developing world in the manner it is from the over-consuming wasteful societies of the “developed” world.
5. Need to Save Humanity from Extinction
It is incumbent upon us to save the humanity from extinction. Consequent to our activitiesconstricting the environment and depleting the biosphere, in the name of development.
6. Need for Wise Planning of Development
Our survival and sustenance depend. Resources withdraw, processing and use of the product have all to by synchronised with the ecological cycles in any plan of development our actions should be planned ecologically for the sustenance of the environment and development.
Elements of Environment
Environment is constituted by the interacting systems of physical, biological and cultural elements inter-related in various ways, individually as well as collectively. These elements may be explained as under:
(1) Physical elements
Physical elements are as space, landforms, water bodies, climate soils, rocks and minerals. They determine the variable character of the human habitat, its opportunities as well as limitations.
(2) Biological elements
Biological elements such as plants, animals, microorganisms and men constitute the biosphere.
(3) Cultural elements
Cultural elements such as economic, social and political elements are essentially manmade features, which make cultural milieu.
Structures of Environment
Environment is both physical and biological. It includes both living and non-living components.
(A) Physical Environment
The Physical Environment is classified into three broad categories viz.
(i) Solid,
(ii) Liquid
(iii) Gas.
These represent the following spheres:
(i) The lithosphere (solid earth)
(ii) The hydrosphere (water component) and
(iii) The atmosphere
As such, the three basic of physical environment may be termed as under:
(i) Lithospheric Environment
(ii) Hydrospheric Environment
(iii) Atmospheric Environment
The scientists have classified them into smaller units based on different spatial scales,e.g.
(i) Mountain Environment
(ii) Glacier Environment
(iii) Plateau Environment
(iv )Coastal Environment
(B) Biological Environment
The biological of the environment consists of:
(i) Plants (flora)
(ii) Animals (fauna).
The biotic environment is further divided into floral environment and faunal environment. All the organisms work to form their social groups and organizations at several levels. Thus, the social environment is formed. In this social environment the organisms work to derive matter from the physical environment for their sustenance and development.
This process gives birth to economic environment. Man claims to be most skilled and civilized of all the organisms. This is the reason why his social organisation is most systematic.
The three aspects of man, e.g. physical, social and economic, function in the biotic environment as under:
(i) The Physical Man
The ‘Physical Man’ is one of the organisms populations or biological community. He is in need of basic elements of the physical environment like habitat (space), air, water and food. Besides, like other biological populations, he releases wastes into the ecosystem.
(ii) The Social Man
The ‘Social Man’ performs the following functions:
(a) Establishing social institutions,
(b) Forming social organisations,
(c) Formulating laws, principles and policies,
(d) Taking steps to safeguard his existence, interest and social welfare.
(iii) The Economic Man
The economic man derives and utilises resources from the physical and biotic environment with his skills and technologies. The economic function makes the man an environment/ geomorphic process as he transports matter and energy from one component of the ecosystem to the other. There may be any following two situations:
(a) His exploitative functions may be in harmony with the natural environment. Such, functions do not necessarily involve change in the working of the ecosystem.
(b) These functions may exceed the critical limit. Consequently, the equilibrium of the environment/ecosystem is disturbed and a great number of environment and ecological problems crop up. These are detrimental to man him besides to whole population of human species in a given ecosystem.
Objective of studying environment
Objective of studying environment is to develop concern for our own environment which will lead us to act at our own live l to protect the environment we all live in. There are three reasons for studying the state of the environment.
The first is the need for information that clarifies modern environmental concepts like equitable use of natural resources, more sustainable life styles etc.
Second, there is a need to change the way in which we view our own environment, using practical approach based on observation and self learning.
Third, there is a need to create a concern for environment that will trigger pro-environmental action, including simple activities in daily life to protect it.
Classification of Environment
There are two types of environments:
1. Natural environment
2. Man made environment
Natural Environment:
The environment in its original form without the interference of human beings is known as natural environment. It operates through self regulating mechanism called homeostasis i.e, any change in the natural ecosystem brought about by natural processes is counter balanced by changes in other components of environment.
Man made or Anthropogenic Environment:
The environment changed or modified by the interference of human beings is called man made environment. Man is the most evolved creature on this earth. He is modifying the environment according to his requirements without bothering for its consequences. Increased technologies and population explosion are deteriorating the environment more and more.
The two major classifications of environment are :
(A) Physical Environment: External physical factors like Air, Water, and Land etc. This is also called the abiotic Environment.
(B) Living Environment: All living organisms around us viz. plants, animals, and microorganisms. This is also called the Biotic Environment.
Components of Environment
The conflict of words and thoughts between scientists of European origin and American origin has had its toll on the subject of environment. For the same topic, they may have different names and different philosophies. When we say, components of environment, the same problem appears.
Though air, water and land are the components of environment, the British and American scientists put in two different manners.
1.Components of Environment as per British literature
Here the components are classified in terms of biotic and abiotic based upon life. The biotic components are further listed as producers, consumers and decomposers and the abiotic components are classified as climatic(water, air) and edaphic(land). It is from this component system that the study of structure of ecosystem was evolved.
2.Components of Environment as per American literature
As per American literature, the components of environment are listed as
1. Hydrosphere(Water)
2. Atmosphere(Air)
3. Lithosphere(Land)
4. Biosphere(Flora/Fauna/Microbes)
5. Anthrosphere (man made things)
I understand your confusion on what to write if they ask you the components of environment. It is pretty simple logic. If they ask biotic and abiotic components, follow the British way. If they ask about the spheres of environment, be American. If they simply ask components of environment, show that you are an Indian by plainly writing down air, land and water.
Earth’s environment can be further subdivided into the following four segments:
(1) Lithosphere
(2) Hydrosphere
(3) Atmosphere
(4) Biosphere.
The Lithosphere
Lithosphere is the outer mantle of the solid earth. It consists of minerals occurring in the earth’s crusts and the soil e.g. minerals, organic matter, air and water.
The earth’s crust consisting of the soil and rocks is the lithosphere. The soil is made up of inorganic and organic matter and water. The main mineral constituents are compounds or mixtures derived from the elements of Si, Ca, K, Al, Fe, Mn, Ti, O etc. (Oxides, Silicates, and Carbonates).
The organic constituents are mainly polysaccharides, organo compounds of N, P and S. The organic constituents even though form only around 4% – 6% of the lithosphere, they are responsible for the fertility of the soil and hence its productivity.
The Hydrosphere
The Hydrosphere comprises all types of water resources oceans, seas, lakes, rivers, streams, reservoirs, polar icecaps, glaciers, and ground water.
(i) Nature 97% of the earth’s water supply is in the oceans,
(ii) About 2% of the water resources is locked in the polar icecaps and glaciers.
(iii)Only about 1% is available as fresh surface water-rivers, lakes streams, and
ground water fit to be used for human consumption and other uses.
This comprises all water resources both surface and ground water. The world’s water is found in oceans and seas, lakes and reservoirs, rivers and streams, glaciers and snow-caps in the Polar Regions in addition to ground water below the land areas. The distribution of water among these resources is as under-
Oceans and Seas 96–97 %
Glaciers and polar icecaps 2–3 %
Fresh water 1%
The water locked up in the Oceans and Seas are too salty and cannot be used directly for human consumption, domestic, agriculture or Industrial purposes. Only less than 1% of water resources are available for human exploitation. Water is considered to be a common compound with uncommon properties. These uncommon properties (e.g. anomalous expansion of water) are mainly responsible for supporting terrestrial and aquatic life on earth.
The Biosphere
Biosphere indicates the realm of living organisms and their interactions with environment, viz atmosphere, hydrosphere and lithosphere
The biosphere is a capsule encircling the earth’s surface wherein all the living things exist. This portion extends from 10000 m below sea level to 6000 m above sea level. Life forms do not exist outside this zone. The biosphere covers parts of other segments of the environment viz. Lithosphere, Hydrosphere and Atmosphere. Life sustaining resources like food, water and oxygen present in the biosphere are being withdrawn and waste products in increasing quantities are being dumped. The biosphere has been absorbing this and assimilating them. However the rate of waste dumping has gone beyond the assimilating capability of the biosphere and signals of this stress is becoming evident.
The Atmosphere
The atmosphere implies the protective blanket of gases, surrounding the earth .The atmosphere is composed of nitrogen and oxygen, besides, argon, carbon dioxide, and trace gases.
(a) It sustains life on the earth.
(b) It saves it from the hostile environment of outer space.
(c) It absorbs most of the cosmic rays from outer space and a major portion of the electromagnetic radiation from the sun.
(d) It transmits only here ultraviolet, visible, near infrared radiation (300 to 2500 nm) and radio waves. (0.14 to 40 m) while filtering out tissue,thus damaging ultraviolet waves below about 300 nm.
The atmosphere, which is a gaseous cover, protects the earth from cosmic radiations and provides life sustaining Oxygen, the macronutrient Nitrogen and Carbon dioxide needed for photosynthesis. The atmosphere screens the dangerous UV radiations from the sun and allows only radiations in the range of 300 nm – 2500 nm (near UV to near IR) and radio waves. The atmosphere plays a major role in maintaining the heat balance of the earth by absorbing the re-emitted radiation from the earth. In addition the atmosphere is the medium of carriage of water from the oceans to the land in the hydrological cycle.
The Structure of the Atmosphere
The atmosphere is broadly divided into four major zones viz. Troposphere, Stratosphere, Mesosphere and Thermosphere. Characteristics of these zones are pictorially represented below
The Troposphere
Troposphere is the layer of air nearest to the ground. Temperature decreases with height. The average temperature drops from 15ºC at sea level to –56.5ºC at 11,000 m above sea level. Mixing of the air molecules due to their constant movement (winds) keeps the composition of the gases more or less same throughout the troposphere. An exception to this is water vapour.
Most water vapour evaporates from the surface of the Earth and is found in the lower troposphere. Most of the weather occurs in the troposphere. Tropopause is the top of the troposphere, which is a transition layer between Troposphere and Stratosphere
The Stratosphere
Stratosphere is the layer of air above the troposphere where temperature increases with height. The average temperature rises to –2.5ºC at 50,000 m above sea level. Ozone is found in higher concentrations between 20 and 30 km above the surface. Hence sometimes this layer is referred to as the “ozone layer”. Ozone absorbs radiant energy from the sun and hence warmer temperatures are encountered in the stratosphere. Stratopause is the top of the stratosphere, which is a transition layer between Stratosphere and Mesosphere.
The Mesosphere
The Mesosphere is the layer of air above the stratosphere where temperature decreases with height. The average temperature decreases to –90°C at 90,000 m. This is the coldest layer of the atmosphere. Mesopause is the top of the mesosphere, which is a transition layer between Mesosphere and Thermosphere.
The Thermosphere
The Thermosphere is the layer of air above the mesosphere. The temperatures in the thermosphere increase with increasing height, but there are not many molecules in this layer. The air becomes less and less dense as we reach space.
Inter Relationship among Components
As discussed earlier matter (chemicals) as well as living beings on earth are distributed among the four major environmental components viz. Lithosphere, Hydrosphere, Atmosphere and Biosphere. While for the purpose of studying and understanding the Global Environment this division may be convenient, constant interaction by way of mass and energy transfer between these components and subcomponents is constantly taking place.
Every sphere has a flow of matter and energy to every other sphere, which is a two way linkage as shown in the figure. Such two-way interactions are also taking place within individual spheres. This indicates movement of matter/energy from one location to another without exiting the sphere. Environmental problems are hence not confined only to the component/system where they arise but spread to other components as well. A clear example of this is the Acid Rain. Emissions of air pollutants like oxides of Sulphur and Nitrogen are transported over long distances where they are brought down to land and fresh water bodies by rain, creating damage to crops, lands, fresh water resources including ground water, properties and aquatic life. Another classical example is the build up of gases like Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The emissions may be localized but the impact is massive and global in nature leading to global warming which has far reaching consequences in terms of both area and time
Reasons for Environmental Degradation
It is essential to make the public aware of the formidable consequences of the ‘Environmental Degradation’, if not retorted and reformative measures undertaken, would result in the extinction of life. We are facing various environmental challenges. It is essential to get the country acquainted with these challenges so that their acts may be eco-friendly. Some of these challenges are as under:
1. Growing Population
A population of over thousands of millions is growing at 2.11 per cent every year. Over 17 million people are added each year. It puts considerable pressure on its natural resources and reduces the gains of development. Hence, the greatest challenge before us is to limit the population growth. Although population control does automatically lead to development, yet the development leads to a decrease in population growth rates. For this development of the women is essential.
2. Poverty
India has often been described a rich land with poor people. The poverty and environmental degradation have a nexus between them. The vast majority of our people are directly dependent on the nature resources of the country for their basic needs of food, fuel shelter and fodder. About 40% of our people are still below the poverty line. Environment degradation has adversely affected the poor who depend upon the resources of their immediate surroundings. Thus, the challenge of poverty and the challenge environment degradation are two facets of the same challenge. The population growth is essentially a function of poverty. Because, to the very poor, every child is an earner and helper and global concerns have little relevance for him.
3. Agricultural Growth
The people must be acquainted with the methods to sustain and increase agricultural growth with damaging the environment. High yielding varieties have caused soil salinity and damage to physical structure of soil.
4. Need to Ground water
It is essential of rationalizing the use of groundwater. Factors like community wastes, industrial effluents and chemical fertilizers and pesticides have polluted our surface water and affected quality of the groundwater. It is essential to restore the water quality of our rivers and other water bodies as lakes is an important challenge. It so finding our suitable strategies for consecration of water, provision of safe drinking water and keeping water bodies clean which are difficult challenges is essential.
5. Development and Forests
Forests serve catchments for the rivers. With increasing demand of water, plan to harness the mighty river through large irrigation projects were made. Certainly, these would submerge forests; displace local people, damage flora and fauna. As such, the dams on the river Narmada, Bhagirathi and elsewhere have become areas of political and scientific debate.
Forests in India have been shrinking for several centuries owing to pressures of agriculture and other uses. Vast areas that were once green lands, today are wastelands.
These areas are to be brought back under vegetative cover. The tribal communities inhabiting forests respects the trees and birds and animal that gives them sustenance. We must recognise the role of these people in restoring and conserving forests. The modern knowledge and skills of the forest department should be integrated with the traditional knowledge and experience of the local communities. The strategies for the joint management of forests should be evolved in a well planned way.
6. Degradation of Land
At present out of the total 329 mha of land, only 266 mha possess any potential for production. Of this, 143 mha is agricultural land nearly and 85 suffers from varying degrees of soil degradation. Of the remaining 123 mha, 40 are completely unproductive. The remaining 83 mha is classified as forest land, of which over half is denuded to various degrees. Nearly 406 million head of livestock have to be supported on 13 mha, or less than 4 per cent of the land classified as pasture land, most of which is overgrazed. Thus, our of 226 mha, about 175 mha or 66 per cent is degraded to varying degrees. Water and wind erosion causes further degradation of almost 150 mha This degradation is to be avoided.
7. Reorientation of Institutions
The people should be roused to orient institutions, attitudes and infrastructures, to suit conditions and needs today. The change has to be brought in keeping in view India’s traditions for resources use managements and education etc. Change should be brought in education, in attitudes, in administrative procedures and in institutions. Because it affects way people view technology resources and development.
8. Reduction of Genetic Diversity
Proper measures to conserve genetic diversity need to be taken. At present most wild genetic stocks have been disappearing from nature. Wilding including the Asiatic Lion are facing problem of loss of genetic diversity. The protected areas network like sanctuaries, national parks, biosphere reserves are isolating populations. So, they are decreasing changes of one group breeding with another. Remedial steps are to be taken to check decreasing genetic diversity.
9. Evil Consequences of Urbanisation
Nearly 27 per cent Indians live in urban areas. Urbanisation and industrialisation has given birth to a great number of environmental problems that need urgent attention. Over 30 percent of urban Indians live in slums. Out of India’s 3,245 towns and cities, only 21 have partial or full sewerage and treatment facilities. Hence, coping with rapid urbanization is a major challenge.
10. Air and water Population
Majority of our industrial plants are using outdated and population technologies and makeshift facilities devoid of any provision of treating their wastes. A great number of cities and industrial areas that have been identified as the worst in terms of air and water pollution. Acts are enforced in the country, but their implement is not so easy. The reason is their implementation needs great resources, technical expertise, political and social will. Again the people are to be made aware of these rules. Their support is indispensable to implement these rules.
Environmental Issues of Global Concern
The main environmental issues today are wide ranging and all-encompassing are deforestation, biodiversity, soil erosion, climate change, and pesticide build-up, industrial and municipal pollution. All these problems can be categorized into three main issues:
1. Population explosion
2. Land degradation
3. Environmental pollution
4. Industrialization, agriculture/fertilizer/pesticide/green house gases, air pollution, acid rain, ozone depletion, green house effect, water pollution and deforestation.
Environmental problems in India can be put into three classes:
Poverty, problems arising as negative effects of the very process of development and problems arising from improper implementation of the directives and laws of environmental protection values of nature. This can be discussed under three categories :
i) Productive value,
ii) Aesthetic value or recreational value and
iii) Option value
Productive value of nature:
Worlds’ species contain an incredible and unaccountable number of complex chemicals. These are raw materials used for developing new medicines and industrial products. When we permit the destruction of a forest, wet land or other natural area and do not protest about it, future generations are being denied the use of these valuable resources. Thus the urgent need to protect all living species is a concept that we need to understand and act upon. There is close link between agriculture and the forest, which illustrates its productive value. For crops to be successful, the flowers of fruit trees and vegetables must be pollinated by insects and birds. Their life cycle frequently require intact forests.
Aesthetic/ Recreational value of nature:
Nature encompasses every aspect of living (biodiversity: flora and fauna) and non- living (sea, desert) part of the earth and it enlivens our existence on earth. This is created by developing national parks and wildlife sanctuaries in relatively undisturbed areas. In an Urban setting, there will be green spaces and gardens – psychological and physical health of city dwellers and provides aesthetic value and visual appeal. It also gives access to certain amount of peace. Nature tourism or wildlife tourism or eco tourism is a pleasurable experience and also creates a deep respect and love for nature.
The Option value of nature:
Nature provides us with various options on how we utilize its goods and services. This is its option value. We can use up goods and services greedily and destroy its integrity and long term values or we can use its resources sustainably and reduce our impact on environment. The option value allows us to use its resources sustainable and preserve its goods and services for the future. “The earth provides enough to satisfiy every persons need but not every persons greed” is the vision of Mahatma Gandhiji.
Need for public awareness:
As the earth’s natural resources are rapidly dwindling and our environment is being increasingly degraded by human activities, it is evident that something needs to be done.
The following measures may help for the environmental awareness.
1. Join a group to study nature, such as WWF-1 or BNHS or another environmental group
2. Begin reading news paper articles and periodicals like Down to Earth, WWF-1 News letter, BNHS, Hornbill, Sanctuary magazine etc which will tell you more about our current environmental issues. There are also several environmental websites.
3. Lobby for conserving resources by taking up the cause of environmental issues during discussions with friends and relatives. Practice and promote issues such as saving paper, saving water, reducing use of plastic, practicing the 3Rs principle of reduce, reuse, recycle and proper waste disposal.
4. Join local movements that support activities like saving trees in your area, go on nature treks, recycle waste, buy environmentally friendly products.
5. Practice and promote good civic sense and hygiene such as enforcing no spitting or tobacco chewing, no throwing garbage on the road, no smoking in public places, no urinating or defecating in public places.
6. Take part in events organized on World Environment Day, Wildlife Week etc.
7. Visit a National Park or Sanctuary or spend time in whatever natural habitat you have near your home.
Man and the Environment
Today, man is the most dominant animal in the biosphere. With the accumulation of artifacts and machines man has acquired the capacity to change the environment for his needs. Human needs and greed coupled with short-sightedness have disturbed the delicate ecological balance by depleting and degrading the vital life supporting systems.
Human ingenuity has helped man to tackle many complex problems. In the process man has developed such devices and synthesized such substances, indiscriminate use of which can be hazardous to the entire biotic community on this planet. Some of bringing about enormous damage to the biosphere as whole are:
Hazardous Chemicals:
These include harmful and poisonous chemicals which persist in the environment for long durations and damage the environment and living beings. The discovery of DDT for example was hailed as a big achievement for pest control technology and by the time its effects on non-target organisms, its persistence came to light few years later enormous quantities of the chemicals were introduced into the environment into the environment. A number of pesticides in common use these days are potentially damaging agents. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) which are inert, non-toxic chemicals and have been used since many years in refrigerators, air conditioners, spray cans, plastic foams, Solvents etc.
Manmade radioactive substances pose another threat to the mankind. We have seen mankind. We have seen many instances when accidental discharge of radioactive materials caused us much problems. Radioactive isotopes also accumulate within a biological system are magnified and persist in the environment or the biosphere for long durations as many of them have a very long half-life.
Misuse of Biotechnology:
Among the latest weapons of war are certain bacteria, viruses, toxic chemicals produced by fungi and bacteria and bio-regulators. Bacillus anthracites, Brucella and toxin from clostridium botulinum etc, have become some of the powerful instruments of biological welfare.Mass production of many of these agents of biological warfare is simple, inexpensive and their use convenient but the results are highly unpredictable with ever-growing human knowledge these uncertainties shall soon be resolved.
Another dimension to all this has been added by rapid studies in genetic engineering. He has been creating new combinations, strains varieties and even species. He can introduce new genes into an organism. He is capable of repairing genetic faults. He has tamed genetics to produce progenies tailored to suit his own specifications
The Nuclear Dilemma:
Science and technology has provided tremendous destructive powers to the human race. The nuclear bomb which terminated the second world war has grown, so much powerful that a third world war could mean total annihilation of our living world.
A collective nuclear strike of 100 MT targeted on strategic location around the world shall bring a long-long night. A thick mantle of dust smoke and soot shall cover the globe through which no solar radiations shall penetrate. Photosynthesis shall stop, temperatures shall drop to sub-zero levels. Changes in perception patterns and chemical changes of atmosphere all around the globe shall drastically affect the entire life on this planet. The protective ozone umbrella shall disappear. These near the point of IMT explosion could be subjected to a temperature of about 10,000,000oc with clearing of atmosphere the sun will Ultra-Violet rays reaching right up to the surface of the earth. This will further extinguish whatever little traces of life shall be left on this planet after the episode. Radioactive materials produced by the explosion shall continue to emit radiations for thousands of years to come.
In a natural state, the earth’s life forms live in equilibrium with their environment. Primitive humans used natural resources to satisfy their basic needs of air, water, food and shelter. These natural and unprocessed resources were readily available in the biosphere and the resist uses produced by the use of these resources were generally compatible with or easily assimilated by the earth. Even when use of fire became common the relatively small amounts of smoke generated were easily and rapidly dispersed and assimilated by the atmosphere. Early human populations left behind very few things which were not readily broken down and absorbed by the environment. As these things were so few in quantity, no significant impact was felt on the environment.
With the dawn of the industrial revolution, humans’ were better able than ever to satisfy their needs for air, water, food and shelter. So, human turned their attention to other needs beyond those associated with survival. Automobiles household appliances, processed foods, and beverages etc have new become so popular as to seem necessities and meeting these acquired needs become a major thrust of Modern industrial society. Man uses much more material and energy war than any other species on the earth. Human needs and greed’s coupled with shortsightedness have disturbed the delicate ecological balance. Not only this, humans are depleting and degrading the vital life supporting systems including air, water and land which belong to the entire living world.
The fast development of Science and technology which resulted in the establishment of a good number of variety of industries and the humanity for sophisticated living are contributing significantly for the degradation of the environment. If we close our eyes and let the trend continue in the same manner, man on this globe may become so rare that he may require a sanctuary for his protection.
If all the problems man is facing today, the most intriguing is “Air Pollution”. The air be breathes goes into direct contact with the most sensitive organs of human body – the respiratory tract and the lungs. Air pollutants one way or the other way have already damaged the art treasurer and cultural heritage of man. .
Water is the most ubiquitous material in nature and is most vital and fascinating of all gods creations! These days water pollutions is assuming menacing proportions. Polluted drinking water claims more lives than all forms of violence, including war a UN report has said, high lighting, the need for clean water. It is estimated that close to 90% of diarrhoea cases, killing some 2.0 million people every year, is caused by unsafe drinking water and poor hygiene.
Forests are the beds on which the humanity rests but another major activity of man of concern is destruction of forests. Every year a large amount of tropical forests are cleared for farming, settlement, mining, plantation, industry, timber and fuel.
Burning fossil fuels and cutting down and burning forests raise the concentration of Co2 and other heat trapping gases in the lower atmosphere within the next 40-50 years Earths climate may become warm enough to disrupt agricultural productivity, alter water distribution and drive countless species to extinction.
Such behaviour is unsustainable, which bleeds our Mother Earth. So, the need of the time is to create a sustainable society that manages its economy and population size without doing irresponsible environmental harm.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Ozone Depletion -The degradation of the Earth`s protective layer

Dr. V.K.Maheshwari, M.A. (Socio, Phil) B.Sc. M. Ed, Ph.D. Former Principal, K.L.D.A.V.(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

Mrs Sudha Rani Maheshwari, M.Sc (Zoology), B.Ed. Former Principal. A.K.P.I.College, Roorkee, India

 

“The size of this year’s ozone hole is approaching an all-time high, but it will probably not break any records.”  Geir Braathen

Ozone is a colorless gas found in the upper atmosphere of the Earth. It is formed when oxygen molecules absorb ultraviolet photons, and undergo a chemical reaction known as photo dissociation or photolysis. In this process, a single molecule of oxygen breaks down into two oxygen atoms. The free oxygen atom (O), then combines with an oxygen molecule (O2), and forms a molecule of ozone (O3). The ozone is located between 4 and 10 miles above the surface of the Earth (lower near the poles), with the highest ozone concentrations in a region that is variously called the lower stratosphere, the tropopause, or simply the “ozone layer”.
Ozone itself is a diatomic molecule, composed of three oxygen atoms that bonded, unlike the oxygen we breathe, which are diatomic molecules, meaning two oxygen atoms. The “ozone layer” contains more than 90% of the earth’s ozone. Ozone is a corrosive, light blue gas with a smell something like burning electrical wiring. The atmosphere at this altitude is still about 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen, and the peak ozone concentration is about 9 pm (or 0.0009%). Other things (water vapour, carbon dioxide, argon, and so on) are present there in small concentrations too.

The ozone molecules, in turn absorb ultraviolet rays between 310 to 200 nm (nanometers) wavelength, and thereby prevent these harmful radiations from entering the Earth’s atmosphere. The process of absorption of harmful radiation occurs when ozone molecules split up into a molecule of oxygen, and an oxygen atom. The oxygen atom (O), again combines with the oxygen molecule (O2) to regenerate an ozone (O3) molecule. Thus, the total amount of ozone is maintained by this continuous process of destruction, and regeneration.

Meaning of Ozone Depletion

The ozone layer is a thin layer of ozone that protects the earth from dangerous ultraviolet light. Destruction of the stratospheric ozone layer which shields the earth from ultraviolet radiation harmful to life. This destruction of ozone is caused by the breakdown of certain chlorine and/or bromine containing compounds (chlorofluorocarbons or halogens), which break down when they reach the stratosphere and then catalytically destroy ozone molecules.

If you took all the ozone in an entire column from the ground to infinity, and compressed it to STP (standard temperature and pressure, or 0°C at 1 atmosphere pressure) it would be a layer about 3 mm thick. There is less than 1/3 as much in the Antarctic “ozone hole” when it is winter there

The ozone layer is a region high in the stratosphere, containing ozone (a form of oxygen) that filters out most of the Sun’s dangerous ultraviolet rays (UV-B). This UV-B could otherwise be absorbed by the DNA in all surface dwelling life on Earth.

Destruction of the stratospheric ozone layer which shields the earth from ultraviolet radiation harmful to life. This destruction of ozone is caused by the breakdown of certain chlorine and/or bromine containing compounds (chlorofluorocarbons or halons), which break down when they reach the stratosphere

The degradation of the Earth`s protective layer of ozone in the high atmosphere by some industrial and domestic gases.

Ozone depletion describes two distinct but related phenomena observed since the late 1970s : a steady decline of about 4% per decade in the total volume of ozone in Earth`s stratosphere (the ozone layer), and a much larger springtime decrease in stratospheric ozone over Earth`s polar regions.

 

There are two different types of ozone depletion, both are very similar. The first one has been a slow, but steady ozone depletion of 4% per decade of the Earth’s stratosphere(ozone layer). This has been happening constantly since the 1970′s. The other is a much larger, although seasonal loss of ozone over the polar regions. This yearly occurrence is called the ozone hole. There are many causes for ozone depletion, but the most important process in both trends is catalytic destruction of ozone by atomic chlorine and bromine. Both come from the breaking down of chloroflourocarbons  by photons in the atmosphere.

 

Meaning of Ozone Hole

 

An ozone hole also periodically forms, since ozone is unstable. The word “hole” is somewhat misleading. This is actually a diminished concentration of ozone due to the lack of sunlight and not a complete absence. An ozone hole forms over a pole, then later closes, once each year at the pole that is not receiving UV-C light from the Sun. The southern polar hole is larger than the northern polar hole, due to the polarity of Earth’s magnetic field. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) make the hole larger, last longer, and contain less ozone, which is only an indication of the general “health” of the ozone layer. The hole itself forms in areas that are receiving no UV-B from the Sun either, so there are no life forms at risk from our Sun directly “beneath the hole,” but every surface organism is at risk from a thinned ozone layer.

Effect of Ozone Layer Depletion

A .Effects on Human and Animal Health

Increased penetration of solar UV-B radiation is likely to have profound impact on human health with potential risks of eye diseases, skin cancer and infectious diseases . UV radiation is known to damage the cornea and lens of the eye. Chronic exposure to UV-B could lead to cataract of the cortical and posterior subcapsular forms. UV-B radiation can adversely affect the immune system causing a number of infectious diseases. In light skinned human populations, it is likely to develop nonmelanoma skin cancer (NMSC). Experiments on animals show that UV exposure decreases the immune response to skin cancers, infectious agents and other antigens

B. Effects on Terrestrial Plants

It is a known fact that the physiological and developmental processes of plants are affected by UV-B radiation. Scientists believe that an increase in UV-B levels would necessitate using more UV-B tolerant cultivar and breeding new tolerant ones in agriculture. In forests and grasslands increased UV-B radiation is likely to result in changes in species composition (mutation) thus altering the bio-diversity in different ecosystems . UV-B could also affect the plant community indirectly resulting in changes in plant form, secondary metabolism, etc. These changes can have important implications for plant competitive balance, plant pathogens and bio-geochemical cycles.

C. Effects on Aquatic Ecosystems

While more than 30 percent of the world’s animal protein for human consumption comes from the sea alone, it is feared that increased levels of UV exposure can have adverse impacts on the productivity of aquatic systems. High levels of exposure in tropics and subtropics may affect the distribution of phytoplanktons which form the foundation of aquatic food webs. Reportedly a recent study has indicated 6-12 percent reduction in phytoplankton production in the marginal ice zone due to increases in UV-B. UV-B can also cause damage to early development stages of fish, shrimp, crab, amphibians and other animals, the most severe effects being decreased reproductive capacity and impaired larval development.

D. Effects on Amphibians
Ozone depletion is listed as one of the causes for the declining numbers of amphibian species. Ozone depletion affects many species of amphibians at every stage of their life cycle. Some of the effects are mentioned below.

  • Hampers growth and development in larvae
  • Changes behaviour and habits
  • Causes deformities in some species
  • Decreases immunity. Some species have become more vulnerable to diseases and death
  • Retinal damage and blindness in some species

E. Effects on Marine Ecosystems
In particular, plankton (phytoplankton and bacterioplankton) are threatened by increased UV radiation. Marine phytoplankton play a fundamental role in both the food chain as well as the oceanic carbon cycle. Plankton plays an important role in converting atmospheric carbon dioxide into oxygen. Ultraviolet rays can influence the survival rates of these microscopic organisms, by affecting their orientation and mobility. This eventually disturbs and affects the entire ecosystem.

 

F. Effects on Bio-geo-chemical Cycles

Increased solar UV radiation could affect terrestrial and aquatic bio-geo-chemical cycles thus altering both sources and sinks of greenhouse and important trace gases, e.g. carbon dioxide (CO2), carbon monoxide (CO), carbonyl sulphide (COS), etc. These changes would contribute to biosphere-atmosphere feedbacks responsible for the atmosphere build-up of these gases. Other effects of increased UV-B radiation include: changes in the production and decomposition of plant matter; reduction of primary production changes in the uptake and release of important atmospheric gases; reduction of bacterioplankton growth in the upper ocean; increased degradation of aquatic dissolved organic matter (DOM), etc. Aquatic nitrogen cycling can be affected by enhanced UV-B through inhibition of nitrifying bacteria and photodecomposition of simple inorganic species such as nitrate. The marine sulphur cycle may also be affected resulting in possible changes in the sea-to-air emissions of COS and dimethylsulfied (DMS), two gases that are degraded to sulphate aerosols in the stratosphere and troposphere, respectively.

G. Effects on Air Quality

Reduction of stratospheric ozone and increased penetration of UV-B radiation result in higher photo dissociation rates of key trace gases that control the chemical reactivity of the troposphere. This can increase both production and destruction of ozone and related oxidants such as hydrogen peroxide which are known to have adverse effects on human health, terrestrial plants and outdoor materials. Changes in the atmospheric concentrations of the hydroxyl radical (OH) may change the atmospheric lifetimes of important gases such as methane and substitutes of chlorofluoro carbons (CFCs). Increased troposphere reactivity could also lead to increased production of particulates such as cloud condensation nuclei from the oxidation and subsequent nucleation of sulphur of both anthropogenic and natural origin (e.g. COS and DMS).

H. Effects on Materials

An increased level of solar UV radiation is known to have adverse effects on synthetic polymers, naturally occurring biopolymers and some other materials of commercial interest. UV-B radiation accelerates the photo degradation rates of these materials thus limiting their lifetimes. Typical damages range from discoloration to loss of mechanical integrity. Such a situation would eventually demand substitution of the affected materials by more photo stable plastics and other materials in future. The chlorine radicals thus produced can undergo complex chemical reaction producing chlorine monoxide which can attack an ozone molecule converting it into oxygen and in the process regenerating the chlorine atom again. Thus the ozone destroying effect is catalytic and a small amount of CFC would be destroying large number of ozone molecules

I. Effects on Climate Change

Ozone depletion and climate change are linked in a number of ways, but ozone depletion is not a major cause of climate change. Atmospheric ozone has two effects on the temperature balance of the Earth. It absorbs solar ultraviolet radiation, which heats the stratosphere. It also absorbs infrared radiation emitted by the Earth’s surface, effectively trapping heat in the troposphere. Therefore, the climate impact of changes in ozone concentrations varies with the altitude at which these ozone changes occur. The major ozone losses that have been observed in the lower stratosphere due to the human-produced chlorine- and bromine-containing gases have a cooling effect on the Earth’s surface. On the other hand, the ozone increases that are estimated to have occurred in the troposphere because of surface-pollution gases have a warming effect on the Earth’s surface, thereby contributing to the “greenhouse” effect. In comparison to the effects of changes in other atmospheric gases, the effects of both of these ozone changes are difficult to calculate accurately.

J. Effects on Ultraviolet Radiation

The depletion of the ozone layer leads, on the average, to an increase in ground-level ultraviolet radiation, because ozone is an effective absorber of ultra-violet radiation. The Sun emits radiation over a wide range of energies, with about 2% in the form of high-energy, ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Some of this UV radiation (UV-B) is especially effective in causing damage to living beings, the largest decreases in ozone during the past 15 years have been observed over Antarctica, especially during each September and October when the ozone hole forms.In areas where smaller ozone depletion has been observed, UV-B increases are more difficult to detect. In particular, detection of trends in UV-B radiation associated with ozone decreases can be further complicated by changes in cloudiness, by local pollution, and by difficulties in keeping the detection instrument in precisely the same condition over many years.

 

International Remedial Actions

Ozone was discovered by C.F. Schonbein  in 1840. In the lower atmosphere O3 is a Pollutant and is produced by Photochemical reactions involving sunlight, Nitrogen Oxides, Hydrocarbons and diatomic oxygen in the stratosphere, O3 provides essential shield against damaging Ultra violet radiation. Approximately 90% of the Ozone in the atmosphere is found in the stratosphere, where peak concentrations are about 300 PPb. The ozone layer in the Stratosphere is often called the ozone shield, because it absorbs most Ultra Violet radiation that is potentially damaging to life. The Ozone layer was discovered in 1913 by the French Physicist Charles Fabry and Henry Buisson. its  properties were explored in detail by the British meteorologist GMB Dobson, who developed a simple spectrophotometer (the dosimeter) that could be used to measure Spectrophotometer ozone from the ground.

The first international action to focus attention on the dangers of ozone depletion in the stratosphere and its dangerous consequences in the long run on life on earth was focused in 1977 when in a meeting of 32 countries in Washington D.C. a World plan on action on Ozone layer with UNEP as the coordinator was adopted.

Montreal Protocol

As experts began their investigation, data piled up and in 1985 in an article published in the prestigious science journal, “Nature” by Dr. Farman pointed out that although there is overall depletion of the ozone layer all over the world, the most severe depletion had taken place over the Antarctica. This is what is famously called as “the Antarctica Ozone hole”. His findings were confirmed by Satellite observations and offered the first proof of severe ozone depletion and stirred the scientific community to take urgent remedial actions in an international convention held in Vienna on March 22, 1985. This resulted in an international agreement in 1987 on specific measures to be taken in the form of an international treaty known as the Montreal Protocol on Substances That Deplete the Ozone Layer. Under this Protocol the first concrete step to save the Ozone layer was taken by immediately agreeing to completely phase out chlorofluorocarbons (CFC), Halogens,  Carbon tetrachloride (CTC) and Methyl chloroform (MCF) as per a given schedule

In 1985 the Vienna Convention established mechanisms for international co-operation in research into the ozone layer and the effects of ozone depleting chemicals (ODCs). 1985 also marked the first discovery of the Antarctic ozone hole.

The treaty provides a time table on which the production of those substances must be phased out and eventually eliminated.

Ozone depleting substances Developed Countries Developing Countries
CFC’s Phased out end of 1995 Total Phase out by 2010
Halogens’ Phased out end of 1993 Total phase out by 2010
Carbon tetrachloride Phased out end of 1995 Total phase out by 2015
Methyl Chloroform Phased out end of 1995 Total phase out by 2015
HCFCs Total phase out by 2030 Total phase out by 2015
Methyl bromide Total phase out by 2005 Total phase out by 2015

 

 

On the basis of the Vienna Convention, the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer was negotiated and signed by 24 countries and by the European Economic Community in September 1987. The Protocol called for the Parties to phase down the use of CFCs, halons and other man-made ODCs. The Montreal Protocol represented a landmark in the international environmentalist movement. For the first time whole countries were legally bound to reducing and eventually phasing out altogether the use of CFCs and other ODCs. Failure to comply was accompanied by stiff penalties. The original Protocol aimed to decrease the use of chemical compounds destructive to ozone in the stratosphere by 50% by the year 1999. The

Protocol was supplemented by agreements made in London in 1990 and in Copenhagen in 1992, where the same countries promised to stop using CFCs and most of the other chemical compounds destructive to ozone by the end of 1995.

Fortunately, it has been fairly easy to develop and introduce compounds and methods to replace CFC compounds. In order to deal with the special difficulties experienced by developing countries it was agreed that they would be given an extended period of grace, so long as their use of CFCs did not grow significantly. China and India, for example, are strongly increasing the use of air conditioning and cooling devices. Using CFC compounds in these devices would be cheaper than using replacement compounds harmless to ozone. An international fund was therefore established to help these countries introduce new and more environmentally friendly technologies and chemicals. The depletion of the ozone layer is a worldwide problem which does not respect the frontiers between different countries. It can only be affected through determined international co-operation.

In consequence, the Montreal Protocol has often been called the most successful international environment agreement to date.

Ozone depletion over India

With so much worry about the rapid ozone depletion taking place in various parts of the earth, Indian scientists are closely monitoring the ozone layer over India for possible depletion trends. Opinions are many and varied. According to S K Srivastava, head of the National Ozone Centre in New Delhi, there is no trend to show total ozone depletion over India. V.Thaphyal and S M Kulshresta of the Indian Meteorological Department also point out that for the period 1956 to 1986 “ozone measurements exhibit year to year variability, but do not show any increasing or decreasing trend over India.”

However, former director of the National Ozone Centre, K Chatterji, now with Development Alternatives, warns that there is no case for complacency. He asserts that his calculations exhibit an ozone depletion trend in the upper, layers of the stratosphere over New Delhi and Pune from 1980 to 1983 in the month of October when the Antarctic ozone hole is at its maximum. Since India already receives high doses of ultraviolet (UV-B) radiation, and is at the threshold go to speak, effects of ozone layer depletion could he far more disastrous in India. A P Mitra, former director general of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, clarifies that while there is no trend in the total ozone value, there is some evidence of ozone depletion at higher altitudes – at about 30 to 40 km – even over the tropics. He argues, however, that there is insufficient data and that the depletion may be due to solar cycles and other natural phenomena.

However, the effects of CFCs and belong cannot be ruled out. Total column ozone data has been recorded over India for a long time. A network of stations using Dobson spectrophotometers to mea- sure total ozone, some six times a day, covers Srinagar, New Delhi, Varanasi, Ahmadabad, Pone and Kodaikanal. Ozone profiles are also regularly using balloons. Ozone levels are the lowest during November and December and the highest in summer. Across the country, variations do exist. In Kodaikanal, the total ozone is 240 to 280 Dobson units (DU), in New Delhi 270 to 320 DU and in Srinagar 290 to 360 DU. One Dobson unit is the equivalent of 0.01 mm of compressed gas at a pressure of 760 rare mercury and 0°C.B. N. Srivastava of the National Physical Laboratory, who been working on incident UVradiation levels, says that during summer, at noon, the UV-B radiation with a wavelength of 290 manometer (nm) is equivalent to levels attained in the Antarctica during the ozone hole period. He warns that even a slight depletion of the ozone layer over India may lead to large percentage changes in UV-B radiation over the country. According to eminent skin specialists in New Delhi, the incidence of skin cancer in India is low, but they admit that the surveys conducted to identify any trends are inadequate. Controlled studies to observe the effects of changing UV- B radiation concentrations on crops are on, they said. However no field surveys have been done in the country as yet.

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Pollution in Environment

Dr. V.K.Maheshwari, M.A. (Socio, Phil) B.Sc. M. Ed, Ph.D. Former Principal, K.L.D.A.V.(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

Mrs Sudha Rani Maheshwari, M.Sc (Zoology), B.Ed. Former Principal.A.K.P.I.College, Roorkee, India

 

Pollution is derived from Latin word ‘polluere’ which means ‘to contaminate’ any feature of environment. Pollution is the effect of undesirable changes in our surroundings that have harmful effects on plants, animals and human beings. This occurs only when short term economic gains are made at the cost of long term ecological benefits of humanity. Environmental pollution is defined as an undesirable change in the physical, chemical and biological characteristics of any component of the environment (water, soil, air) that can cause harmful effect on various forms of life and property.

Pollution can be primary (effects immediately on release to the environment) or secondary (product of interaction after release with moisture, sunlight, other pollutants etc.) pollution may be local, regional, trans boundary or global.  The agent which causes pollution is called pollutant.

 

Classification of Pollution

Pollutants can be classified as:

1. Degradable or non persistent pollutants: These can be rapidly broken by natural processes.

2. Slowly degradable or persistent pollutants: These remain in the environment for many years in an unchanged condition and take decades or longer to degrade. Example,

3. Non degradable pollutants: These cannot be degraded by natural processes.

Air Pollution

Air pollution is a major problem since very long.

Air pollution occurs due to the presence of undesirable solid or gaseous particles in the air in quantities that are harmful to human health and environment. It can be defined as presence of foreign matter either gaseous or particulate or combination of both in the air which is detrimental to the health and welfare of human beings.

Primary air Pollutants

Pollutants that are emitted directly from identifiable sources are produced by natural events can be in the form of particulate matter or gaseous form. These are called primary pollutants. There are five primary pollutants that contribute to air pollution. These are carbon oxides  , Nitrogen oxides, sulphur oxides, volatile organic compounds and suspended particulate matter.

Secondary air pollutants

The pollutants that are produced in the atmosphere, when certain chemical reactions take place among the primary pollutants and with others in the atmosphere are called secondary air pollutants.

Particulates are small pieces of solid material. Particulate matter can be:

1) Natural such as dust, seeds, spores, pollen grains, algae fungi, bacteria and viruses

2) Anthropogenic such as mineral dust, cement, asbestos dust, fibers, metal dust, fly ash

smoke particles form fires etc.

3) The artificial generates from human activities and includes sources such as fuel burning, refuge burning, transportation, construction of buildings, chemical factories, metallurgical factories and, vehicles.

Effects of Air Pollution:

  1. Effects on human health

The various health effects are as under:

i) Eye irritation can be caused by many air pollutants such as NOx, O3 , PAN, Smog etc

ii) Nose and Throat irritation can be caused by SO2 ,NOx, insecticides, Pesticides etc.

iii) Gaseous Pollutants like H2S, SO2, NO2 and hydrocarbons can cause Adour nuisance even at low concentration.

iv) A variety of particulates, particularly pollens can initiate asthmatic attacks.

v)                   High concentrations of SO2, NO2, SPM and photochemical Smog can aggravate chronic pulmonary diseases like bronchitis and asthma.

vi)                 CO, combines with hemoglobin in the blood an consequently stress on those suffering from cardiovascular and pulmonary disease. Similarly nitric oxide can react with hemoglobin and reduce the oxygen carrying capacity of the blood.

vii)               Hydrogen fluoride can cause fluorosis and mottling of teeth.

viii)             Dust Particles can cause dust specific respiratory diseases, such as siliceous (associated with silica dust) asbestosis (associated with asbestosis dust) etc.

ix)                 Particulates cause carcinogenic effects, accumulate in lungs and interfere with ability of lungs to exchange gases. Prolong exposure causes lung cancer and asthma.

 

Effects on plants:

Gaseous pollutants enter the leaf pores and damage the leaves of crop plants, interfere with photosynthesis and plants growth and reduces nutrient uptake .The effect of some of the important air pollutants on plants are given in table.

Effects of Air pollutants on Plant

S.No Pollutants Effects on Plants
01 SO2 Bleaching of Leaves, Necrosis (killing of tissues)
02 O3 Premature aging, suppressed growth, necrosis
03 NO2 Suppressed growth bleaching
04 Fluorides Necrosis at leaf tip
05 Ethylene Leaf abscissa (dropping of leaves), leaf epinasty
06 PAN Suppressed growth, silvering of lower leaf surface.

 

Effect of Air Pollution on Animals:

The process by which the animals get poisoned is entirely different from that by which human beings exposed to air pollutants are poisoned. In case of animals it is a two step process.

i)                    accumulation of air pollutants in the vegetation and forage; and

ii)                  Subsequent poisoning of the animals, when they eat the contaminated vegetation/forage.

 

The Pollutants mainly responsible for most livestock damage are: -

Fluorine: -Of all the form animals, cattle and sheep are the most susceptible to fluoride toxicity. Its effects are lack of appetite, rapid loss of weight, lameness. Periodic diarrhoea, muscular weakness, wearing of teeth, and death.

Lead: – Chronic lead poisoning has been observed frequently in animals that have been grazing near smelters and lead mines. It causes paralysis and difficulty in breathing in case of acute lead poisoning, the onset is sudden and the course is relatively short. There is complete loss of appetite, paralysis and diarrhoea.

Arsenic: – In acute cases, it can cause serve salivation, thirst, vomiting, irregular pulse and respiration, abnormal body temperatures and death in few hours. Chronic arsenic poisoning cause cough, diarrhoea, anaemia, absorption, paralysis and death.

Economic Effect of Air Pollution

Air pollution damage to property /material is very important economic aspect of pollution and it covers a wide range.

i) Corrosion: – Air pollution damages materials chiefly by corrosion of metals.

ii) Damage to building materials: – The acid deposition reacts with lime stone, Marble and other building materials to cause deterioration and disfigured the building materials.

iii) Damage to Paints and protective Covering: – Pollutants like SO2, O3 , H2S and aerosols damage protective coating and paints of the surface.

iv) Damage of textile dyes and textile fibres: – The fading of textile dyes and deterioration of natural and synthetic textile fibres is caused by SO2, NO2 and O3.

v) Damage to Objects of Art and Architecture: – Acid rains causes’ intangible loss to objects of art and architecture throughout the world .Air Pollution also causes damage to rubber, leather and paper, glass and ceramics etc.

Control of Air Pollution

The need for strict monitoring and control of air pollutants is very essential to reduce pollutant concentrations to levels considered safe for life and property.The following methods are most effective for dealing with the control of air pollution.

Control at the Source: – Industries make a major contribution towards causing air pollution. Formation of pollutants can be prevented and their emission can be minimized at the source itself. These source correction methods are: -

1) Substitution of Raw Materials: – If the use of Particular raw materials results in air pollution, then it should be substituted by another purer grade raw material which reduces the formation of pollutants .

2) Process Modification: – The existing process may be changed by using modified techniques to control emission at source e.g if coal is washed before pulverization, fly -ash emissions are considerably reduced.

3) Modification of Existing Equipments: –  Smoke, Co and fumes can be reduced if open hearth Furnaces are replaced with controlled basic oxygen furnaces or electric furnaces

4) Maintenance of Equipments: – An appreciable amount of pollution is caused due to poor maintenance of the equipments. Emission of pollutants can be minimized by a routine check up.

2) Dilution of pollutants in air: – Dilution of the contaminants in the atmosphere is another approach to the control of air pollution.

3) Vegetation: – Plants contribute towards controlling air pollution by utilizing CO2 and releasing O2 in the process of photosynthesis.

4) Pollution Control Equipment: – Pollution Control equipments are generally classified into two types.

A. Control devices for particulate contaminants

a) Gravitational setting chamber

b) Cyclone separators

c) Fabric Filters

d) Electrostatic precipitators

e) Wet collectors

B. Control devices for gaseous contaminants

a) Absorption method

b) Absorption method

c) Combustion method

d) Combustion method

Soil Pollution

Soil pollution is the introduction of substances, biological organisms, or energy into the soil, resulting in a change of the soil quality, which is likely to affect the normal use of the soil or endangering public health and the living environment.

Causes of Soil Pollution

a. Erosion: Soil erosion can be defined as the movement of surface litter and topsoil from one place to another. It  is a natural process often caused by wind and flowing water, accelerated by human activities such as farming, construction, overgrazing by livestock, burning of grass cover and deforestation.

b. Soil contaminants: Soil contaminants are spilled onto the surface though many different activities. Most of these are the result of accidents involving the vehicles that are transporting waste material from the site at which it originated to the site at which it is to be deposited.

c. Excess use of fertilizers and pesticides: Agricultural practices including the use of  agriculture chemicals is primary sources of pollution. Most agricultural chemicals are water soluble, nitrates and phosphates.

Effects of Soil Pollution

a) Food shortage: The foremost effect of loosing top soil is causing water pollution and reduced food production leading to food shortage.

b) Desertification: Continuous exposure of eroded soil to sun for longer periods may transform the land into sandy and rocky in nature. These are symptoms of desertification rendering the soil unsuitable for cultivation.

c) Water logging: Top soil which is washed away also contributes water pollution by clogging of lakes, and increasing turbidity of water, ultimately leading to loss of aquatic life.

Control Measures of Soil Pollution

a) Proper soil conservation measures to minimize the loss of top soil

b) INM,  IPM, using bio pesticides and  integrated environment friendly agriculture to reduce pesticides or fertilizers.

c) Appropriate water management practices in agriculture

d) Keeping the soil surface covered with crop residues or crop cover

e) Planting trees as a part of forestation/ shelter belts/wind breakers) Cleaning up of polluted soil

f) Bioremediation is any process that uses microorganisms,  fungi,  green plants or their enzymes to return the natural environment.

Water Pollution

Water Pollution is yet another major manmade environmental problem. When the quality or composition of water changes directly or indirectly as a result of man’s activities becomes unfit for any useful purpose is said to be polluted.

Types of water pollutions:

Point source of pollution: This source of pollution can be readily identified because it has a definite source and place, where it enters the water. Example: Municipal industrial discharges pipes.

Non point source of pollution: when a source of pollution cannot be readily identified  such as acid rain etc.

Causes of Surface water pollution:

Disease causing agents: parasitic worms, bacteria, viruses, protozoa that enter water  from domestic sewage and untreated human and animal wastes.

Oxygen depleting wastes: These are organic wastes that can be decomposed by aerobic bacteria.

Inorganic plant nutrients: There are water soluble nitrates and phosphates.

Excess pesticides: For control of pest pesticides are used in discriminately. These fall on ground and reach with rain water to canals and rivers.

Water soluble organic chemicals: These are acids, salts and compounds of toxic metals such as mercury & lead.

Variety of organic chemicals: includes oil, gasoline, plastics, pesticides, detergents & many other chemicals.

The sediments of suspended matter: Occur when soil is eroded.

Water soluble radio- active isotopes: Enter the water courses along with rain water.

Causes of Ground water pollution:

1. Urban runoff of untreated or poorly treated waste water storage and garbage

2. Industrial waste storage located above or near aquifer

3. Agricultural  practices such as application of large amounts of fertilizers and pesticides, animal feeding operations etc in rural sector

4. Leaks from under ground storage tanks containing gasoline and other hazardous substances

5. Poorly designed and inadequately maintained septic tanks

Effects of Water pollution:

1. Large amount of human waste in water increase the number of bacteria such as Escherichia coli and  streptococcus sps which cause gastro intestinal diseases. Water borne diseases diarrhoea, typhoid  etc.

2. If more organic matter is added to water the oxygen is used up. This causes fish and other forms of oxygen dependent aquatic life dies.

3. eutrophication due to inorganic pollutants.

4. Excess pesticides cause Bio magnification.

5. High levels of organic chemicals (acids, salts& toxic metals) can make the water unfit to drink, harm fish and other aquatic life, reduce crop yields

6. Variety of organic chemicals / oil gasoline, plastics detergents) are harmful to aquatic life and human life

7. Sediments (erosion) fish, clog the lakes and artificial reservoirs

8. Radioisotopes cause birth defects, cancer and genetic damage.

9. Hot water because of  thermal pollution not only decrease the solubility of oxygen  but  changes the breeding cycles of various aquatic organisms.

10. Accidental oil spills cause environmental damage.

11. Minamata disease is caused due to mercury poisoning of water.

Control measures of water pollution:

  • Setting up of effluent treatment plants to treat waste water can reduce the pollution  load in the recipient water.
  • Providing sanitation and waste water treatment facility.
  • Integrated nutrient management (INM) and integrated pest management (IPM) practices will reduce the effects caused due to excess pesticides.

 

Thermal Pollution

Thermal pollution is the degradation of water quality by any process that increases the ambient water temperature. The increase in temperature (a) decreases the dissolved oxygen/oxygen supply, and (b) affects ecosystem composition.

Sources of Thermal Pollution:

1) Industries: A common cause of thermal pollution is the use of water as a coolant by power plants and industrial manufacturers, hydro-electric power plants, coal fired power plants, nuclear power plants, and  industrial effluents from power, textiles, paper and pulp industries

2)Urban runoff : storm water discharged to surface waters from roads and parking lots can also be a source of elevated water temperatures.

3) Domestic sewage: municipal sewage normally has a higher temperature.

Effects of Thermal Pollution:

§ Elevated temperature typically decreases the level of dissolved oxygen (DO) in water. The decrease in levels of DO can harm aquatic animals such as fish and amphibians.

§ Thermal pollution may also increase the metabolic rate of aquatic animals, as enzyme activity, resulting in these organisms consuming more food in a shorter time than if their environment were not changed.

§ An increased metabolic rate may result to fewer resources; the more adapted organisms moving in, may have an advantage over organisms that are not used to the warmer temperature. As a result Biodiversity can be decreased.

§ Releases of unnaturally cold water from reservoirs can dramatically change the fish and macro invertebrate fauna of rivers, and reduce river productivity.

§ Interference with reproduction, in fishes, several activities like nest building, spawning, hatching, migration and reproduction etc. depend on some optimum temperature.

§ Activities of several pathogenic microorganisms are accelerated by higher temperature. Hot water causes bacterial disease in salmon fish.

§ Thermal pollutants may permit the invasion of organisms that are tolerant to warm water and highly destructive.

§ Many of the planktons, small fish and insect larvae that re sucked into the condenser along with the cooling water are killed by the thermal shock, increased pressure and water viscosity.

Control Measures for Thermal Pollution :

A. Thermal pollution can be controlled by passing the heated water through a cooling pond or a cooling tower after it leaves the condenser.

B. During warm weather, urban runoff can have significant thermal impacts on small streams, as storm water passes over hot parking lots, roads and sidewalks. Storm water management facilities that absorb runoff or direct it into groundwater, such as bio retention systems and infiltration basins, can reduce these thermal effects.

 

Marine Pollution

Marine pollution is defined as the introduction of substances to the marine environment directly or indirectly by man resulting in adverse effects such as hazardous to human health, obstruction of marine activities and lowering the quality of sea water

Sources of Marine Pollution

1. Municipal waste & sewage from residences and hotels in coastal towns are directly discharged into sea

2. Pesticides and fertilizers from agriculture which are washed off by rain enter water courses & finally to sea.

3. Petroleum & oil washed of from roads normally enter sewage system & finally into seas

4. Ship accidents & accidental spillage at sea can therefore be very damaging to the marine environment.

5. Off shore oil exploration also pollute the sea water to a large extent.

6.  All ships periodic dry docking servicing; cleaning the hulls etc. during this period when cargo compartments are emptied, residual oil goes into sea.

7. Volcanic eruptions in the sea.

8. Deep sea mining is a relatively new mineral retrieval process that takes place on the ocean floor. Beside from direct impact of mining the area, leakage, spills and corrosion would alter the mining area’s chemical makeup.

Effects of Marine Pollution:

§ Commercially important marine species are also killed due to clogging of gills and other structures.

§ When oil is spilled on the sea, it spreads over the surface of the water to form a thin film called as oil slick. This damages marine life to a large extent. Commercial damage to fish by tainting which gives unpleasant flavor to fish and sea food reduces market values of sea food and causes death of birds through its effect on feathers. Birds often clean their plumage by pruning and in the process consume oil which can lead to intestinal, renal and liver failure.

§ For salt marshy plants oil slick can affect the flowering, fruiting and germination.

Control Measures of Marine Pollution:

1) Introduction of sewage treatment plants to reduce BOD of final product before discharging into sea.

2) Cleaning oil from surface waters and contaminated beaches can be accelerated through the use of chemical dispersants which can be sprayed on the oil.

3) Load on top system reduce oil pollution cleaned with high pressures jets of water.

4) Crude oil washing: The cling age is removed by jets of crude oil while the cargo is being unloaded.

Noise Pollution

Noise is defined as ‘unwanted or offensive sound that unreasonably intrude into our daily activities’. Sound is measured in a unit called the decibel (dB). The permitted noise level is 125 decibels as per the Environment Protection Rules 1999.

Sources of Noise Pollution:

1) Outdoor Sources – Industries/factories, vehicular movements such as car, motor, truck, train, tempo, motor cycle, aircrafts, trains, Construction work, defence explosions, playing of loudspeakers during various festivals etc.The invention of supersonic air crafts has added more noise for the persons who live near aerodromes.

2) Indoor Sources – Loudly played radio or music systems, and other electronic gadgets etc.

Effects of Noise Pollution:

v  Irritability, anxiety and stress. Lack of concentration and mental fatigue are significant health effects of noise.

v  It has been observed that the performance of school children is poor incomprehension tasks when schools are situated in busy areas of a city and suffer from noise pollution – disturbance.

v  Interferes with normal auditory communication, it may mask auditory warning signals and hence increases the rate of accidents especially in industries.

Effects of Noise Pollution on Physical Health:

• Physical damage to the ear and the temporary hearing loss often called a temporary threshold shift.

• In additions to hearing losses, excessive sound levels can cause harmful effect on the circulatory system by raising blood pressure and altering pulse rates.

Noise control techniques:

There are four fundamental ways in which noise can be controlled.

 

Reduce noise at the source

1. Make sure that all openings are acoustically sealed.

2. In industries, different types of absorptive material can be used to control interior noise.

3. Regular and thorough maintenance of operating machinery.

4. Traffic volume and speed also have significant effects on the overall sound. Establishing lower speed limits for highways that pass through residential areas, limiting traffic volume and providing alternative routes for truck traffic are effective noise control measures.

Block the path of noise:

v  Through construction of temporary/permanent barriers

v  Planting of trees around houses can also act as effective noise barriers.

v  Increasing the path length. Increasing distance from the noise source and the recipient offers a passive means of control.

v  Municipal land-use ordinances pertaining to the location of airports make use of the attenuating effect of distance on sound levels.

v  Educating and bringing awareness in the people is common for control of any pollution Ex: Ban on loud speakers from 10pm to 6pm.

Solid Waste

The combined effects of population explosion and changing modern living standards have had a cumulative effect in the generation of a large amount of various types of wastes. Solid waste can be classified into different types depending on their source.

Solid waste management:

Municipal Solid Waste (MSW):  The term municipal solid waste (MSW) is generally used to describe most of the non-hazardous solid waste from a city, town or village that requires routine collection and transport to a processing or disposal site. Sources of MSW include private homes, commercial establishments and institutions, as well as industrial facilities. However, MSW does not include wastes from industrial processes, construction and demolition debris, sewage sludge, mining waste or agricultural wastes. MSW is also called as trash or garbage. In general, domestic waste and MSW are used as synonyms.

Hazardous Wastes

Hazardous wastes are those that can cause harm to human and the environment. Wastes are classified as hazardous if they exhibit any of four primary characterises based on physical or chemical properties of toxicity, reactivity ignitability  and corrosively.

Toxic wastes:

Toxic wastes are those that are poisonous in small or trace amounts. Some  may have acute or immediate effect on human or animals. Carcinogenic or mutagenic  causing biological changes in the children of exposed people and animals. Eg: pesticides,  heavy metals.

Reactive wastes:

Reactive wastes are those that have a tendency to react vigorously with air or water are unstable to shock or heat, generate toxic gases or explode during routine management. Eg: Gun powder, nitro-glycerine.

Ignitable waste:

Ignitable waste are those that burn at relatively low temperatures and are capable of spontaneous combustion during storage transport or disposal.  Eg: Gasoline, paint thinners and alcohol.

Corrosive wastes: Are those that destroy materials and living tissues by chemical reactions. Eg: acids and base

Infectious wastes: included human tissue from surgery, used bandages and hypoderm needles hospital wastes.

Industrial Wastes

These contain more of toxic and require special treatment. Food processing industries, metallurgical chemical and pharmaceutical unit’s breweries, sugar mills, paper and pulp industries, fertilizer and pesticide industries are major ones which discharges toxic wastes. During processing, scrap materials, tailings, acids etc.

Agricultural Wastes

The waste generated by agriculture includes waste from crops and live stock. In developing countries, this waste does not pose a serious problem as most of it is used e.g. dung is used for manure, straw is used as fodder.

Waste Management

1. Waste to energy

i) Gasification: It is the process in which chemical decomposition of biomass takes place in the presence of controlled amounts of oxygen, producing a gas. This gas is cleaned and used in an internal combustion engine to produce electric power. Without clean up also, the gas can be used in boilers to produce electric power. This technology is highly suited to generate electric power from agrl wastes like rice husks, groundnut shells etc.

ii) Pyralysis: It is similar to gasification except that the chemical decomposition of biomass wastes take place in the absence or reduced presence of O2 at high temp. Mixtures of gases result from decomposition including H2, NH4 Co, CO2 depending on the organic nature of waste matter. This gas used for power generation.

2. Biogas production

Animal wastes, food processing wastes and other organic matter are decomposed anaerobically to produce a gas called biogas. It contains methane and CO2. The methane can provides gas for domestic use. The byproduct of this technology is slurry, settled out the bottom of the digester. This can be used as manure.

3. Agricultural waste

Agricultural waste like corn cobs, paddy husk, bagasse of sugarcane, waste of wheat, rice and other cereals, cotton stalks, coconut wastes, jute waste etc can be used in making of paper and hard board.

Waste production can be minimized by adopting the 3 R’s principle: Reduce, Reuse,

Reduce

  • Reduce the amount and toxicity of garbage and trash that you discard.
  • Reuse containers and try to repair things that are broken.
  • Recycle products wherever possible, which includes buying recycled products  i.e. recycled paper books, paper bags etc.
  • Reduce (Waste prevention): Waste prevention, or “source reduction,” means consuming and discarding less, is a successful method of reducing waste generation.
  • Backyard composting, double sided copying  of papers, purchasing durable, long-lasting environmentally friendly goods; products and packaging that are  free of toxics,
  • Redesigning products to use less raw material production and transport packaging
  • Reduction by industries are the normal practices used and have yielded substantial environmental benefits.
  • Source reduction prevents emissions of many greenhouse gases, reduces pollutants the need saves energy, conserves resources, and reduces wastes for new landfills and combustors. It reduces the generation of waste and is generally preferred method of waste management that goes a long way toward saving the environment.

Re-use:

Re-use is the process, which involves reusing items by repairing them, donating  them to charity and community groups, or selling them. Reusing products is an alternative to recycling because the item does not need to be reprocessed for  its use  again.  Using durable glassware, steel using cloth napkins or towels, reusing bottles,  reusing boxes, purchasing refillable pens and pencils are suggested.

Recycling:

The process of recycling, including composting, has diverted several million tons of material away from disposal. Recycled materials include batteries, recycled at a rate of 93%, paper and paperboard at 48%, and yard trimmings at 56%. These materials and others may be recycled through drop off centres, buy-back programs, and deposit systems. Recycling prevents the emission of many greenhouse gases that affect global climate, water pollutants, saves energy, supplies valuable raw materials to industry, creates jobs, stimulates the development of greener technologies, conserves resources for  our children’s future, and reduces the need for new landfills and combustors

Recycling can create valuable resources and it generates a host of environmental, financial, and social benefits. Materials like glass, metal, plastics, and paper are collected, separated and sent to processing centres where they are processed into new products. The advantages of recycling are it conserves resources for future generation, prevents emissions of greenhouse gases and pollutants, saves energy, supplies valuable raw, materials to industries, stimulates the development of greener technologies, reduces the need for new landfills and incinerators.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

TAXONOMY OF INSTRUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES IN EDUCATION

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V (P.G) College, Roorkee, India


An objective is an goal or end point of something towards which actions are directed. Objectives generally indicate the end points of a journey. They specify where you want to be or what you intend to achieve at the end of a process. An educational objective is that achievement which a specific educational instruction is  expected to  make  or accomplish.  It is the outcome of any educational instruction. It is the purpose for which any particular educational undertaking is carried out.

Various Level of Educational objectives

Educational objectives can be specified at various levels. These levels include the national level, the institutional level and the instructional level..

At the National Level

At  this  level  of  educational  objectives,  we  have  merely  policy statements of what education should achieve for the nation. They are in broad outlines reflecting national interests, values, aspirations and goals. It can be in the form of the National Policy on Education.

At the Institutional level

This is the intermediate objectives level. The aims are logically derived and related to both the ones at the national level and the one’s at the instructional levels. They are narrowed to achieve local needs like the kinds of certificate to be awarded by the institutions. These institutional objectives  are  usually  specified  by  an  act  or  edict  of  the  house  of assembly if it is a state government institution, otherwise by an act of the national Parliament.

At the Instructional Level

Since the schools are institutions consciously created to ensure desirable changes  in human behaviour towards  the  ultimate  realization  of the national  goals,  they  have  to  make  conscious  efforts  to  ensure  the attainment  of  the  goals.  This  can  be  done  through  a  systematic translation  of  these  objectives,  and  then  to  instructional  objectives. Here, educational objectives are stated in the form in which they are to operate in the classroom. They are therefore referred to as instructional objectives..  They  are  specifically  based  on  the intended  learning  outcomes.  These  objectives  state  what  teaching  is expected to achieve,  what the learner is  expected to learn from the instruction, how the learner is expected to behave after being subjected to the instruction and what he has to do in order to demonstrate that he has learnt what is expected from the instruction. These instructional objectives  are  therefore  stated in behavioural  terms  with the  use  of action verbs to specify the desirable behaviour which the learner will exhibit in order to show that he has learnt

Importance of Instructional Objectives.

The  instructional  objectives  are  very  important component of teaching system,  as they provide the necessary feedback for the  adjustments  of  curriculum,  teaching  method  and  teaching  aids. They also show how appropriate  the  curriculum  of  the  institution  is.  These  instructional objectives can be used as a feedback on how much the institutional objectives have been achieved and how appropriate these objectives are.

The objectives start from broad goals at the national level to the instructional level. In the same way when evaluating these objectives, we use the instructional level objectives. From this, evaluation goes to the institutional to the national levels. In other words, the feedback got from the assessment of the instructional objectives  is  translated  into  finding  and  how  much  the  national educational objectives have been achieved in respect to the particular type of institution, and their appropriateness.

At the instructional level, they may lead to the adjustment of teaching methods or provision of instructional materials. From the small things, activities, tests, examinations, projects, assignments, exercises, quizzes, home works etc done in the classroom setting,  can be used to evaluate, in a general process, the national policy at the national level.

Apart  from  the  feedback  instructional  objectives  are  also  important because the teacher’s plans of what to teach and how to teach it is based on the objectives specified to be achieved. The evaluation of pupils’ learning outcome will make him know whether the objectives are being achieved or not. It means that the instructional objectives give meaning and direction to the educational process.

BLOOM’S  TAXONOMY  OF  EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVES

Bloom’s Taxonomy, (in full: ‘Bloom’s Taxonomy of Learning Domains’, or strictly speaking: Bloom’s ‘Taxonomy Of Educational Objectives’) was initially (the first part) published in 1956 under the leadership of American academic and educational expert Dr Benjamin S Bloom. Taxonomy means ‘a set of classification principles’, or ‘structure’, and Domain simply means ‘category’. ‘Bloom’s Taxonomy’ was originally created in and for an academic context, (the development commencing in 1948), when Benjamin Bloom chaired a committee of educational psychologists, based in American education, whose aim was to develop a system of categories of learning behaviour to assist in the design and assessment of educational learning. Bloom’s Taxonomy has since been expanded over many years by Bloom and other contributors (notably Anderson and Krathwhol as recently as 2001, whose theories extend Bloom’s work to far more complex levels and which are more relevant to the field of academic education).

Bloom’  Benjamin’s  has  put  forward  a  taxonomy  of  educational objectives,  which  provides  a  practical  framework  within  which educational  objectives  could  be  organized  and  measured.  In  this taxonomy Bloom  divided educational objectives into three domains.  These  are;

Cognitive  domain,

Affective  domain  and

Psychomotor domain.

Cognitive domain (intellectual capability, ie., knowledge, or ’think’)

The  cognitive  domain  involves  those  objectives  that  deal  with  the development of intellectual abilities and skills. These have to do with the mental abilities of the brain.

The domain is categorized into six hierarchical levels , comprehension,  application,  analysis,  synthesis  and evaluation. These levels are of  hierarchical and increasing operational difficulties  that  achievement  of  a  higher  level  of  skill  assumes  the achievement of the previous levels. This implies that a higher level of skill could be achieved only if a certain amount of ability called for by the previous level has been achieved.

Learning outcome in Cognative Domain



KNOWLEDGE (or Memory)LEVEL

Knowledge or memory is the first, the lowest and the foundation for the development of higher order cognitive skills. It involves the recognition or  recall  of  previous  learned  information.   For  measurement purposes,  memory  or  knowledge  involves  bringing  to  mind  the appropriate material. This cognitive level emphasizes the psychological process of remembering. Knowledge is remembering or retrieving previously learned material.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate. Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

know
identify
relate
list
define
recall
memorize
repeat
record
name
recognize
acquire 

 

These verbs can be used to formulate instructional objectives. Using these action verbs, specify some objectives in related subject area.

Knowledge can also be classified into the following:-

i. Knowledge of specifics (taxonomy, facts, definitions etc)

ii. Knowledge of ways and means of dealing with specifics (rules)

iii. Knowledge of conventions (styles, symbols practices, allegories)

iv. Knowledge of Trends and sequences (order or sequence)

v. Knowledge of classification and categories (classes, sets, divisions)

vi. Knowledge of criteria (established facts and criteria)

vii. Knowledge of Techniques and procedures or Methodology.

viii. Knowledge of universals and abstractions.

ix. Knowledge of principles and generalizations (laws, formulas)

x Knowledge of theories and structures (models, philosophies)

Questions inherent in Knowledge

What is …? How is …? Where is …? When did _______ happen? How did ______ happen? How would you explain …? Why did …? How would you describe …? When did …? Can you recall …? How would you show …? Can you select …? Who were the main …? Can you list three …? Which one …? Who was …?

COMPREHENSION or UNDERSTANDING LEVEL

Comprehension is the ability to grasp or construct meaning from material. Comprehension is all about internalization of knowledge. It involvers making memory out of what is stored in the brain file. It is on this basis that what is stored inthe brain can be understood and translated, interpreted or extrapolated. It is only when you have known something that you can understand it.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate. Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

restate
locate
report
recognize
explain
express
identify
discuss
describe
review
infer 

conclude

illustrate
interpret
draw
represent
differentiate 

 

 

Comprehension level is made up of the following:

i. Translation: which  involves  the  ability  to  understand  literal messages across communication forms, changing what is known from one form of communication to another e.g. from words to numbers,  graphs,  maps,  charts,  cartoons,  pictures,  formulas, symbols,  models, equations etc.

ii. Interpretation: which  goes  beyond  mere  literal  translation  to identification of inter-relationships among parts and components of communication and interpreting and relating these to the main components e.g. to interpret a chart or graph etc.

iii. Extrapolation: which involves the ability to draw implications and ability  to  identify  and continue  a  trend,  isolate  or  detect consequences, suggest possible meaning and estimate possible effect.

Questions inherent in Comprehension Level -

How would you classify the type of …? How would you compare …? contrast …? Will you state or interpret in your own words …? How would you rephrase the meaning …? What facts or ideas show …? What is the main idea of …? Which statements support …? Can you explain what is happening . . . what is meant . . .? What can you say about …? Which is the best answer …? How would you summarize …?

 

APPLICATION LEVEL

As per the hierarchic nature of the instructional objectives  it is not possible to understand unless it is known..  It  also  means  that  one  cannot  apply  what  he/she  do  not understand.  The  use  of abstractions  in a  concrete  situation is  called application. These abstractions can be in the form of general ideas, rules, or procedures or generalized methods, technical terms, principles, ideas and theories which must be remembered, understood and applied. Understanding before correct application is an essentiality.

In application the learner uses what he knows to solve a new problem, or in a new situation. Application involves the ability to the learner to grasp exactly what the problem is all about and what generalization or principles are relevant, useful, or pertinent for its solution.  Application is the ability to use learned material, or to implement material in new and concrete situations.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate. Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

apply
relate
develop
translate
use
operate
organize
employ
restructure
interpret
demonstrate
illustrate 

 

practice
calculate
show
exhibit
dramatize

it involves the principles of transfer of learning.

Questions inherent in Application Level

How would you use …? What examples can you find to …? How would you solve _______ using what you have learned …? How would you organize _______ to show …? How would you show your understanding of …? What approach would you use to …? How would you apply what you learned to develop …? What other way would you plan to …? What would result if …? Can you make use of the facts to …? What elements would you choose to change …? What facts would you select to show …? What questions would you ask in an interview with …?

ANALYSIS LEVEL

Analysis is the breaking down of communication into its constituent parts or elements in order to establish the relationship or make the relations between ideas expressed to be clear or explicit.   Analysis The ability to break down or distinguish the parts of material into its components so that its organizational structure may be better understood.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate..   Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

 

analyze
compare
probe
inquire
examine
contrast
categorize
differentiate
contrast
investigate
detect
survey
classify
deduce
experiment
scrutinize
discover
inspect
dissect
discriminate
separate 

 

The components here include:

i. Analysis  of Elements: which is  concerned with the  ability  to identify the underlying elements such as assumptions, hypothesis, conclusions,  views,  values,  arguments,  statements  etc  and  to determine the nature and functions of such elements?

ii. Analysis of Relationship: which involves trying to determine how the elements identified are related to each other? For instance, how does the evidence relate to the conclusion?

iii. Analysis  of  Organizational  principles: which  involves determining the principles or system of organization which holds the different elements and parts together? It involves finding the pattern, the structure, systematic arrangements, point of view, etc.

Questions inherent in Analysis Level

What are the parts or features of _______? How is _______ related to _______? Why do you think______? What is the theme …? What motive is there …? Can you list the parts …? What inference can you make …? What conclusions can you draw …? How would you classify …? How would you categorize …? Can you identify the difference parts …? What evidence can you find …? What is the relationship between …? Can you make a distinction between …? What is the function of …? What ideas justify …?

SYNTHESIS LEVEL

Contrary to analysis which involves breaking down of materials, communication, object etc, in synthesis  building up or putting together elements is processed. In other  words,  synthesis  is  concerned with the  ability  to put parts  of knowledge together to form a new knowledge.  Parts, pieces and components in order to form a unique whole or to constitute a new form, plan, pattern or structure. It involves categorizing of  items,  composing  of  poems,  and  songs,  writing  etc.  it  involves divergent  thinking.  It  calls  for  imaginative,  original  and  creative thinking.  It calls for creative answers to problems and for the development of questioning mind, spirit of inquiry or inquisitive mind. It requires fluency of novel ideas and flexible mind.  Synthesis is  the ability to put parts together to form a coherent or unique new whole.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate. Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

compose
produce
design
assemble
create
prepare
predict
modify
tell
plan
invent
formulate
collect
set up
generalize
document
combine
relate
propose
develop
arrange
construct
organize
originate
derive
write
propose

 

 

Synthesis can be sub divided into:

(a) Production of unique communication: which is concerned with the ability to put together in a unique organizational form a piece of written or oral communication to convey a novel idea, feeling or experience to others?

(b) Production  of  a  plan  or  proposed  set  of  operations: this  is concerned  with  the  ability  to  develop  a  plan  or  to  propose procedures for solving problem or dealing with others.

(c) Derivation of a set of Abstract Relation: this is based on the result of  the  analysis  of  an  experimental  data,  observation  or  other specific. It is the ability to form concepts generalizations, deduce propositions, predictions or relationship based on classification of experiences or observations.

Questions inherent in Synthesis Level

What changes would you make to solve …? How would you improve …? What would happen if …? Can you elaborate on the reason …? Can you propose an alternative …? Can you invent …? How would you adapt ________ to create a different …? How could you change (modify) the plot (plan) …? What could be done to minimize (maximize) …? What way would you design …? What could be combined to improve (change) …? Suppose you could _______ what would you do …? How would you test …? Can you formulate a theory for …? Can you predict the outcome if …? How would you estimate the results for …? What facts can you compile …? Can you construct a model that would change …? Can you think of an original way for the …?

 

EVALUATION LEVEL

It  is  the  top most level in the  hierarchy. In education, evaluation as a cognitive objective involves the learners’  ability  to  organize  his  thought  and  knowledge  to  reach  a logical and rational decision which is defendable.  It involves making a quantitative or qualitative judgment about a piece of communication, a procedure, a method, a proposal, a plan etc. Based on certain internal or external criteria alternatives abound, choice depends on the result of judgment which we make consciously or unconsciously based on values we held. Evaluation  is  the  most  complex  of  human  cognitive  behaviour.  It embodies  elements  of  the  other  five  categories.  (knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis and synthesis). Evaluation is the ability to judge, check, and even critique the value of material for a given purpose.

Action verbs which can serve as appropriate. Examples of verbs that relate to this function are:

judge
assess
compare
evaluate
conclude
measure
deduce
argue
decide
choose
rate
select
estimate
validate
consider
appraise
value
criticize
infer

 

 

Evaluation can be subdivided into

(a) judgment in terms of internal criteria and

(b) judgment in terms of external criteria.

Questions inherent in Evaluation Level

Do you agree with the actions …? with the outcomes …? What is your opinion of …? How would you prove …? disprove …? Can you assess the value or importance of …? Would it be better if …? Why did they (the character) choose …? What would you recommend …? How would you rate the …? What would you cite to defend the actions …? How would you evaluate …? How could you determine …? What choice would you have made …? What would you select …? How would you prioritize …? What judgment would you make about …? Based on what you know, how would you explain …? What information would you use to support the view …? How would you justify …? What data was used to make the conclusion …? Why was it better that …? How would you prioritize the facts …? How would you compare the ideas …? people …?

REVISED B.S.BLLOM TAXONOMY OF INSTUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES

Anderson and Krathwohl  in the year 1995-2000 revised the taxonomy of instructional objectives previously propounded by Bloom.

In the following table are the two primary existing taxonomies of cognition. The one on the left, entitled Bloom’s, is based on the original work of Benjamin Bloom and others as they attempted in 1956 to define the functions of thought, coming to know, or cognition. This taxonomy is over 50 years old.

Table – Bloom vs. Anderson/Krathwohl

Visual comparison of the two taxonomies

One of the things that clearly differentiates the new model from that of the 1956 original is that it lays out components nicely so they can be considered and used, and so cognitive processes as related to chosen instructional tasks can be easily documented and tracked. This feature has the potential to make teacher assessment, teacher self-assessment, and student assessment easier or clearer as usage patterns emerge.

The primary differences are not just in the listings or rewordings from nouns to verbs, or in the renaming of some of the components, or even in the repositioning of the last two categories. The major differences in the updated version is in the more useful and comprehensive additions of how the taxonomy intersects and acts upon different types and levels of knowledge — factual, conceptual, procedural and meta-cognitive.

 

AFFECTIVE DOMAIN (feelings, emotions and behaviour, ie., attitude, or ’feel’)

Previously the educationists never encourage emotionalism  in education. They believe that intellectualism had  nothing to do with the learner’s interests, emotions or impulses. Today, they have acknowledge that the learner’s feelings and emotions are equally  important  in  education.  In the year 1975 Tanner and Tanner  insist that the primary goals of learning are affective. They are of the opinion that learners should not learn what is selected for them by others. This is because it amounts to imposition on the learners of other peoples values and purposes. This of course  defys  learners’ own feelings and emotions..

Krathwohl’s affective domain taxonomy is perhaps the best known of any of the affective taxonomies. “The taxonomy is ordered according to the principle of internalization. Internalization refers to the process whereby a person’s affect toward an object passes from a general awareness level to a point where the affect is ‘internalized’ and consistently guides or controls the person’s behavior .

Previously our  school  systems  was  the discipline-centred  . Although the primary goal of a good teacher is to help students learn, not to make them feel good yet it is an important role of a good teacher to make students feel good about their efforts to learn and their success in learning. This will help to create a balance and interdependence between the cognitive and the affective processes of learningThe affective domain has to do with feelings and emotions. These are the emphatic characteristic of this domain of acceptance or rejection. It isconcerned with interests, attitudes, appreciation, emotional biases and values.

The  function  of  the  affective  domain  in  the  instructional situation pertains to emotions, the passions, the dispositions, the moral and  the  aesthetic  sensibilities,  the  capacity  for  feeling,  concern, attachment or detachment, sympathy, empathy, and appreciation.

Affective domain is generally covert in behaviour. The educational objectives here vary from simple  attention  to  complex  and  internally  consistent  qualities  of character and conscience.

 

Affective domain has five hierarchical categories. You remember that the cognitive domain has six hierarchical levels. Specifically, the levels in affective domain fall into these levels:

 

Receiving

This is the lowest level of the learning outcomes in the affective domain. It means attending. It is the learner’s willingness to attend to a particular stimulus or his being sensitive to the existence of a given problem, event, condition or situation. The learner is sensitized to the existence of certain  phenomena; that is, that she/he be willing to receive or to attend to them.

Receiving has three sub-levels. These are:

i. Awareness: which  involves  the  conscious  recognition  of  the existence  of  some  problems,  conditions,  situations,  events, phenomena etc. take for instance as a teacher, you come into your class while the students are making noise. You will notice that the atmosphere will change. This is because the students have become aware of your presence. They are merely aware.

ii. Willingness: This is the next stage which involves the ability to acknowledge the object, event, problem instead of ignoring or avoiding it. The students in your class kept quite because they noticed and acknowledged your presence. If they had ignored your presence they would continue to make noise in the class.

iii. Controlled  or  selected  attention:  This  involves  the  learner selecting or choosing to pay attention to the situation, problem, event or phenomenon. When you teach in the class, the learner is aware of your saying or the points you are making. In that case he will  deliberately  shut  off  messages  or  speeches  or  sounds  as noises.  Receiving  in  a  classroom  situation  involves  getting, holding and directing the attention of the learners to whatever the teacher has to say in the class.

Examples  of  Receiving

Listen to others with respect

Listen for and remember the name of newly introduced people.

Examples of verbs that relate to this function are

asks, chooses, describes, follows,

gives, holds, identifies, locates

, names, points to, selects, sits,

erects, replies, uses.

 

Responding

Here the learner responds to the event by participating. . Attends and  reacts to a particular phenomenon. He does not only attend, he also reacts by doing something. Active participation on the part of the learners.

Learning outcomes may emphasize:

compliance in responding,

willingness to respond,

satisfaction in responding  (motivation).

Responding has three sub-levels too. These are:

i. acquiescence in responding: which involves simple obedience orcompliance.

ii. Willingness to respond: This involves voluntary responses to a given situation.

iii. Satisfaction in response: if he is satisfied with the response he enjoys reacting to the type of situation.

Examples of Responding :

Participates in class discussions

Gives a presentation

Questions new ideals, concepts, models, etc. in order to fully understand them

.Know the safety rules and practices them.

Examples of verbs that relate to this function are

answers, assists, aids, complies,

conforms, discusses, greets, helps,

labels, performs, practices, presents,

reads, recites, reports, selects, tells, writes

 

Valuing

Valuing is related with the worth or value or benefit which a leaner attaches to a particular object, phenomenon ,behaviour or situation. This ranges from simple acceptance to the more  complex state of commitment  This ranges in degree from mere acceptance of value or a desire to improve group skills to a more complex level of commitment or an assumption of responsibility for the effective functioning of the group.. Valuing is based on the internalization of a set of  specified values, while clues to these values are expressed in the learner’s overt  behavior and are often identifiable.

There are three sub-levels of valuing:

i. Acceptance  of  a  value:  This  is  a  situation  where  the  learner believes  tentatively  in  a  proportion,  doctrine,  condition  or situation.

ii. Preference for a value: In this case the learner believes in the desirability or necessity of the condition, doctrine, proposition etc.  and  ignores  or  rejects  other  alternatives  and  deliberately  looks for other people views where the issues are controversial, so as to form his own opinion.

iii. Commitment to a value: In this stage the learner is convinced and fully  committed  to  the  doctrine,  principle  or  cause.  In consequence,  the  learner  internalizes  a  set  of  specific  values, which consistently manifest themselves in his event behaviour, attitudes and appreciation.

Examples  of Valuing :

Demonstrates belief in the democratic process

. Is sensitive towards individual and cultural differences (value diversity).

Shows the ability to solve problems

. Proposes a plan to social improvement and follows through with commitment

. Informs management on matters that one feels strongly about.

Examples of verbs that relate to this function are

completes, demonstrates, differentiates, explains,

follows, forms, initiates, invites,

joins, justifies, proposes, reads,

reports, selects, shares, studies, works.

 

Organization

Here the learner starts to bring together different values as an organized system. He determines the interrelationships and establishes the order of priority by comparing, relating and synthesizing the values. He  then builds  a  consistent value  system by resolving any  possible conflicts between them. He has to organize the values into a system in order to decide which value to emphasis .Organizes values into priorities by contrasting different  values and, resolving conflicts between them, and creating an unique value system.  The emphasis is on comparing, relating, and synthesizing values.

There are two sub-levels of organization . These are:

i. Conceptualization of a Value

This involves the understanding of the relationship of abstract elements of a value to these already held or to new values which are gaining acceptance. For example, the area of music where he/she may have to identify the characteristics of two types of music such  as  classical  and  hip  up  music,  which  he/she  admire  or  enjoy  in relation to the others such as jazz or highlife which you do not like.

ii. Organization of Value System?

This  involves  the  development  of  a  complex  value  system,  which includes  those  values  that  cannot  be  compared  for  the  purpose  of making choices in order to promote public welfare, instead of the sheer aggrandizement of special personal interest. It is this level that leads  individuals  to develop  vocational plan  which  can  satisfy  their needs for economic security and social welfare. It leads the individual to develop philosophy of life, which helps him to avoid dependence upon others,  especially  to  avoid  a  situation  where  one  becomes  a  public nuisance.   Recognizes the need for balance between freedom and responsible behavior.

Examples of  Organization:

Accepts responsibility for one’s behaviour

Explains the role of systematic planning in solving problems

Accepts professional ethical standards.

Creates a life plan in harmony with abilities, interests, and beliefs

Prioritizes time effectively to meet the needs of the organization, family, and self.

Examples of verbs that relate to this function are

: adheres, alters, arranges, combines,

compares, completes, defends, explains,

formulates, generalizes, identifies, integrates,

modifies, orders, organizes, prepares, relates, synthesizes.

Characterization by a Value or a Value Complex

Here the person acts  consistently in accordance with such values, beliefs or ideals that comprise his total philosophy or view of life. A life-style which reflects these beliefs and philosophy are developed. The behaviour of such individuals or groups can be said to be controlled by the value system.Here it is possible to predict with accuracy how an individual would behave or respond. The behavior is pervasive, consistent, predictable, and  most importantly, characteristic of the learner. Instructional objectives are  concerned with the student’s general patterns of adjustment  in personal, social,  emotional domain.

There are two levels Value Complex of :

i. Generalized set: This involves a situation where the orientation of the  individual  enables  him  to  reduce  to  order  a  complex environment and to act consistently and effectively in it. There may be room for the individual to revise his judgements and to change  his  behaviour  as  a  result  of  available  new  and  valid evidence.

ii. Characterization: In  this  case,  the  internalization  of  a  value system  is  such  that  the  individual  is  consistently  acting  in harmony with it. The value system regulates the individual’s personal and civil life according to a code of behaviour based on ethical principles.

Examples of Internalizing values

Shows self-reliance when working independently

. Cooperates in group activities (displays teamwork).

Uses an objective approach in problem solving.

Displays a professional commitment to ethical  practice on a daily basis.

Revises judgments and changes behavior in light of new evidence

. Values people for what they are, not how they look.

Examples of verbs that relate to this function are

acts, discriminates, displays, influences,

listens, modifies, performs, practices

, proposes, qualifies, questions, revises,

serves, solves, verifies.

 

Psychomotor domain (manual and physical skills, ie., skills, or ’do’)

Psychomotor objectives are those specific to discreet physical functions, reflex actions and interpretive movements. Traditionally, these types of objectives are concerned with the physically encoding of information, with movement and/or with activities where the gross and fine muscles are used for expressing or interpreting information or concepts. This area also refers to natural, autonomic responses or reflexes.

It means  that the  instructional  objectives make  performance  skills  more prominent. The psychomotor domain has to do with muscular activities.

 

The psychomotor domain includes physical and motor (or muscular) skills. Every act has a psychomotor component. In the learning situation there is again a progression from mere physical experience – seeing, touching, moving etc. – through the carrying out of complex skills under guidance, to the performance of skilled activities independently. 

Psychomotor domain is sub divided into hierarchical levels. The six levels from simplest to most complex are:

(i)Reflex  movements

(ii)  Basic  Fundamental movements

(iii) Perceptual abilities

(iv) Physical abilities

(v) Skilled movements and

(vi) Non-discursive communication

Reflex Movements:

At the lowest level of the psychomotor domain is the reflex movements which  every  normal  human  being  should  be  able  to  make.

Reflex movements are defined as involuntary motor responses to stimuli. They form the basis for all behaviour involving movement of any kind.

Objectives at this level include reflexes that involve one segmental or reflexes of the spine and movements that may involve more than one segmented portion of the spine as inter-segmental reflexes (e.g., involuntary muscle contraction). These movements are involuntary being either present at birth or emerging through maturation.

Basic Fundamental Movements:

Objectives in this area refer to skills or movements or behaviors related to walking, running, jumping, pushing, pulling and manipulating. They are often components for more complex actions.

Basic fundamental movements are defined as those inherent body movement patterns, which build upon the foundation laid by reflex movements. They usually occur during the first year of life, and unfold rather than are taught or consciously acquired. These movements involve movement patterns which change a child from a stationary to an ambulatory learner.

There are three sub-categories at this stage. These are:

i. Locomotor movement: which involves movements of the body from place to place such as crawling, walking, leaping, jumping etc.

ii. Non-locomotor  movements: which  involves  body  movements that do not involve moving from one place to another. These include muscular movements, wriggling of the trunk, head and any other part of the body. They also include turning, twisting etc of the body.

iii.     Manipulative movements: which involves the use of the hands or limbs to move things to control things etc.

-Perceptual Abilities:

Objectives in this area should address skills related to kinesthetic (bodily movements), visual, auditory, tactile (touch), or coordination abilities as they are related to the ability of acquiring  information from the environment and react.

Perceptual abilities are really inseparable from motor movements. They help learners to interpret stimuli so that they can adjust to their environment. Superior motor activities depend upon the development of perception. They involve kinaesthetic discrimination, visual discrimination, auditory discrimination and co-ordinated abilities of eye and hand, eye and foot.

Perceptual abilities are concerned with the ability of the individuals to perceive and distinguish  things  using  the  senses.  Such  individuals  recognise  and compare  things  by  physically  tasting,  smelling,  seeing,  hearing  and touching.

-Physical abilities:

Objectives in this area should be related to endurance, flexibility, agility, strength, reaction-response time or dexterity. Physical abilities are essential to efficient motor activity. They are concerned with the vigor of the person, and allow the individual to meet the demands placed upon him or her in and by the environment. These abilities fall in the area of health and physical education.

Skilled Movements:

Objectives in this area refer to skills and movements that must be learned for games, sports, dances, performances, or for the arts.

Skilled movements are defined as any efficiently performed complex movement. They require learning and should be based upon some adaptation of the inherent patterns of movement described in level number two above. This  is  a  higher  ability  than  the  physical  abilities.

There are three sub-levels of the skilled movements. These are:

Simple adaptive skills,

compound adaptive skills and

complex adaptive skills.

Non-Discursive Communication:

Objectives in this area refer to expressive movements through posture, gestures, facial expressions, and/or creative movements like those in mime or ballet.  These movements refer to interpretative movements that communicate meaning without the aid of verbal commands or help. Non-discursive communication can be defined as comprising those behaviours which are involved in movement communication.

Every body that is normal can move his limbs and legs. But  must have some level of training, practice and the ability to combine a variety of  movements  and  some  perceptive  abilities  in  order  to  do  diving, swimming, typing, driving, cycling etc.

There are two sub-levels of the non-discursive communication. They are:

expressive movement

and interpretive movement.

Primary taxonomies of the psychomotor domain:

Taxonomy developed by Dave

Dave (1970) developed this taxonomy of psychomotor   domain:

  • Imitation – Observing and copying someone else.
  • Manipulation – Guided via instruction to perform a skill.
  • Precision – Accuracy, proportion and exactness exist in the skill performance without the presence of the original source.
  • Articulation – Two or more skills combined, sequenced, and performed consistently.
  • Naturalization – Two or more skills combined, sequenced, and performed consistently and with ease. The performance is automatic with little physical or mental exertion.

 

 

Taxonomy developed by Simpson

Simpson (1972) built this taxonomy on the work of Bloom and others:

  • Perception – Sensory cues guide motor activity.
  • Set – Mental, physical, and emotional dispositions that make one respond in a certain way to a situation.
  • Guided Response – First attempts at a physical skill. Trial and error coupled with practice lead to better performance.
  • Mechanism – The intermediate stage in learning a physical skill. Responses are habitual with a medium level of assurance and proficiency.
  • Complex Overt Response – Complex movements are possible with a minimum of wasted effort and a high level of assurance they will be successful.
  • Adaptation – Movements can be modified for special situations.
  • Origination – New movements can be created for special situations.

Taxonomy developed by Harrow

Harrow (1972) developed this taxonomy. It is organized according to the degree of coordination including involuntary responses and learned capabilities:

  • Reflex movements – Automatic reactions.
  • Basic fundamental movement – Simple movements that can build to more complex sets of movements.
  • Perceptual – Environmental cues that allow one to adjust movements.
  • Physical activities – Things requiring endurance, strength, vigor, and agility.
  • Skilled movements – Activities where a level of efficiency is achieved.
  • Non-discursive communication – Body language.

 

The taxonomy of educational objectives from the work of Professor B.S. Bloom and his colleagues has given us a sound base for the formulation of  our  objectives.  A  sound  system  of  education  should  be  able  to produce graduates who have a wealth of knowledge and are able to comprehend much of it, and are also able to apply their knowledge and engage  in  those  mental  activities  variously  referred  to  as  critical thinking,  reflective  thinking,  divergent  thinking,  inductive-deductive processes, problem solving etc. these activities are concerned with the higher categories of the cognitive domain. These areas should form the bulk of the objectives because they are the ones from where we expect the highest educational dividends.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Operant conditioning – Skinner’s learning theory

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V (P.G) College, Roorkee, India


 

 

Operant conditioning was developed by Burrhus Friederich Skinner (1904–1990), a psychologist at Harvard University, in 1938. Operant conditioning was coined by B.F. Skinner that is why one may occasionally hear it referred as Skinnerian conditioning. Skinner believed that the best way to understand behaviour is to look at the causes of an action and its consequences

Beginning in the 1930’s, Skinner started his experimentation on the behaviour of animals. Skinner’s quest was to observe the relationship between observable stimuli and response.  Essentially, he wanted to know why these animals behaved the way that they do.

Definition of Operant Conditioning:

Operant conditioning refers to a kind of learning process where a response is made more probable or more frequent by reinforcement. It helps in the learning of operant behaviour, the behaviour that is not necessarily associated with a known stimulus.

Operant conditioning (sometimes referred to as instrumental conditioning) is a method of learning that occurs through rewards and punishments for behaviour. Through these rewards and punishments, an association is made between a behaviour and a consequence for that behaviour.

Operant conditioning is defined as the use of consequences to modify the occurrence and form of behaviour. “To put it very simply, behaviour that is followed by pleasant consequences tends to be repeated and thus learned. Behaviour that is followed by unpleasant consequences tends not to be repeated and thus not learned” (Alberto & Troutman, 2006, p. 12). Operant conditioning is specifically limited to voluntary behaviour, that is, emitted responses, which distinguishes it from respondent or Pavlovian conditioning, which is limited to reflexive behaviour (or elicited responses).

Operant Conditioning is a type of learning in which a behaviour is strengthened (meaning, it will occur more frequently) when it’s followed by reinforcement, and weakened (will happen less frequently) when followed by punishment. Operant conditioning is based on a simple premise – that behaviour is influenced by the consequences that follow. When you are reinforced for doing something, you’re more likely to do it again. When you are punished for doing something, you are less likely to do it again.

Skinner’s Operant Conditioning

Skinner used the term operant to refer to any “active behaviour that operates upon the environment to generate consequences”. In other words, Skinner’s theory explained how we acquire the range of learned behaviours we exhibit each and every day.

Skinner considers an operant as an act which constitutes an organisms doing something and Operant conditioning can be defined as a type of learning in which voluntary (controllable; non-reflexive) behaviour is strengthened if it is reinforced and weakened if it is punished (or not reinforced).

Operant Conditioning recognizes the differences between elicited responses and emitted responses. The former are responses associated with a particular stimulus, and the latter are responses that act on the environment to produce different kinds of consequences that affect the organism and alter future behaviour. . As a behaviourist, Skinner believed that internal thoughts and motivations could not be used to explain behaviour. Instead, he suggested, we should look only at the external, observable causes of human behaviour.

Skinner’s research focuses on the manipulation of the consequences of an organism’s behaviour and its effect on subsequent behaviour. Learning can be understood by a basic S (Discriminative Stimulus)-R (Operant Response, the behaviour)-S (Contingent Stimulus, the reinforcing stimulus) relationship. The change in behaviour is operated by the contingencies of reinforcement. A reinforcing event is any behavioural consequence that strengthens behaviour.

Fundamental Experiment

Operant Conditioning, or Instrumental Conditioning, is the method of teaching associations between behaviours and the behaviour’s consequences, thereby strengthening or weakening the behaviours. Strengthened behaviours are those that have high probability of re-occurrence, while weakened behaviours are those that have low probability of re-occurrence. Operant conditioning involves voluntary responses (operant behaviour), whereas classical conditioning involves involuntary responses (respondent behaviour).

Prior to the work of Skinner, instrumental learning was typically studied using a maze or a puzzle box. Learning in these settings is better suited to examining discrete trials or episodes of behavior, instead of the continuous stream of behavior. The Skinner box is an experimental environment that is better suited to examine the more natural flow of behavior. (The Skinner box is also referred to as an operant conditioning chamber.)

It was B.F. Skinner, who expanded Thorndike’s law of effect. Much of the principles of operant conditioning known and used today came from Skinner’s extensive research experiments A Skinner Box is a often small chamber that is used to conduct operant conditioning research with animals. Within the chamber, there is usually a lever (for rats) or a key (for pigeons) that an individual animal can operate to obtain a food or water within the chamber as a reinforcer. The chamber is connected to electronic equipment that records the animal’s lever pressing or key pecking, thus allowing for the precise quantification of behaviour. . For example, he was able to successfully teach pigeons to guide missile direction. His pigeons constantly poked on a dot found on the screen to keep the missile on track while being fed with food pellets. Although Skinner’s offer to use the pigeons to serve during _World War I was rejected by the US Navy officials, the experiment showed the success behind operant conditioning.  For example, he was able to successfully teach pigeons to guide missile direction. His pigeons constantly poked on a dot found on the screen to keep the missile on track while being fed with food pellets. Another good example is the Skinner box, where a rat is taught to press the lever to get food.

Skinner’s method of conditioning went like this: random pellets were thrown to the tray to accustom the rat, then the lever is installed, and the rat gets food pellets whenever it occasionally presses on the lever. The reason why the Skinner box is named after Skinner is because Skinner subsequently improved the box to increase the degree of control he has over the experimental setting. He installed devices to precisely measure activity inside the box, and to avoid human error. First, he soundproofed it, then he installed a mechanical device to record the rat’s responses, and lastly, he automated the food dispenser.

Skinner’s research focused on the experimental study of behaviour. The underlying assumptions about the research in Skinner’s experiments include:

•             The lawful relationships between behaviour and environment can be only found only if behavioural properties and experimental conditions are carefully studied

•             Data from experimental study of behaviour are the only acceptable sources of information about the causes of behaviour.

 

The Laws of Conditioning

Skinner proposed two laws that govern the conditioning of an operant:

•             The Law of Conditioning: If the occurrence of an operant is followed by presentation of a reinforcing stimulus, the strength is increased.

•             The Law of Extinction: If the occurrence of an operant already strengthened through conditioning is not followed by the reinforcing stimulus, the strength is decreased.

The Learning Process

The procedure suggested in operant conditioning is indirectly based on Thorndike’s Law of Effect and Pavlov classical conditioning.

The  simple behaviour learning process is based on connectionism,  holds –The response R which is closely associated with a stimulus S and the conjunction of the two is reinforced by primary need reduction, there is greater possibility of that S-R to recur on later occasions. That means the strength of the connection is directly proportional to need reduction.

 

The complex behaviour learning process is based on classical conditioning, holds-The stimulus S  which is reinforced by primary need reduction acquire itself the power to reinforce any other contiguous or immediately antecedent stimulus, and the chain goes on infinitely.

 

S1—————-R1

S2-S1————-R1

S2——————R1

S3-S2————R1

S3——————R1

And goes on

Components of Operant Conditioning

Some key concepts in operant conditioning:

Responses

Types of Responses:

1. Elicited by known stimuli:

Respondent behaviour which includes all reflexes. Examples are jerking one’s hand when jabbed with a pin, construction of the pupils on account of bright light, salivation in the presence of food.

Stimulus preceding the response is responsible for causing the behaviour.

2. Emitted by the unknown stimuli:

Operant behaviour which includes the arbitrary movements. Examples are Movement of one’s hand, arms or legs, A child abandoning  one toy in favour of another, eating a meal, writing a letter standing up and walking about, similar other everyday activities.

Stimulus is unknown & knowledge of the cause of the behaviour is not important.

Reinforcement

Generally there seems quite confusion about the relationship of Conditioning and Reinforcement. “Conditioning” is so called because it result in formation of conditioned responses. A conditioned response is a response which is associated with, or evoked by a new-conditioned-stimulus. Conditioning implies a principle of adhesion; one stimulus and response is attached to another stimulus or response so that revival of the first evokes the second.

Reinforcement is a special kind or aspect of conditioning with in which the tendency for a stimulus to evoke a response on subsequent occasion is increased by reduction of a need or of a drive stimulus. A “need” as used here is an objective, biological requirement of an organism which must be met if the organism is to survive and grow. A ‘drive stimulus” is an aroused state of an organism. I t is closely related to the needs which sets an organism into action and may be defined as a strong persistent stimulus which demands an adjusting response. When an organism is deprived of satisfaction of a need, drive stimuli occur.

Schedules of Reinforcement

There are two types of reinforcement schedules – continuous, and partial/intermittent (four subtypes of partial schedules)

A) Fixed Ratio (FR) – reinforcement given after every N the responses, where N is the size of the ratio (i.e., a certain number of responses have to occur before getting reinforcement).

b) Variable Ratio (VR) – the variable ration schedule is the same as the FR except that the ratio varies, and is not stable like the FR schedule. Reinforcement is given after every N the response, but N is an average.

c) Fixed Interval (FI) – a designated amount of time must pass, and then a certain response must be made in order to get reinforcement.

d) Variable Interval (VI) – same as FI but now the time interval varies.

The concept of reinforcement is identical to the presentation of a reward

Reinforcement is any event that strengthens or increases the behaviour it follows. Reinforcement is the process of strengthening behaviour through the use of rewarding consequences.

Skinner identified two types of reinforcing events – those in which a reward is given; and those in which something bad is removed. In either case, the point of reinforcement is to increase the frequency or probability of a response occurring again.

Kinds of reinforcement:

Positive Reinforcement

In Positive Reinforcement a particular behaviour is strengthened by the consequence of experiencing a positive condition. Positive reinforcement – give an organism a pleasant stimulus when the operant response is made. For example, a rat presses the lever (operant response) and it receives a treat (positive reinforcement)

Negative reinforcement

Negative reinforcement – take away an unpleasant stimulus when the operant response is made. For example, stop shocking a rat when it presses the lever.

Generally people use the term “negative reinforcement” incorrectly. It is NOT a method of increasing the chances an organism will behave in a bad way. It is a method of rewarding the behaviour you want to increase. It is a good thing – not a bad thing!

In Negative Reinforcement a particular behavior is strengthened by the consequence of stopping or avoiding a negative condition. . Positive Reinforcement uses rewarding stimuli, while Negative Reinforcement removes the aversive stimuli, to strengthen behaviors

Reinforcer:

A reinforcer is the stimulus the presentation or removal of which increases the probability of a response being repeated.

Kinds of rein forcers:

There are two kinds of rein forcers:

Positive Reinforcers:

Stimulus that naturally strengthens any response that precedes it (e.g., food, water, sex) without the need for any learning on the part of the organism. These reinforcers are naturally reinforcing Positive rein forcer is any stimulus the introduction or presentation of which increases the likelihood of a particular behaviour

Positive rein forcers are favourable events or outcomes that are presented after the behavior. It gives an organism a pleasant stimulus when the operant response is made. A response or behavior is strengthened by the addition of something, such as praise or a direct reward

Negative Reinforcers

A previously neutral stimulus that acquires the ability to strengthen responses because the stimulus has been paired with a primary reinforcer. For example, an organism may become conditioned to the sound of food dispenser, which occurs after the operant response is made. Thus, the sound of the food dispenser becomes reinforcing. Notice the similarity to Classical Conditioning, with the exception that the behaviour is voluntary and occurs before the presentation of a reinforcer.

Negative reinforcer is any stimulus the removal or withdrawal of which increases the likelihood of a particular behaviour. Educational context example is Teachers’ saying to the students that whoever does drill work properly in the class would be exempted from homework, Scolding students.  Negative reinforcers involve the removal of an unfavourable events or outcomes after the display of a behaviour. In these situations, a response is strengthened by the removal of something considered unpleasant.

In both of these cases of reinforcement, the behaviour increases.

Punishment

In Punishment a particular behaviour is weakened by the consequence of experiencing a negative condition. Punishment, on the other hand, is the presentation of an adverse event or outcome that causes a decrease in the behaviour it follows.

The process in which a behaviour is weakened, and thus, less likely to happen again. Consequences which are not reinforcing or do not strengthen behaviour and aims at reducing behaviours by imposing unwelcome consequences.

Skinner did not believe that punishment was as powerful a form of control as reinforcement, even though it is the very commonly used. Thus, it is not truly the opposite of reinforcement like he originally thought and the effects are normally short-lived.

Types of punishment:

Positive punishment, – sometimes referred to as punishment by application, involves the presentation of an unfavourable event or outcome in order to weaken the response it follows.

Reducing a behaviour by presenting an unpleasant stimulus when the behaviour occurs.  If the rat previously pressed the lever and received food and now receives a shock, the rat will learn not to press the lever.

Presentation of an aversive stimulus to decrease the probability of an operant response occurring again. For example, a child reaches for a cookie before dinner, and you slap his hand.

Negative punishment- also known as punishment by removal, occurs when an favourable event or outcome is removed after a behaviour occurs Reducing a behaviour by removing a pleasant stimulus when the behaviour occurs.  If the rat was previously given food for each lever press, but now receives food consistently when not pressing the lever (and not when it presses the lever), the rat will learn to stop pressing the lever.

In both of these cases of punishment, the behaviour decreases.

Reinforcements and Punishments

Whereas reinforcement increases the probability of a response occurring again, the premise of punishment is to decrease the frequency or probability of a response occurring again because learning take time in operant conditioning, reinforcement, develops approximations of the desired behaviour. Punishment, on the other hand, is the process of weakening or extinguishing behaviour through the use of aversive (or undesirable) consequences.

Reinforcements and punishments are categorized as positive/negative, primary/secondary and partial/continuous. Positive Reinforcement uses rewarding stimuli, while Negative Reinforcement removes the aversive stimuli, to strengthen behaviours. On the other hand, Positive Punishment uses aversive stimuli, while Negative Punishment removes rewarding stimuli, to weaken behaviors. Primary Reinforcements use rewarding stimuli that are innately satisfying, such as food, water and sex, while Secondary Reinforcements use rewarding stimuli that are learned (or conditioned), such as eye contact, a pat in the back or a smile. Token reinforcers, like money, for instance, may be exchanged for another reinforcing stimuli. On the other hand, Primary Punishments use aversive stimuli that are innately punishing, such as painful objects and poisonous substances, while Secondary Punishments use aversive stimuli that are learned (or conditioned), such as loss of trust and angry look from other people. Continuous Reinforcements use rewarding consequences all the time, while Partial Reinforcements use rewarding consequences only a portion of the time, in order to successfully establish association. Just the same, Continuous Punishments use aversive consequences all the time, while Partial Punishments use aversive consequences only a portion of the time, in order to successfully establish association.

Learning principles

Shaping

Shaping refers “the reinforcement of successive approximations to a goal behaviour”. This process requires the learner to perform successive approximations of the target behaviour by changing the criterion behaviour for reinforcement to become more and more like the final performance. In other words, the desired behaviour is reinforced each time only approximates the target behaviour.

The most general technique is called shaping, a process of reinforcing each form of the behaviour that more closely resembles the final version. It is used when students cannot perform the final version and are not helped by prompting. Shaping involves gradually changing the response criterion for reinforcement in the direction of the target behaviour.

Shaping is operant conditioning method for creating an entirely new behaviour by using rewards to guide an organism toward a desired behaviour (called Successive Approximations). In doing so, the organism is rewarded with each small advancement in the right direction. Once one appropriate behaviour is made and rewarded, the organism is not reinforced again until they make a further advancement, then another and another until the organism is only rewarded once the entire behaviour is performed. Technique of reinforcement used to teach new behaviours.   At the beginning, people/animals are reinforced for easy tasks, and then increasingly need to perform more difficult tasks in order to receive reinforcement For Example, to get a rat to learn how to press a lever; the experimenter will use small rewards after each behaviour that brings the rat toward pressing the lever. So, the rat is placed in the box. When it takes a step toward the lever, the experimenter will reinforce the behaviour by presenting food or water in the dish (located next to or under the lever). Then, when the rat makes any additional behaviour toward the lever, like standing in front of the lever, it is given reinforcement (note that the rat will no longer get a reward for just taking a single step in the direction of the lever). This continues until the rat reliably goes to the lever and presses it to receive reward.

Fading

Behaviours are acquired and exhibited because they are reinforced; non-reinforced behaviours tend not to occur. Individuals are clearly able to distinguish between settings in which certain behaviours will or will not be reinforced. The concept of fading refers to “the fading out of discriminative stimulus used to initially establish a desired behaviour” (Driscoll, 2000). The desired behaviour continues to be reinforced as the discriminative cues are gradually withdrawn.

Extinction

In Extinction a particular behaviour is weakened by the consequence of not experiencing a positive condition or stopping a negative condition. The elimination of the behaviour by stopping reinforcement of the behavior.  For example, a rat that received food when pressing a bar, receives food no longer, will gradually decrease the amount of lever presses until the rat eventually stops lever pressing.

Generalization

In generalization, a behaviour may be performed in more than one situation.  For example, the rat who receives food by pressing one lever may press a second lever in the cage in hopes that it will receive food.

Discrimination

Learning that a behaviour will be rewarded in one situation, but not another.  For example, the rat does not receive food from the second lever and realizes that by pressing the first lever only, he will receive food.

Chaining

The most complete acts are infecting a sequence o movements in which the Nth segment provides feedback stimuli (external and internal) which become discriminative for the next segment of the response. Thus the act may be thought of as a chain of small S-R Units.

Skinner also provided the explanation of the mechanism underlying the nature of complex learning. He proposed that the acquisition of complex behaviours is the result of the process referred to as chaining. Chaining establishes “complex behaviours made up of discrete, simpler behaviours already known to the learner”

Skinner’s position on typical Problems of Learning.

  1. Capacity- Skinner argues against the usefulness of a trait description in studying individual differences’ trait name does not refer to any unit of behaviour suitable for study through the functional analysis that he recommends. Thus Skinner would reject most ‘ personality tests’ saying that they provide useless characterisations of the person .Intelligence tests might be useful for educational decisions, since they sample directly the problem solving skills they purport to measure, but the tests do not tell us how to remedy specific educational disabilities.
  2. Practice- Sometimes like a simple law of exercise is accepted for Type S conditioning. The conditioning that occurs under Type R depends upon repeated reinforcement. The possibility is favoured that maximum reinforcement may occur in a single trial for the single operant, but the single operant is difficult to achieve experimentally. Usually, the accumulation of strength with repeated reinforcement depends upon a population of discriminated stimuli and a chain of related operant.
  3. Motivation-Reinforcement is necessary to increase operant strength. Punishment has a diverse range of effects, although typically it suppresses the response. Internal drives are viewed as relatively useless explanatory constructs, similar to personality traits. Skinner recognizes the effects of explicit deprivation variables on strength of operant’s  reinforced by that restricted commodity, but he claims that nothing is added to a functional analysis by talking about a ‘ drive’ intervening between deprivation operations and changes in strength of operant responses.
  4. Understanding- The word insight does not occur in Skinner’s writings. The emergence of the solution is to be explained on the basis of (1) similarity of the present problem to one solved earlier or (2) the simplicity of the problem. The technique of problem-solving is essentially that of manipulating variables which lead to emission of the response. It is possible to teach people to ‘think’ or ‘to creative ‘by these methods.
  5. Transfer-Skinner used the word induction for what is commonly called generalization. Such induction is the basis for transfer. He recognizes both primary and ‘secondary ‘or ‘mediated’ generalization. The reinforcement of a response increases the probability of that response or similar ones to all stimulus complexes containing the same elements. Included is feedback simulation from verbal labels; thus ,an overt response will  occur  to a novel object if some property of it controls a verbal label which in turn controls the overt response.

Educational Applications of Operant Conditioning

As a strong supporter of Programmed instruction and Teaching machine, Skinner thought that our education system was ineffective. He suggested that one teacher in a classroom could not teach many students adequately when each child learns at a different rate. He proposed using teaching machines (what we now call computers) that would allow each student to move at their own pace. The teaching machine would provide self-paced learning that gave immediate feedback, immediate reinforcement, identification of problem areas, etc. that a teacher could not possibly provide.

Operant conditioning is a vehicle for teachers to achieve behavior modification in order to improve classroom management and facilitate learning. There are three techniques employed in particular to facilitate learning: prompting, chaining, and shaping. Prompting involves giving students cues (called discriminative stimuli in the lexicon of operant conditioning) to help them perform a particular behavior. When students are learning to read, a teacher may help them by sounding out a word (just as when actors forget their lines, someone prompts them by saying their next line). Prompting helps to make the unfamiliar become more familiar, but, if used too often, students can become dependent on it, so teachers should withdraw prompts as soon as adequate student performance is obtained (a process called fading). Also, teachers should be careful not to begin prompting students until students try a performing task without extra help.

Learning complex behaviours can also be facilitated through an operant conditioning technique called chaining, a technique for connecting simple responses in sequence to form a more complex response that would be difficult to learn all at one time. Each cue or discriminative stimulus leads to a response that then cues the subsequent behaviour, enabling behaviours to be chained together

The most general technique is called shaping, a process of reinforcing each form of the behaviour that more closely resembles the final version. It is used when students cannot perform the final version and are not helped by prompting. Shaping involves gradually changing the response criterion for reinforcement in the direction of the target behaviour.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

EDUCATION OF THE DEPRIVED/ MARGINALIZED GROUPS

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V (P.G) College, Roorkee, India

It is widely acknowledged that education has an important role to achieve a greater degree of social justice. The educational institutions are expected to equip children to the best of their ability for securing a meaningful place in society and thus fostering a process of developing an egalitarian society. However, a large number of children are still excluded from the educational system and hence cannot participate meaningfully in the economic, social, political and cultural life of their communities.

Meaning of Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

The concept of Deprived/ Marginalized Groups   is generally used to analyse socioeconomic, political, and cultural spheres, where disadvantaged people struggle to gain access to resources and full participation in social life. In other words, marginalized people might be socially, economically, politically and legally ignored, excluded, or neglected, and, therefore vulnerable. Marginality’ is demeaning, for economic well-being, for human dignity, as well as for physical security.

Marginalization/deprived is generally described as the overt actions or tendencies of human societies, where people who they perceive to be undesirable or without useful function are excluded, i.e., marginalized. The people who are Deprived/ Marginalized are outside the existing systems of protection and integration. This limits their opportunities and means for survival.

Nature of Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Marginalization - [mahr-juh-nl-ahyz] is, to place in a position of marginal importance, influence, or power. Deprived/ marginalized is a multidimensional, multi-causal, historical phenomenon. To relegate or confine to a lower or outer limit or edge, as of social standing. There are no general laws to understand and comprehend the complex nature of marginalization.  Marginalization can be due to class, in relation to specific social, cultural, economic and political conditions, as well as ideological systems, social awareness, and human action.

Deprived/ Marginalized Groups vary in different settings. The religious, ecological system, patriarchy, political economy of a country, and the overall social system have an impact on the marginalization of specific groups or an individual.

Deprived/ Marginalized also varies from culture to culture. This can be seen in relation to elderly people living in different countries and cultures. The strong and supportive traditional family system in some cultures often provides better respect and care to elders than the public aided system available in others.

Level of awareness among the marginalized groups plays very important role. Organized communities which are aware of their rights, demand more justice than unorganized communities. This also depends upon the support of the political-economic system of the country where they live in. Democratic institutions are favourable for most of the disadvantaged groups.

Deprived/ Marginalized Groups happen simultaneously at the micro and macro levels. Deprived/ Marginalized Groups occurs at different levels, i.e., individual, group, community, and global. Discrimination across different social institutions, such as family, schools and neighbourhood, at work places, or places of worship. Many communities, a result of colonization, experience marginalization such as aboriginals, or women too face discrimination. Globalization too has increased the gap between rich and poor nations. The influx of capitalism, information technology, company outsourcing, job insecurity, and the widening gap between the rich and the poor, impacts the lives of individuals and groups in many capacities.

Types of Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Marginalization at the individual level results in an individual’s exclusion from meaningful participation in society.

Some broad types of Deprived/ Marginalized Groups such as social, economic, and political have been identified.

i)  Socially Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Social marginalisation is a process of social rupture or destruction, in which groups as well as individuals alike become detached from various types of social functions and relations. This generally prevents these people from functioning in the so called normal activities within a society. The individual is forced into a new system of rules while facing social stigma and stereotypes from the dominant group in society.  Socially marginalized people are largely deprived of social opportunities. There are those born into marginal groupings e.g., lower castes in India, or members of ethnic groups suffer discrimination. This marginality is typically for life. They lack the required social and cultural capital to participate in mainstream development processes. Their social networks are weak and vulnerable. They are deprived of access to resources, such as, economic, educational, cultural, and other support systems. This creates social isolation and limits their participation in the development process.

ii) Economically Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Economic marginalization” means being unimportant to the economy. Some individuals or groups can be marginalized from the rest of the economy. The sources and amount of their income varies. Poverty and economic marginalization have both direct and indirect impact on people’s health and wellbeing.

iii) Politically Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Political marginalization does not allow the group to participate democratically in decision making, and, hence, they lose their right to every social, economic, and political benefit.  In every society, lack of political empowerment affects large sections of people, including women, ethnic minorities, migrants, and disabled persons, elderly.

Reasons responsible for Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Some of the important factors that are responsible for marginalization are exclusion, globalization, displacement, and disaster both natural, and manmade.

i) Exclusion: Marginalization is a process that denies opportunities and outcomes to ‘those ‘living on the margins’, while enhancing the opportunities and outcomes for those who are ‘at the centre’. Deprived/ Marginalized combines discrimination and social exclusion. It offends human dignity, and it denies human rights. Caste and class prejudice, in many societies across the globe, exclude many groups and communities, and hinder their active participation in economic and social development.

ii) Globalization: Globalization has increased openness which has promoted development at the cost of equity. It is viewed that globalization has enhanced the gap between haves and have-nots and thus boosted marginalization. While it is true that some middle income developing countries, as well as the most populous countries, India and China, are gaining out of globalization, yet the impact is not equally universal.

iii) Displacement: The development programmes implemented by the government and increasing construction of development projects consistently displace a massive number of tribal, poor, and weaker sections. This results in marginalization of already marginalized people.

iv) Disasters- Natural and Unnatural: Disasters are a global phenomena and a serious challenge to development. Vulnerability is linked to broader social issues such as poverty, social exclusion, conflict, education, health, gender issues and marginalization.

Classifications of disasters.

Natural: earthquake, volcanic eruption, hurricane, tornado, ice storm, flood, landslide, wildfire, insect infestation, and disease outbreaks.

Manmade: Can be associated with technological advances, i.e., explosives, unexploded ordinance, toxic spills, emissions of radioisotopes, and transportation accidents. It also includes incidents involving hazardous materials such as carcinogens, mutagens, or heavy metals. Dangers are posed by structural failure of devices and machines or installations, and plants, such as bridges, dams, mines, power plants, pipelines, high rise buildings, vehicles, and trains.

Social: These include incidents primarily involving social unrest, such as hijacking, riots, demonstrations, crowd rushes, and stampedes, terrorist incidents, as well as bombings, shootings, and hostage taking.

Most vulnerable Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Some of the most vulnerable marginalized groups in almost every society are:

i) Women: Under different economic conditions, and under the influence of specific historical, cultural, legal and religious factors, marginalization of women can be seen from their exclusion from certain jobs and occupations. Women belonging to lower classes, lower castes, illiterate, and the poorest region have been marginalized more than their better off counterparts.

ii) People with Disabilities:  People with disabilities have had to battle against centuries of biased assumptions, harmful stereotypes, and irrational fears. The stigmatization of disability resulted in the social and economic marginalization of generations with disabilities, and thus has left people with disabilities in a severe state of impoverishment for centuries.

iii) Elderly: Being past middle age and approaching old age; rather old. S Ageing is an inevitable and inexorable process in life. For most nations, regardless of their geographic location or developmental stage, the 80 year olds, or over-age group is growing faster than any younger segment of the older population. Elderly women form the majority of marginalized groups among them.

iv) Ethnic minority: – a group that has different national or cultural traditions from the majority of the population the term, ethnic minority, refers to marginalised people of the same race or nationality who share a distinctive culture. A minority is a sociological group that does not constitute a politically dominant voting majority of the total population of a given society. It may include any group that is subnormal with respect to a dominant group, in terms of social status, education, employment, wealth, and political power. Every large society contains ethnic minorities. They may be migrant, indigenous or landless nomadic communities, or religious minorities that have a different faith from the majority.

v) Caste Groups: The caste system is a strict hierarchical social system based on underlying notions of purity and pollution. Brahmins are on the top of the hierarchy and Shudras or Dalits orthe Scheduled Castes constitute the bottom of the hierarchy. The marginalization of Dalits influences all spheres of their life, violating basic human rights such as civil, political, social, economic and cultural rights. Literacy rates, purchasing power and poor housing conditions among Dalits are very low. Physical segregation of their settlements is common. However, in recent years due to affirmative action and legal protection, the intensity of caste-based marginalization is reducing.

vi) Tribes: In India, the population of Scheduled Tribes is around 84.3 million and is considered to be socially and economically disadvantaged group. They are mainly landless with little control over resources such as land, forest and water. They constitute agricultural, casual, plantation and industrial labourers. This has resulted in poverty, low levels of education and poor access to health care services. In the Indian context the marginalized are categorized as the scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, denoted tribes, nomadic tribes, and other backward classes.

Problems Related to Education for Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

The challenge of poverty associated with disability: With an estimated 1,027 million people, India is the world’s second most populated country. It has 17 percent of the global population and 20 percent of the world’s out-of-school children. Despite impressive gains in the last few decades India still has more than 260 million people living in poverty. A large number of children with disabilities live in families with income significantly below the poverty level.   While disability causes poverty, it is also possible that in a country like India, poverty causes disability. The combination of poverty and disability results in a condition of “simultaneous deprivation. This is a syndrome that sets up barriers to the participation of persons with disabilities in the normal routines and activities of the community, including regular schooling.

The challenge of modifying deeply held attitudes: Attitudes of the non-disabled are proving to be a major barrier in the social integration of persons with disabilities. “The more severe and visible the deformity is, the greater is the fear of contagion, hence the attitudes of aversion and segregation towards the crippled”. Such attitudes reinforced by religious institutions may militate against any attempts to include students with disabilities into regular schools. For example, Hindus believe that disability is a consequence of misdeeds performed in the previous life (often referred to as the doctrine of Karma. Any attempts to improve the life of a person with a disability may be considered a “defiance of the wills of Allah or as interference with a person’s karma”

Dissemination and public education: People, including parents and school personnel, are largely unaware of the full intent of the recent legislation passed by Indian Parliament. A large number of school personnel are also not aware of funding available to include students with disabilities in regular schools. There is some evidence that those educators who are knowledgeable about government policies and laws concerning integrated education tend to have positive attitudes toward implementing such programs. There is also evidence when parents are knowledgeable and supportive of integrated education; they tend to have a positive effect on school personnel. Thus, unless people, especially parents of children with disabilities and school personnel, are made knowledgeable about the various provisions enshrined in the Act, the Central and State governments’ commitment to providing integrated education will be in vain. Although some attempts are being made to disseminate information about the Persons with Disabilities Act to parents, to government officials and non government organizations, they have been extremely limited in coverage.

The challenge of providing adequate levels of training to key stakeholders: The majority of school personnel in India are not trained to design and implement educational programs for students with disabilities in regular schools. Most teacher training programs in India do not have a unit on Disability Studies. The universities, which do cover some aspects of special education in their teacher training programs, fail to train teachers adequately to work in integrated settings

Inadequate resources: The majority of schools in India are poorly designed and few are equipped to meet the unique needs of students with disabilities. The lack of disability friendly transportation services and accessible buildings are considered by some to be far greater problems than social prejudice and negative attitudes. Both the Central and State governments will have to provide increased resources to this aspect of education to ensure successful implementation of integrated practices in schools.

Education of the Marginalized Deprived/ Marginalized Groups in the Indian Context

The Education Commission 1964-66 in its report stressed on the equalization of educational opportunity. One of the most important objectives of education is to equalize opportunity enabling the marginalized, backward or the underprivileged classes to use education for improvement of their conditions. Policies on education 1968, 1986 and 1992 all stressed upon speedy action for the promotion education of the deprived sections of the society.

Mainstreaming the Marginalized. Deprived/ Marginalized Groups

Mainstreaming is the process, to integrate (a student with special needs) into regular school classes. To incorporate into a prevailing group. The prevailing current of thought, influence, or activity. Representing the prevalent attitudes, values, and practices of a society or group.

Efforts have been made to reach education to all. However, there is wastage and stagnation in education. There are economic, social and educational causes that hinder the education of children coming from lower strata of society.

Incentives to families to send their children regularly to schools till they reach the age of 14.

Pre-metric scholarships for all children regardless of incomes.

Constant micro planning and verification to ensure enrolment, retention and successful completion of courses.

Remedial measures to better their chances for further education and employment.

Recruitment of teachers from scheduled castes.

Provision of hostel facilities.

Location of school buildings, balwadis, and adult education centres to facilitate participation especially in rural areas, hill and desert districts or remote and inaccessible areas.

Priority given to opening schools in tribal areas with help of tribal welfare schemes.

Developing curricula and instructional materials in tribal languages with facility to switch to regional language. Also

The curricula in the states to depict rich cultural identity of the tribal people.

Teacher training to tribal youth with assured employment.

Residential schools including ashram schools, anganwadis, non formal and adult education centres to open on priority basis.

Incentive schemes, scholarships for higher education with emphasis on technical, professional and Para-professional courses.

Remedial programmes to help overcome psycho-social impediments.

 

The marginalized/deprived groups existing in society have historically suffered deprivation in all walks of life in general and in education in particular. Efforts have been made towards economic, social and educational progress of the marginalized people of India. The examination reforms have been suggested right from the time of independence by various committees set up for the purpose There is great diversity in the population and the government of India has passed regulations with respect to inclusion of all irrespective of any kind of disability. There are efforts to provide equal opportunities and inclusion of all in the process of education.

Not only are we aware of the vital role that education plays in counteracting disadvantages over which people have little control, but also its important role in shaping their opportunities for education and wider life chances.

Protecting the rights of, marginalised and vulnerable persons is probably the most overlooked and disregarded area of human rights law. Marginalised groups are generally marginalised by society, making them easy to ignore. Since they only ever represent a small percentage of the population they lack the critical mass that is often needed to successfully assert human rights claims. Furthermore marginalised themselves are often antagonistic towards each other.

There is a need to draw attention to unacceptable levels of education inequality across countries and between groups

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Concept of Education

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

Education

There are a lot of contradictions regarding the meaning of education. The fact responsible for this contradiction is lack of uniformity in the meaning of education. Every debater looks at its meaning in a unique form, because its sense has underwent such a massive change since earliest times that its very assumption has become quite misleading. Therefore, it is essential that the assumption of education should be explained at the very outset.

Webster defines education as the process of educating or teaching. Educate is further defined as “to develop the knowledge, skill, or character of …” Thus, from these definitions, we might assume that the purpose of education is to develop the knowledge, skill, or character of students. Unfortunately, this definition offers little unless we further define words such as develop, knowledge, and character.

Etymologically the term EDUCATION has been derived from different sources-

  1. Educate means the art of teaching of teaching or training
  2. The other way of explaining the term of Latin E means to ‘lead forth out of and duco means I lead, ; thus; education may be interpreted to means to ‘lead forth’
  3. Etymological Meaning from etymological point of view, the Hindi word ‘shiksha’ has been derived from the Sanskrit verb ‘shiksh’ which mean ‘to learn’. Thus, education mend both learning and teaching. In the Raghuvansh, the term ‘education’ has been used in these two senses. In India languages, the terms ‘vidya’ and jnana’ have been used as synonyms to the term ‘shiksha’. The term ‘vidya’ has been derived from the verb ‘vid’ which means ‘to’ know, to find out, to learn’, but later, this was fixed for ‘curriculum’. In the beginning, four subjects were included under viday, but later, Manu added the fifth, called Atma Vidya, and gradually, this number rose to fourteen, which included Vedas, Vedangas, Dharma, Nyaya, Mimansa etc. Thus, ‘vidya’ means both curriculum and learning.

 

4 .The term ‘janja’ means the same as education in its wide sense in Indian philosophy. In Indian philosophies, the term ‘jnana’ is not used for only information or facts, though in the west, this sense is The term ‘janja’ means the same as education in its wide sense in Indian philosophy. In Indian philosophies, the term ‘jnana’ is not used for only information or facts, though in the west, this sense is quite prevalent. In the Amarkosha, the terms ‘jnana’ and ‘vijnana’ have been distinguished saying that is reated with emancipation while ‘vijnana’ is reated with crafts. In other words, jnana or knowledge is that which develops man and illuminates his path to emancipation, while whatever is learnt and known in practical life is called vijnana or science.

 

On the other hand, his the English term ‘education’ has been derived from the Latin word ‘education’. On analysis, it gives out the following meaning:

English-education

Latin-education k=e+duco

Meaning-to lead=from within+to lead out

Assumption of education: To bring out inherent capabilities of a child

 

Some scholars opine that the term ‘education’ has been derived from the Latin words ‘educere’ or ; however, from etymological sense, all three to these are no different in meaning.

 

The definition of education in an act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, and generally of preparing oneself or other intellectually for mature like. It It could be a certain degree, level or kind of schooling. It is a training imply a discipline and development by means of the special and general abilities of the mind or a training by which people learn to develop and use their mental, moral, and physical power or skill. It is a gaining experience, either improving or regressing. Actually Education is a deliberate and organized activity though which the physical, intellectual, aesthetic, moral and spiritual potentialities of the child are developed, both in the intellectual, aesthetic, moral and spiritual potentialities of the child are developed, both in the individual as an individual and also as a member of society so that he may lead the fullest and richest life possible in this world and finally attain his ultimate end in the world to come.

 

Education is very essential in everyday to be able to cope and survive whatever the difficulties and complication may experience. Without education, life can be so hard and frustrating in every aspect.

The instances of education can be from school, society or home Internet, or anywhere. It is necessary that everyone needs to go to school, to learn academically and socially. If help build up confidence in every person, if gives a high self-esteem as well. Also, we need to educate oneself in the society, so that we are aware in catastrophic situation. To know what’s going on around us, it is an advantage to be one of the biggest technologies that revolve around the word, from researching or communicating. It is a big help to explore and educate our self to the word of technology. It is a big help discipline, patient, time hard-work and effort. With these important behavioral qualities, it will be easier ot deal with life. Education doesn’t require a perfect physical appearance but it requires attention and focus. Having the knowledge in everything, it refers to a high intellect power, a power that ready for anything. The skills to educate our self is something that we couldn’t share to anyone but we could extend if is some ways.

 

Technically, education is really important and it is a necessity for us, to have a better life and a better future. We need to get the best of education that we want to, it is worth it to have the knowledge, and intellect the capacity to participate in the word and it can change our life tremendously.

 

Mostly education is accepted as a learning and training process which is applied in school.

 

In the past few years, another sense of education has come to be applied, according to which education is looked at as an or a science  of guidance and teacher-training departments.

The above point of view is clear to a great extent, but there is an element of ambiguity in it. When the meaning of education is analyzed in the context of the time spent in school, refined form for behavior and other points of view, a need for developing a clearer meaning of education is felt. Thus, the environment in which education is imparted, and the form of for giving a distinct meaning of education, on the above basis, it become essential in the context of its meaning, nature and scope.

 

Assumption of Education

In fact, man continues to learn lifelong and he evolves on its basis.

School provides a definite direction to this evolution, but school education in included under the wide form of education.

 

Every living being takes birth in the universe in one or the other species, and he learns certain activities during his existence. These activities are not limited to only adjustment with the prevailing circumstances; rather they also cultivate a capability to concept of hedonism. This capability of construct is called education.

 

The term ‘Education’ is applied for knowledge, for a process in physiological and psychological behavioral change and for studying as a subject under the curriculum.

 

When the term ‘education’ is applied for knowledge, its scope is pervasive all through the universe. Each element of the universe becomes its component. In this form, the scope of education has no limit.

The term ‘education’ is applied as a process for bringing about behavioral  change in man. In this form too, ,it is used in two senses: in wider sense and in narrow sense. In its wider sense, educational process has education three components: teacher, student and social environment. All these three education elements are equally important.

 

As a subject, under education are studied different components of education process, like teacher, student, social sentiment and curriculum.

Meaning and Nature of Education

For a common man, education is synonym to literacy in which a person is supposed to elicit a specific behavior. In his view, a literate of education person should necessarily have specific civil living style, conversation style. Manners, clothing language etc.

Education is biologically and philosophically evolved, psychologically developed and socially based. It has various dimensions. It will be interesting to see it different perspectives.

 

Education in social Perspective

In social context, the meaning of education can be taken only on one basis, that is whither to attach importance to man’s happiness or society happiness. In the wider perspective, education encompasses not only individual but also the whole universe.

As education process is adopted in each society for its development during a period under consideration, which is a replanted individual. Each society places before itself certain human ideals which determine an individual intellectual physical and moral behavior. This idealism is the basis of education. A society can live when its members are quite uniform. The basic manners or norms of norms of behavior which are necessary for community life are made uniform by education, it also strengthens these manners. It is education but the uniformity is relative.

Thus, education is that process which is imparted to those generations which are not yet ready for social life. It is aimed for creating and expected by political society.

Thus the above standpoint means that the systematic socialization of young generation is inherent in education.

Education in Moral perspective

The moral context comprises many aspects, such as guidance, direction, rules, codes of conduct and behaviors etc.

Morality is analyzed in the context of three eternal values: Satya (truth), Shiv (goodness) and Sundar is (beauty ). Satya, shiv and sunder cannot be explained, they are eternal for all ages. What is morality? It is the highest aim of humanity What objective is it that which creates bliss. Whose crates bliss. whose bliss is it? That of individual or universe. Education is an effort to explain these contexts. Therefore, from moral point of view, education can be called a novel synthesis of certain characteristics, attitudes, aptitude and habits in objective way. Thus education can be called the establishment of this type of thinking by which values can become meaningful only when both means and end are sacred, the doe and the soon are good , and which does good of both individual and universe.

 

Education in Biological Perspective

When a child is born, he is no different from an animal biologically. Later, his social personally undergoes a change according to the social assumptions. In fact it is behavior of an animal or a man is governed as per the by innate disposition, while that of a social individual is governed as per the social assumptions. The society has assigned this responsibility of behavioral modification to schools. This behavior medication is called education, which is realized through interaction between teacher and students.

Education in Spiritual Perspective

In spiritual context, education is looked in three forms: knowledge, learning and science. Knowing the truth is dependent on methods. Science is based on matter. Philosophy is based on thought.

All that knowledge which is based on spiritual field is called learning, and is accepted as the only means of attaining emancipation.

Sa Vidya Ya Vimuktaye.

(Education is that which emancipates.)

Therefore, is spiritual context, education means the attainment of learning, which prepares for the future. In the context of science, the attainment of knowledge based on matter can be called education, and it is related to the present situation.

In both its wide and narrow senses, education is a social process. Man is born with certain faculties. These facilities are developed and refined in the physical and social environment, and human behavior and thinking too undergo specific changes. The development of entire human civilization and culture occurs in the social environment itself. Educational process cannot exist in the absence of social environment.

In its narrow sense, education is limited to school life, but in its actual sense, it continues lifelong, from birth till death. Man begins to learn right from his birth and he keeps acquiring some learning with every experience of life. Thus, continuity is one of its characteristics.

Generally, educational process takes place between tow aspects: one who is influenced and one who influences. On its basis, John Adams has accepted education as a bipolar process. According to him, these two poles of education are student and teacher. John Dewey too accepts tow components of education, he has termed them psychological and psychological and social aspects. Sometimes, social environment is accepted as the third pole of education, which makes education a tripolar process which are student, teacher and curriculum.

Man’s behavior at birth is just like an animal’s. He wants to effect changes to his behavior living in the social environment. This process of modification is called education .Thus, man effect his development by education, at the same time, he constructs a basis for transmitting learning to the next generation. Thus, the civilization and culture of a race of community is developed.

Any type of education proceeds ahead accepting social changes. Its aims, objectives, curriculum and teaching process are influenced by social needs. This influence makes education dynamic.

different meanings of educationThough the above diagram explains different senses of education, yet it is necessary that their systematic analysis should be carried out.

In the Amarkosha, the term ‘education’ is used as one of the parts of the Vedas. At that time, the aim of education was to teach correct pronunciation of the Vedic rhymes. Perhaps, the reading the studying of Vedas was only aim of education, therefore education become a fixed term for the science of speech.

Education as a process – Education is conscious and deliberate process in which one personality acts another in order to modify the development to that other by the communication and manipulation of knowledge Adams. Thus education is the process of living through a continuous reconstruction of experience. It is the development of all those capacities in the individual which will enable him to control his environment and fulfill his capacities an individual as a result of his interaction with the environment constitutes learning. The child learns through his experience. His gains experience, when he comes in contact with different social institutions, persons, places and things. There is no end to thie experience. It goes on forever without any break or barrier. thus, education becomes and active and dynamic process. It is much more than schooling, memorizing or learning a prescribed syllabus. Therefore J.S.Mackenzie  rightly says. "Education is a process that goes on though out life and is promoted by almost every experience in life." Thus the child goes on recons trusting experiences throughout the whole life. When the learn comes in contact with real situation, he utility all his part experiences that are relevant to it and gains new experience throughout the whole life. Therefore, education is considered by the educationists an active and dynamic process.

Education as a product – Education may also be considered as a product… A person is said to be educated, when he acquires knowledge, skills attitude etc. Which are the product of group life at a great cost of time and suffering. Education becomes a product only when it is used. As assimilation of the culture of any society and its transference  from one generation to another. As such it perpetuates and give continuity to the society.

Since culture is dynamic in nature, education fosters to the people, the values, which are universally accepted as valuable at particular point of time. For example, in the present day world, scientific attitude, spirit of inquiry of habit of co-operation are accepted as desirable values. Therefore, education should inculcate these values n the minds of the people.

Formal and Informal Education

The Definition of education is living life. We are constantly being educated, regardless of age or race. There are two types of education: formal and informal. Formal education is what a person receives from the age of five in structured classrooms, be it public or private, through college. the quality of this formal education solely depends on where one may live, or how much money one’s parents may have. Public educations are a hit or miss. The school system may be well reputed, but there will be classrooms in these systems that aren’t up to par. This could be for man reasons; inexperienced teachers, teacher burnout, very disruptive students, and the list could go on. There is not a national standard, so schools across our country are completely different. A child, therefore, gets a formal education, through schools, but not necessarily ne of excellence.

The second type of education is informal. People of all ages receive thids type of education throughout their lives. Let’s begin from birth. Babies are taught from birth, First how to suckle. They are taught how to eat, talk, and walk usually by family. Each year of life brings about different types of informal education. Don’t doubt there aren’t things being learned on the playground in play groups. In every sports arena coaches are dispersing wisdom. Sunday school classes across the nation are guiding children through the doctrine of their particular faith.

Narrow and Broader Meaning of Education

Education is a Dynamic concept. Therefore divergent view have been expressed by the eminent scholars from Socrates to Plato from Dewey to Gandhi. Because of its dynamic nature, there is no common agreement o the question of education .People look upon it differently according to their personal interests and expectations, when a parent desires his child to achieve material progress in life and to earn name and fame, another parent may expect him to prosper spiritually to realize the self. When an educational administrator desires his son to complete course within a limited time and to pass examination, a teacher desire him to master the subject matter. A statesman may desire the child to be trained as an ideal citizen. Thus, the significance of the meaning of the education of differs from person to person. It is also a continuous process, which being at a particular point of life and ends at another point. This point of beginning the point of end of education fifers in narrower and broader sense.

The common sense of education is very narrow. It includes only school. The community makes it still narrower when only intellectual knowledge experiences are included in it, and all those experiences which are imparted at school other than falling under intellectual aspect, are called co-curricular activities. Thus, in common sense, education means only school instruction.

However, in the past few years, a change has become perceptible in educational thought. As a result of which, co-curricular activities have been attached importance, and they are not considered extra-curricular activities. They are accepted as those activities which are run concurrently with education are educational curriculum.

Narrow Meaning of Education- Establishing the meaning of education, however special and specific, must begin with consideration of it essential nature. In order to establish its essential nature and distinguish it from the various forms of education, one must first of all distinguish between spontaneous incidental education, and the planned organized and formalized education provided in schools, colleges and universities. Education becomes wider in the former sense and narrow in the latter sense.

Education in narrow sense is a planned, organized and formalized process. It is imparted at a particular place (school, college or university) and at a definite time. It is also imparted to definite persons (the students). Its curriculum too is formal. The amount of education received by the child is measured –in terms of number and grade of examination passed by him. The teacher makes deliberate efforts to inculcate certain values, attitudes or habits in the children which are considered to be most essential and useful.

The teacher in narrow sense aims at producing the literate man, professional man, bureaucrat, mechanic, politician or a religious man or to produce a thinking or intellectual man. Thus, man is deliberately ‘taught to think’ as the teacher thinks. It is a specific influence brought to bear upon the child with a definite purpose, in a pre-planned, suitable and methodical manner, According to John Stuart Mill, "In narrow sense education means the culture, which each generation purposely gives to its successors in order to qualify, to keep up and to improve the level attained. It includes whatever we do for ourselves and whatever is done for us by others for the purpose of bringing up somewhat nearer to the perfection of the nature." Thus, in narrow sense, education is nothing but a purpose for activity deliberately planned for the optimum development of an individual’s potentialities. To quote T. Reymont "In the narrow sense in which the term is used in common speech and in legal enactments education does not include self-culture and the general influences of one’s surroundings but only those special influences which are consciously and deliberately brought to bear younger by the adult person of the community, whether trough the family the church or the state."

 

Broader Meaning of Education

In wide sense, education is a process of all-round development which runs lifelong. The pragmatist philosopher John Dewey and Indian educational thinker Mahatma Gandhi are of the view that education is a lifelong process and the changes which occur within us as a result of experiences occur due to education. From this point of view, the experiences which are attained outside the four walls of school are also included under education. When this wide sense of education is accepted, all desirable or undesirable influences and experiences are included which a child gets from the family, society, community, state, religion, peer group, films, means of communication etc, which are called informal agencies. This reduces the role of school to a secondary place, and education jumps out of human control, and it makes difficult to determine the definite direction of child’s development.

Both common and wide senses present incomplete and vague analysis of education. In real, sense, education is the chronological and systematic development of a child’s personality. Physiological development of a child is governed automatically, and the traits that he acquires from heredity become mature with the growth of mind and body. However, the development of a child’s inherent personality can be possible only by conscious effort. Personality is an outcome of heredity and environment in which heredity is constant because the traits obtained from parents cannot be changed, thought they influence personality all thought life, environment is variable and this environment has to be controlled in order to effect desired development of child’s personality.

Thus, education is a product of action-reaction between tow important elements: Heredity and environment. Every child is born with certain facilities and capabilities right from birth which expresses his reaction to words physical and social environment.

Education, in the wider sense, is used for the purpose of teaching people all characteristics which will enable them to live and act like normal and civilized human beings n the society.

In the wider sense, education is not limited to a classroom or school only. There is no time limit for the purpose. It is rather a ‘life-long affair’. The point of beginning of this ‘continuous education’ is conception and the point of end is death. Every platform of lie –the playground, the library, the temple, the office, the market, the sea shore, the hotel etc. educate the individual. All the event, and experience, knowledge and wisdom, an individual….acquires during infancy, childhood, adolescence, youth manhood or old age through different channels of education (incidental, formal and non-formal) is education.

In this broad sense, life is education and education is life. “Whatever broadens or horizon, deepens our insight, refines our reaction and stimulates our thought and feeling, educates us.” In the process of living, and individual is both a teaches and a taught. He received education in two ways. One type of education; he receives from other and another he gives to himself from his experience. Education in wider sense includes all our experiences whatever we do, think or say educate us.

Thus, in the broader sense “Education is neither teaching nor instruction. Instruction is an artificial and limited activity. It influences the child only in a limited time and place. But life-long education goes on influencing an individual throughout his life.” Instruction ends in the classroom, but education ends only with life

Innate and Acquired Education

According to yet another standpoint, behavior is of two types: natural or innate behavior and acquired or social behavior. Education is behavioral change. When a child takes birth, he is no different from an animal, as per the biological standpoint, because his behavior is governed by innate tendencies; however, his behavior becomes as per social assumptions gradually. An animal-man’s behavior is governed by his innate tendencies while that of the social-man as per the social assumptions or approvals. Thus, education is to modify the behavior of an animal-man into social-man. The society in which an individual takes birth, learns several behaviors and sanctifies according to that. These activates are not limited to only adjustment with the environment, but they are capable of construction favorable circumstances. This construction is based on hedonism.

 

Thus, each society assigns the responsibility of behavioral change according to its social goal to schools, where teacher (mature personality) and students (immature personality) interact mutually, and thus teacher transforms a child into a social and mature personality.

According to J.D.Butler, education is such an activity or endeavor in which more mature people of human society make an effort for more maturity of the latest mature people, and thus, contribute in making human life better.

This process of behavioral change by education is laid down by three poles : objectives or goals, means and evidences.

It is evident from the above figure that a teacher has certain goals of behavioral change as per the social assumption, to realize which he provides learning experiences to a student through such means as curriculum and methods of teaching, and then compiles evidences by educational tests, on the basis of which evaluation is undertaken to find out how far the objectives have been realized, how effective the learning experiences have been. Thus, the last pole provides feed back to the other two poles.

Though all the above meaning of education are distinct from each other, yet they all are related to human development, change or learning in essence. However, the term ‘education’ has come to be applied in altogether different context too. Today, the term ‘education’ is also used as ‘subject’ or ‘discipline’. As a discipline, also called education or science of education, it comprises of different components of education, such as teacher, student, curriculum, method of teaching, evaluation, testing, objectives etc. for intensive study in training colleges and universities. Thus, the subject of ‘education’’ is a private curriculum which is taught at academic level in Inter, BA and MA classed and in professional class of B.ED.

 

Besides, the term ‘education’ is also used to mean training, because the teaching of ‘education’ at professional level of preparing future teachers is taught for providing theoretical knowledge as well as practical knowledge, so that they become adept in the art of teaching. This training is imparted in real time school conditions.

 

Nature and Characteristics of Education

The above discussion brings to the fore the following characteristics of education:

 

Education is a social process. Though man is born with certain innate traits and faculties, yet his development depends on social interaction in social environment. Each society formulates educational objectives as per its assumptions. Thus, education is a total in the hands of a society or community which transforms as animal-man into a social-man in order to realize its social goals.

The means employed are commensurate to the end to be realized. Therefore, educational objectives and curriculum to the etc. undergo a change according to social needs. Thus, education assumes dynamism. In wide sense, education is a lifelong process. Man continues to learn from every life experience. Thus, continuity is one of its characteristics.

Education is described as a bipolar process. According to it, education is performed between two poles, which are teacher and student in which teacher make a conscious effort to bring about desirable change in a student’s personality. This becomes possible by two means : teacher’s personality and his knowledge.

The above diagram presents the interaction between teacher-student as a one-way process. It appears that the teacher produces the change while the student receives it. It appears as if the teacher remains unaffected by this change. This type of  absence is not seen in the process as described in the Kathopanishad. This treatise describes the teaching process in these words:

“Both teacher and student are helpful in each other’s morel development and protect each other from possible fall”.

They should consume together, that is, they should consume the acquired traits together. It means that knowledge or learning in augmented together.

They should enhance each other’s vigor.

They should become better as a result of study.

They should not envy each other”

They above discussion make the process two-way, which can be presented as follows:

  1. Teacher
  2. Teaching process
  3. Student

On the other hand, John Dewey has described education as a tripolar process, the three poles of which are: teacher, student and social influences. In fact, social influences present the subject matter as per the society, which is called curriculum in its extensive sense

  1. Teacher
  2. Student
  3. Curriculum
  4. Teaching process

The term ‘education’ is also used in the context of ‘discipline’ and ‘training’. Generally all subject and disciplines are divided into two classed: art and science as per their nature. From this point of view, education is both art and science.

In Hindi, the term ‘art’ means which brings bliss. All those activities which beget bliss fall under the class of art, such as music, dance, poetry, literature, drawing sculpture etc. Art influences all three domains: cognitive domain, effective domain and psycho-motor domain. It is the mind which makes feel joy or bliss. Education is also related to knowledge, emotions and activity aspects, respectively called cognitive, effective and psycho-motor domains. And a teacher also takes joy in his teaching as an artist takes joy in his creation.

On the other hand, education is also a science. The scope of science is external world and it is used in the steps of experimentation, analysis and inference etc., and as it is related with intellectual human being as against the matter, education cannot be used as a science; though some psychologists have conducted successful experiments on dogs, mice, cats, chimpanzees etc., and gave deduced inferences which are taught as fundamental principles of education. These principles provide a solid scientific basis to education despite certain limitations and exceptions.

Functions of Education

In the words of Daniel Webster “The function of education is to discipline feeling, to control emotions to stimulate motivation and develop religious sentiments”.

In the words of John Dewey “the function of education is to help the growing of a helpless young animal into a happy, moral and efficient human being”.

Basically; education means “what education is”?

Function of education means:-“what education does”

There are three main functions of education which are as follows :–

 

Preservation function of Education- The main function of education is to preserve and protect the old values, customs, beliefs, traditions, etc. Education shows the path of righteous living and guides us how to preserve the old education ideas and how to organize the educational system of a country in such a way that one makes progressive development in every field. It includes fulfillment of public and civic duties and also the preservation, protection and propagation of national cultural.

.

In the words of Pt. Nehru, “Education must help in preserving the vital elements of our heritage. The core of India’s cultural heritage is love of beauty and truth, spirit of tolerance, capacity to absorb earlier cultures and work out new synthesis.”

As a matter of fact, it is the duty of education to educate people of the country to preserve the precious old. In a way education acts as the custodian of the culture. The cultural heritage is a great wealth which has been gathered with great labour over a number of centuries. This precious wealth has to be preserved with a greater care than we devote to material wealth

Transmission function of Education- Another important function of education is to transmit the best preserved traditions of thoughts is and actions (i.e the cultural heritage) from one generation to another.

Education plays an important role. It transfers knowledge, ideologies, theories, principles and attributes from one generation to another and thus contributes greatly to the general progress of society. In the words of Ottaway, “One of the tasks of education is to handover the cultural values and the behavior pattern of society to the young potential members.” Education helps in creating favorable atmosphere to pass on the best experiences of the race to the next generation.

 

Enrichment function of Education-Education also helps in enriching the existing cultural heritage by making use of latest technologies in the field of education which are invented for adding novelty so that the concept become more enriched for the learner. Actually each generation had to enrich its predecessors otherwise no intellectual or social development would be possible and the present state of the society would be no different from the society of the Old Stone Age.”

 

Education provides opportunities to recognize and restructure human experiences and as a result of this, there is development of human civilization and culture. Through education cultural groups strive for the enrichment of their lives.

 

Theories of Education

The jet theory of education.

 

Education is the outcome of man’s desire to preserve and promote his heritage and transmit it to be oncoming generation. His heritage is as old as his civilized life. So also his education. In the early period, knowledge was considered as the centre of instruction. All educational effort was directed towards the acquisition of knowledge only. A person could work as a teacher, only when he could master some branches of know knowledge only. A person could work as a teacher, only when he could master some branches of knowledge. “Knowledge was supposed to issue forth from the teacher as in a jet, and the pupil was expected to each the jet and scope as much of it as he could.” This may be called the ‘Jet Theory of Education’. A child then, had to undergo a series of cruelties in order to receive knowledge by harsh discipline an a code of conduct people believed that learning cannot take place in the midst of comforts and pleasure. Therefore, physical hardships were deliberately included as and integral part of learning.

 

The Bi-polar Theory of Education

Adams considered the relation between teacher and pupil as bi-polar. In his words, “there must always be a teacher or educator pole, and a pupil of educand pole.” A child becomes a student only because of his relationship with the students. We should not think one pole to be passive, another to be active. In the process of education, the teacher is active while giving instructions and the pupil in active while receiving it. Listening to the instruction of a teacher involves an activity of thought and imagination. In be-polar theory of education, the teacher is active in teaching and the students are active in learning.

 

The Uni-Polar Theory of Education

Adams pointed out that the activity of the educator and educand pole comes to a point of redistribution when the child tries to acquire certain skill and knowledge or develops a pattern of behavior. He becomes a partner of the teacher and tries to educate himself. Now, the teacher is nothing but a means by which the child educates himself. He is no more in the foreground. Thus education becomes uni-polar.

 

Process of education can interpreted as ‘subjective’ and ‘objective’ ‘Education becomes objective, when the student only responds to the stimulus of the teacher without unable to enter the purpose of the teacher by making it making it his own or by opposing it at times. This way never happens in case of some pupils. Hence this process is objective bi-polar . In true sense, it is uni-polar as regards the experience of most educands. In the words of Adams; “In the experience of most educands education is bi-polar throughout, in both subjective and objective spheres. It is true that at the highest point in the educational experience of the intelligent educand, there comes a time when the process appears to be uni-polar, for the educand is now fully aware of his own desires in matter of education and does all his own educating, using the external educator merely as a means. Yet even at this stage, and while the educated thinks that he is complete command of the whole educational process, he may be under education in way that he does not suspect. A school caption, a school perfect, a university student is often in this position. He thinks he is merely using his tutors as means with which to educate himself, while these tutors are deliberately molding his character”

The Tri-Polar Theory of Education

Sri J.E. Adamson proposed a tri-polar theory of education. According to him, the essence of education consists in adjustment which he describe as bringing the individual and his word into relation, the word of the individual is in reality an his words, nature, society and morality, which correspond to be activities of knowing, feeling and willing in human experience. The process of adjustment has both passive and active aspects. The child is molded by his environment but he is also to mold it.

Adams believed that there is definite though variable relation between the educator and the educand. Adamson, on the other hand, establishes a direct relation between the educand and his environment in which the educator is an external factor. In the word for Adamson, “we now come to a point of fundamental importance. It is the position and function of the teacher in relation to his business of adjustment which we take to be the end and essence of education. In the process itself, there does not seem to be any room for him. On the other hand, there is the individual and the other three worlds, and in the miracle of experience they, subjective and objective, have become one; while adjustment in but the elaboration and extension of this unity. The whole business is between the individual and his world, and the teacher is outside it, external to it”.

Thus the bi-polar relation is not between the teacher and the pupil but between the pupil and has environment (worlds).

Purpose and Functions

To make matters more complicated, theorist have made a distinction between the purpose of education and the functions of education. A purpose is the fundamental goal of the process an end to be achieved. Functions are other outcomes that may occur as a natural result of the process – by products or consequences of schooling. For example, some teachers believe that the transmission of knowledge is the primary purpose of education, while the transfer of knowledge from school to real world is something that happens naturally as a consequence of possessing that knowledge-a function of education.

Because a purpose is an expressed goal, more effort is put into attaining it. Function are assumed to occur without directed effort. For this reason it’s valuable to figure out which outcomes one consider a fundamental purpose of education. Which of the following do one actually include in his planning?

As Tom Peters reminds us, “What gets measured, gets done.” Regardless of the high sounding rhetoric about the development of the total child , it is the content of assessments that largely drives education. How is the capacity/ability to think creatively assessed in today’s schools? To what extent is the typical student recognized  and given respect? How often are students given the opportunity to recognize and evaluate different points of view when multiple choice tests require a single ‘correct’ answer?

Teacher who holds a more humanistic view of the purpose of education often experience stress because the meaning they assign to education differs greatly from the meaning assigned by society or their institution. It is clear in listening to the language of education that its primary focus is on knowledge and teaching rather than on the learner. Students are expected to conform to schools rather than schools serving the needs of students.

 

Stopping to identify and agree upon a fundamental purpose of education is rare. One sees nebulous statements in school mission statements, but they are often of the “Mom, baseball, and apple pie” variety that offer little substance on which to build a school culture. Creating meaningful and lasting change in education is unlikely without revisiting this basic definition. At the very least, educators must be challenged to identify and reexamine their beliefs in the light of present knowledge.

 

It is not a function of education to get entangled in narrow and minor concepts. It is in fact engaged in understanding each process of thought. Its objective is to look into the life problems as a whole. In fact, education is only a unit of different aspects of everything that is known or should be known by man. It proves the extensiveness, humility, forbearance and all-embracing nature of education.

Dimensions of Education

“Dimension” refers to the breadth range, extent, comprehensiveness and variety of learning experiences, the extent of range view, outlook, application, effectiveness, and operation. From this point of view, education is concerned with the “whole man”, the entire life of an individual comes under the preview of education.

Education is life itself, Hence its scope is very wide. It is a wide as the whole world and as long as the history of mankind, the following subject-matter may be included under the scope of education:

1.      History of Education- History of education also comes under the scope of education. By the help of this, we understand the gradual development of education during different periods of history. Beside this, it also helps us to find out suitable system of education according to the changing needs of the society.

2.      Problem and Issues of Education – Some of the important problems of education, are vocationalization of education problems of population education non-formal education adult education development of a national system of education, religious and moral education, national integration, medium of instruction etc. Education cannot achieve progress unless it studies the problems and find out their solutions.

3.      Sociology of Education – “Education can be studied from many different views. What is here called the sociology of education is fairly a new name for an aspect of education which has always been the concern of the educator in some from or another.” Education is an activity which goes on in the society. Hence it aims and methods depend on the nature of the society in which it functions. Sociology of education may be defined briefly as a study of relations between education and society. This branch of study deals with aims of education, methods of teaching, administration and supervision, curriculum, only in relation to the socio-political, economic, cultural and religious forces of the society in which they take place.

4.      Comparative Education – In the age of globalization, Comparitive education help us to modify reform, reorient and improve our own education system in the light of the system followed in other countries. It is the study of cross cultural comparison of the structure, operation, methods, aims and achievements of various educational system and practices of different countries of the world.

5.   Education Psychology – Psychology has been considered as one of the youngest, yet one of the most influenced education in many different ways and has practically given a new turn, a psychological turn to the human mind. For a skillful teacher of the present day, knowledge of the child has been considered to be more important than the knowledge of the subject matter, Therefore, teacher at present should be equipped with those psychological skills and competencies which are badly necessary for the successful guidance of learning, adjustment and the growth of the child.

6.      Philosophy of Education – In philosophy are reflected hopes, aspirations, ideals and values of man. Philosophy reflects and meditates on them. For its realization, human society has adopted many occupations. Education is one of the chief ones through which man wishes to attain his long-desired and eternal values. From this standpoint, it appears impossible to realize the educational outcomes without a healthy philosophical basis. As Dupis defines “Philosophy of education is one of the oldest, yet one of the newest disciplines.” It is one of the oldest since Plato, the philosopher of par excellence of ancient time devoted considerable attention to the nature, purposes and content of education, it is one of the newest since philosophy of education began to emerge as a separate discipline only in twentieth century. Now it is realized that philosophy and educations are related like flower and fragrance. Philosophy determines all the aspects of education-nature of education, curriculum, method of teaching, nature of text-book, nature of discipline, evaluation role of the teacher, school organization etc.

7. Techniques of Teaching- The minds of the pupils are growing organism. Filling the minds of the pupils with ideas is not right education. To make the food of education palatable we follow different techniques of teaching. The techniques of teaching have been bided either upon the nature of the subject matter of psychology of the learning process or merely because it has been observed that certain ways of presenting the lesson is essential, to develop the interest and attention of the students. The students of education should get themselves familiarized with different techniques of teaching.

8. Educational Administration and Supervision – Administrative functions are concerned primarily with the infrastructural facilities and the operation of the schools and supervisory functions are concerned with improving the learning situation, A student of education should know how these activities are going on in our schools.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

MOTIVATION-’Golden Road to Learning’

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V(P.G) College, Roorkee, India


Motivation plays a vital role in every sphere of human resource .Motivation is said to be the ‘heart of learning,’  and ‘potent factor in learning’, as all learning is motivated learning. Adequate motivation results in promoting reflection, attention, interest and effort in the pupils and hence promotes learning.

Learning cannot be successful, effective or efficient without persistent, purposeful and selective effort. Naturally teacher’s problem is to discover, direct and capitalize upon these motives and develop interest for educational purpose.

Motivation is the combined action of desires and incentives, pushes and pulls. Like a machine, a person must have energy in order to behave. Motive provides the energy. High motivation means high drive.

Definitions of Motivation

Motivation is derived from the  word motus, movere ‘mover’ which means to move’. It is an art of inculcating and stimulating interest in studies and in other such activities in the pupils. It is the process of arousing action, sustaining activity in progress, regulating and directing pattern of activity. Motivation is defined as the act or process of motivating; the condition of being motivating; a motivating force, stimulus, or influence; incentive; drive; something (such as a need or desire) that causes a person or student to act ,and the expenditure of effort to accomplish results .

According to J.W. Atkinson, “The term motivation refers to the arousal of tendency to act to produce one or more effects.”

According to Maslow, “Motivation is the universal characteristic of every organism state of affair. It is constant, never ending, fluctuation and complex phenomenon.”

According to Good, “Motivation is the process of arousing, sustaining and regulating activity.”

According to Woodworth, “A motive is a state of the individual which disposes him of certain behaviour and for seeking certain way.”

According to Crow and Crow, “Motivation is considered with the arousal of the interest in learning which is essential for learning.”

According to Lowell, “Motivation may be defined more formally as a psychological of internal process initiated by some need, which leads to the activity which will satisfy that need.”

The concept of motivation .

Motivation is typically defined as the forces that account for the arousal, selection, direction, and continuation of behaviour. Nevertheless, many teachers have at least two major misconceptions about motivation that prevent them from using this concept with maximum effectiveness. One misconception is that some students are unmotivated. Strictly speaking, that is not an accurate statement. As long as a student chooses goals and expends a certain amount of effort to achieve them, he is, by definition, motivated. What teachers really mean is that students are not motivated to behave in the way teachers would like them to behave. The second misconception is that one person can directly motivate another. This view is inaccurate because motivation comes from within a person. What many teachers can do, with the help of the various motivation theories, is create the circumstances that influence students to do what many teachers want them to do.

Thus motivation is concerned with the inculcation and stimulation of the learner’s interest in the learning activities. It is the force which energizes a man to act and to make constant efforts in order to satisfy his basic motives. In fact motives are the dynamic force that energizes all behaviour. Motives are to two types-Primary motives and secondary motives.

Primary Motives are the biological or psychological motives. These motives ensure the preservation of life. Hunger, thirst, sex, sleep, rest are the examples of these motives. They are inborn and innate. They are found in all organisms.

Secondary Motives are the psychological or social motives. The need for belongingness, need for security, desire of gaining status and recognition, power and achievement ‘motive’ are its examples.

Motives can be divided into two types: external and internal. Internal motives are considered as the needs that every human being experience, while external indicate the presence of specific situations where these needs arise

Approaches  of Motivation

A Humanist Approach to Motivation; Self-Actualisation.

Maslow saw motivation in terms of an individual’s striving for growth; he sought to explain it by reference to a ‘hierarchy of human needs’. People are ‘wanting animals’. He believed that at any given moment a person’s behaviour is dominated by those of his needs which have the greatest potency. As their ‘lower’, physiological needs are adequately satisfied, motives at a ‘higher’ level in the hierarchy come into play

These needs are hierarchical; high-level needs will be attended to only after low-level needs are satisfied. Maslow’s basic needs (physiological, safety and belonging) are termed deficiency because they motivate (lead to behaviour) when the organism has a deficiency with respect to a need (for example, lacks food or water). The meta-needs (esteem and self-actualisation) are termed growth needs because they motivate behaviours that do not result from deficiencies but from a natural human tendency toward growth. The growth needs will be attended to only after the basic needs are reasonably satisfied. The ultimate need is that of self-actualisation. Self-actualization is a difficult concept to explain. It is a process of growth—of becoming—evident in the unfolding and fulfilment of self.

A Cognitive Approach to Motivation; Self-efficacy.

Bandura informs  that self-efficacy has to do with our own estimates of our personal effectiveness. “Perceived self-efficacy,” he writes, “refers to beliefs in one’s capabilities to organize and execute the courses of action required to produce given attainments” .The most efficacious people are those who are most competent. Accordingly, self-efficacy has two related components: The first has to do with the skills—the actual competencies—required for successful performance; the second concerns the individual’s personal estimates of competence.

Students with a high sense of academic efficacy display greater persistence, effort, and intrinsic interest n their academic learning and performance In fact, academic self-concept he to be a better predictor of future course selections than actual grades in various subjects.

A Behaviourist Approach to Motivation; Reinforcement.

Skinner demonstrated how positive reinforcement increases the probability of a behavior when it follows as a consequence of the behavior. Negative reinforcement also increases the probability of a response, but it does so as a function of being removed as a consequence of behaviour

Positive and negative reinforcement are used in virtually all classrooms; teachers praise and admonish students, they give high and low grades, they smile and frown. These and a thousand other indicators of approval or disapproval are examples of reinforcement. When reinforcement is used judiciously and systematically, it can have profound effects on behaviour.

Types of motivation.

Some psychologists concerned with understanding learning have attempted to formulate ‘categories of motivation’, i.e. groupings of students’ motives for learning.

Instrumental motivation: This type of motivation, which is purely extrinsic, is in evidence where students perform tasks solely because of the consequences likely to ensue

Social motivation: Students influenced by this type of motivation tend to perform tasks so as to please those they respect, admire, or whose opinions are of some importance to them.

Achievement motivation: This is involved where students learn ‘in the hope of success’. Ausubel suggests that there are three elements in motivation of this type:

(a) Cognitive drive—the learner is attempting to satisfy a perceived ‘need to know’;

(b) Self enhancement—the learner is satisfying the need for self-esteem;

(c) Affiliation—the learner is seeking the approval of others.

Intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic motivation arises from a desire to learn a topic due to its inherent interests, for self-fulfilment, enjoyment and to achieve a mastery of the subject. On the other hand, extrinsic motivation is motivation to perform and succeed for the sake of accomplishing a specific result or outcome. Students who are very grade-oriented are extrinsically motivated, whereas students who seem to truly embrace their work and take a genuine interest in it are intrinsically motivated.

Basic Elements of Motivation

Motivation is probably the most important factor that educators can target in order to improve learning.  Numerous cross-disciplinary theories have been postulated to explain motivation.  While each of these theories has some truth, no single theory seems to adequately explain all human motivation.  The fact is that human beings in general and students in particular are complex creatures with complex needs and desires.  With regard to students, very little if any learning can occur unless students are motivated on a consistent basis.  The five key basic elements impacting student motivation are:  student, teacher, content, method/process, and environment.

A-The Student

“You cannot push anyone up the ladder unless he is willing to climb himself.” – Robert Schuller

The student’s role in education is crucial and should go beyond the traditional view of student as customer or recipient of knowledge.  In addition to the roles of buyer and recipient, Research in Higher Education Journal   “students are the raw materials for education and the primary products of educational transformations; and most important…students are key members of the labour force involved in  creating education”

That is, student motivation is enhanced when these factors pertinent to students are present:

Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation:  Typical students bring varying degrees of both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation to the learning arena.  Intrinsic motivational factors found to be at work with most students include involvement Extrinsic motivational factors include compliance,  recognition ; competition; and work avoidance

Various individual and social factors: Overall academic motivation is affected by various individual and social factors

• Hierarchy of needs and perceived well-being:  Students’ perceptions may be clouded by their perceived wellbeing,

Efficient use of energy and focus: Students should be taught how to produce results while maintaining focus and energy.  Hence, educators need to train students to “stalk” efficient and effective results.

Purposeful connection with work: Emergent motivation results from connecting with work as a source of self-expression, exploration, and sustained creativity

Conscientiousness and achievement: Conscientiousness and achievement motivation are positively correlated with GPA.

Public speaking competence: Student motivation has been positively related to public speaking competence, make students more confident and motivated.

Study time and study habits:  Students lead very busy lives.  Having a good set of notes is important, but it still depends on how study time is used

Lecture attendance: Lectures are viewed as positively associated with academic performance. They also are perceived as valuable and interesting learning experiences for students

Comprehensive, long-range educational plan: The development of a long-range educational plan will help students to value education and to make the most of their time in school.  This plan also should contribute to their confidence and reduce the fear of the unknown

B- The Teacher

“…the really great make you feel that you, too, can become great.” – Mark Twain

Students display more motivational benefits from teachers they like over teachers they dislike

.  The following suggestions are offered regarding  teacher contributions to student motivation:

Subject knowledge and motivational level:  The professor’s knowledge of the subject matter and the motivational level of the professor are most important to motivate college students to do well in college.

Teacher qualifications: Qualifications of the teacher employed in universities should be questioned and improved.  Educators need to acquire new qualities and continue to grow and evolve as they are role models for the students

Test giving: Teachers need to know how to give tests that are motivating to the students.  Tests need to have thematic relevance, that is, they need to aim at checking what students have learned and whether they can apply it to real-life tasks

Scientific management and human relations:  The educator must consider whether to approach students from the viewpoint of scientific management, human relations, or both

Conscious of small details:

Consequently, small details do make all the difference.  Greet each student at the door by his or her first name.  Make eye contact and smile.  Actively listen to each student.  Avoid giving advice.  Be genuine.  Be clear in approval and disapproval.  Let students know you do not carry a grudge.  Avoid sarcasm and criticism.

Reach out to students: Student engagement is a key to academic motivation, persistence, and degree completion.  Teachers are competing for the students’ attention, that is, jobs, family, personal activities and interests, surfing the Web, instant-messaging, social media, cell phones and apps, text-messaging, video games, and so forth

Value and build relationship: “Relationships are at the heart of teaching since it is an activity based on communication” .  Some of the necessary elements that build and maintain constructive relationship include trust.  Empathy can help to build a trusting relationship.

Enthusiasm: When the teacher is more enthusiastic about a topic, then the students will be more inclined to believe that the topic has value for them.  That is, teacher enthusiasm can motivate students

C- The Content

What the mind of man conceives and he believes, he can achieve.” – Napoleon Hill

At the least, content must be accurate and timely.  However, content also should be relevant and useful to the student in his or her life

Students experience success and achievement: Ensuring that students experience success is an extremely important strategy for motivation.  Success creates selfconfidence which in turn makes students more inclined to engage in learning.

Student ownership:  Students feel some ownership of a decision if they agree to it.  Whenever possible, students should be allowed to determine class rules and procedures, set learning goals, select learning activities and assignments, and decide whether to work in groups or independently

Student choices: Human beings are naturally curious and self-directed, that is, they want to learn, make choices, and achieve .  As a result, students will be more motivated when they are given choices.  Doing something one chooses rather than what one has been told to do, can be very motivating

Build competency: Content that builds students’ competency requires assignments that challenge students’ beliefs, actions, and imaginations.

Creativity and critical thinking: Competence also is learned from experiences that involve both creative and critical thinking.  Creative and critical thinking requires the student to define the task, set goals, establish criteria, research and gather information, activate prior knowledge, generate additional ideas and questions, organize, analyze, and integrate all the information.

• Students feel connected: Content that contributes to the student feeling connected may include advisory programs, cooperative learning, peer mentoring, peer counselling, and community service.

Novelty: Novel content can introduce a surprising or unusual experience creating a discrepancy in the student’s mind, and this can cause a short-term arousal of interest in order to resolve the discrepancy

Variety: Variety is very relevant to student motivation.  Variety can be brought into the class by including activities wherein the students are physically active with a thinking component.  Other forms of variety can be added into the content via dramatizations, model making, and out-of-classroom activities.

Technology and information from the Internet such as Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and phone apps: Students love the Internet, so give them examples, videos, or demonstrations of topics from Internet sites that are interesting to them.  At the very least, this incorporation of technology, the Internet, and phone apps involves using more of the students’ language and experience base.  Also, the Internet is a great way to keep up-to-date and to show important current trends and ideas.

D- The Instructional Methodology

“If you tell me I will listen.  If you show me I will see.  If you let me experience, I will learn.” -Lao-Tzu

The method or process is the way in which content is presented, that is, the approach used for instruction.  Some specific ideas or tips for are:

Incentives: In general, rewards and punishments work at controlling the students’ immediate classroom behaviour, but they do not foster an intrinsic, long-term desire or commitment to learning.

Mutual goals or objectives: Students need to see the point of it all and know what they personally will get out of the educational process

Verbal conformity: One method to use to support students in accomplishing their goals is verbal conformity wherein the student repeats all or part of the goal in his or her own words.

Flexible and stimulating just-in-time training and interactivity: One way to support students in seeking out responsibility and working toward goals to which they are committed is to use flexible and stimulating just-in-time training which allows the student to train at his or her own pace and time

• Objective criteria: Objective criteria should be clearly communicated and employed in testing and evaluating student success.  The clarity of knowing exactly what is needed can be very motivating.

Encouragement and praise: Positive verbal statements of encouragement and praise can strongly influence student motivation.  Praise for effort and for improvement can build a student’s self-confidence.  Esteem can be boosted by emphasizing his or her performance relative to personal goals

Guided discussion: Discussion seems to be a viable strategy for motivating students.  Through guided discussion, students can demonstrate reading comprehension with integration of multiple and different texts and critical thinking using analysis and synthesis of information

Positive social interactions: When students have positive social interactions with their peers or teacher, they will become more engaged in learning.  Social interaction can occur when students work in groups, have group discussions, group projects, and group presentations

.• Enhanced lecture: While the lecture method is an academic staple, students do not pay attention continuously.  Teachers need to be aware of attention cycles and strive to improve student attention by using student-centred enhanced lecture techniques That is, lectures can be enhanced to make the class stimulating, entertaining, and interactive.

E- The Environment

“To stay motivated you must fight self-doubt, poor discipline, fear, and any other ghost” – Dr. Zonnya

Environment is the fifth key ingredient of student motivation.  First of all, an environment must be available and accessible.

Suggestions for creating an environment conducive to student motivation are as follow:

• Create an effective environment: The learning environment should take into consideration the intrinsic and extrinsic student motivations and the opinions of students and teachers in arranging the environment

Teamwork: An environment of teamwork can contribute to learning.  All teams need four competencies:  generate and refine ideas, organize and integrate work, sustain group spirit, and manage boundaries

Structures: Teachers, administrators, and counsellors contribute to a positive teaching and learning environment by putting in place structures that provide an optimal learning environment for learners

Emotionally literate environment: The more comfortable individuals feel in themselves and with others, the easier it is to concentrate and achieve.

Factors Effecting  Motivation

Incentive

A form of motivation that involves rewards, both monetary and nonmonetary is often called incentive motivation.

Fear

Fear motivation involves consequences. Punishment or negative consequences are a form of fear motivation. This type of motivation is commonly used to motivate students in the education system

Achievement

Achievement motivation is also commonly referred to as the drive for competency generally, this feeling of accomplishment and achievement is intrinsic in nature.

Growth

The need for self-improvement is truly an internal motivation. A burning desire to increase our knowledge of ourselves and of the outside world can be a very strong form of motivation.

Power

The motivation of power can either take the form of a desire for autonomy or other desire to control others around us. We also often aspire to control others around us

Social

Many people are motivated by social factors. This may be a desire to belong and to be accepted by a specific peer group or a desire to relate to the people in our sphere or in the larger world.

 

Characteristics of Motivated Behaviour

The analysis of place of motive in experience and behaviour as given above, clarifies the general characteristics of motivated behaviour.

1. Energy mobilization

Even the most peaceful animal becomes frightening in times of emergency. This is due to the mobilisation of energy. This process of the mobilisation of energy is chemical as well as physical.

3. Variability

Motive has a goal; hence it continuously changes with the view of attainment of goals. In fact, the motivated person goes on changing his ways till he arrives at the way successful for the achievement of the aim.

4. Persistence

Sometimes some motivated actions go on for years A young man in search of a job goes on laboring for several years till he gets a suitable one.  An animal cannot leave its work without achieving the goal of its motive

5. Restlessness for the Attainment of the Goal

The motivated behaviour is goal-directed. The restlessness observed in such behaviour persists so long as the goal is not achieved. For example, the goal of hunger is food. Till the food is taken the restlessness disappears. The goal can be conscious or unconscious.

6. Extinction of Restlessness

After the Attainment of the Goal the restlessness of the motivated behaviour exhibits itself in following ways of the fulfilment of some internal want or desire and extinguishes as soon as that want or desire is fulfilled.
Motivational Techniques

Getting students motivated to learn can be hard no matter what grade level one teach. Sometimes it’s because students find the material boring or useless, or sometimes because they are simply there because they are required to be and not because they have any interest in the subject matter at hand. There are some things many teachers can do, however, to help boost your students’ interest in whatever it is that many teachers are teaching

General

Here are some basic ideas to consider when motivating your students

Encourage internal motivation. Prepare students to learn

Create realistic goals. .Ensure students are aware of their responsibility.

Change the style and content

Make student reaction and involvement essential parts of the learning process

Use group cooperative goals to maximize student involvement and sharing

Plan assignments and exercises that are neither too easy nor too difficult

Explain the purpose behind assignments. Explore the connections between lessons.

Make sure students know what to expect

Don’t over teach. Present material logically.Summarize. Lead by example

Be aware of students’ needs

Enhance the attractions and minimize the dangers of learning.

Downplay setbacks .Encourage additional study.

Keep things positive. Spark Interest

The first step to motivating students is to spark their interest in the subject. Here are some ways you can make any topic seem more interesting.

ü  Focus on the importance of the subject

ü  Use impressive or startling statistics.

ü  Ask rhetorical questions.  Use quotes.

ü  Ask questions to engage the class

ü  Tell a story. Make it funny. .

ü  Incorporate student experiences. Get students involved.

ü    Respond to student interest.

ü  Use visual aids.

Learning Environment

Creating a great learning environment is key to motivating students. Here are some ways you can make your classroom more learning-friendly.

Make the classroom inviting.

Create an environment where students want to learn.  Organize. .

Show interest in students as individuals.

Supporting students in their efforts to learn. .

Promote open communication and discussion. .

Make your classroom learning oriented. Avoid negativity. .

Allow students to help decorate. Create familiarity

Give students jobs around the classroom.

Create special traditions for your classroom.

Feedback

How you react to your students can have a big impact on their motivation to learn. Here are a few things to consider trying.

Give praise. .Help relieve student anxiety.

Confront the beliefs, expectations and assumptions underlying negative attitudes. Provide closure with a positive ending

Build students’ confidence and self-esteem.

Encourage curiosity. Point out areas that need improvement. .

Recognize achievement.

Encourage student response. Arrange learning experiences so that all students can gain at least a degree of esteem. .

Emphasize the positive. Guide students. .

Focus on the behaviour not the student.

Learning Opportunities

Use these special learning opportunities to motivate students.

  • Show students ways that material is useful.
  • Help students set goals.
  • Take field trips
  • Do labs and experiments
  • Make learning more interactive
  • Encourage students to participate. Promote teamwork. .
  • Make concepts real. .
  • Play games.
  • Use computers
  • Allow students to study in groups.

Rewards

Here are some ideas on how to use rewards to motivate your students.

Offer special privileges. Tailor rewards to the individual.

Make learning the reward. Give small rewards.

Make sure all students feel included.

Allow students to display good work

Reward milestones.  Use praise as reward.

Recognize achievements in all students.Don’t make it all about grades.

Work with parents.

Online Learners

Teaching online students can come with its own set of challenges. Here are some ideas on facing them.

  • Remind students that online learning is real learning
  • Get to know your class.
  • Publish requirements and set expectations ahead of time
  • Establish relevance
  • Provide continuous encouragement. Use assessments
  • Get supervisor and peer support
  • Offer rewards and recognition. Ensure success.
  • Connect with students. Encourage students to get to know one another
  • Self-Motivation

Sometimes teachers become the students and can use a little motivation themselves. Here are some ideas on boosting your own learning potential.

  • Imagine yourself in the future. Give yourself rewards.
  • Remember that you cannot know everything.  Find a friend
  • Stop making excuses
  • Plan out your learning. Use the right tools.
  • Tackle things you don’t understand in parts. Focus on the why.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Connectionism -Thorndike’s Learning Theory

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

Connectionism was based on the concept, that elements or ideas become associated with one another through experience and that complex ideas can be explained through a set of simple rules..

Connectionism, today defined as an approach in the fields of artificial intelligence, cognitive psychology, cognitive science and philosophy of mind which models mental or behavioural phenomena with networks of simple units, is not a theory in frames of behaviourism, but it preceded and influenced behaviourist school of thought. Connectionism represents psychology’s first comprehensive theory of learning. It was introduced by Thorndike, the most commonly cited connectionist.

Fundamental concepts-

Connectionism is the theory that all mental processes can be described as the operation of inherited or acquired bonds between stimulus and response. A theory that proposes that all learning consists primarily of the strengthening of the relationship between the stimulus and the response.

Type of learning- The trial and error learning

Connection-Stimulus-response connection, the basic unit of learning according to behaviourist learning theory.

Stimulus- Stimulus can be an object effecting the senses or an idea/ thought. Its nature is purely individualistic that means it  differ from organism to organism from time to time  from situation to situation and from place to place

1. Something causing or regarded as causing a response.

2. An agent, action, or condition that elicits or accelerates a physiological or psychological activity or response.

3. Something that incites or rouses to action; an incentive:

Response-. The Reaction is always in the form of Attraction or Repulsion .Response can be positive or negative, weak or strong, overt or hidden, right or wrong.

1. The act of responding

2. A reply or an answer.

3. A reaction, as that of an organism or a mechanism, to a specific stimulus

Bond- Bond represents the connection in between the stimulus and response. It is denoted by (–)

Strength of connection- The strength of the connection depends upon the reaction time. ( The time taken by an organism in giving response after receiving stimulus ) the strength of the bond/ connection is inversely proportional to the reaction time. The less the reaction time the more will be the strength of the bond/ connection or vice-versa.

Fundamental Experiment-

E. L. Thorndike had a powerful impact on both psychology and education. Thorndike experimented on a variety of animals like cats, fishes, chicks and monkeys. His classic experiment used a hungry cat as the subject, a piece of fish as the reward, and a puzzle box as the instrument for studying trial-and-error learning

Thorndike (1898) studied learning in animals (usually cats).  He devised a classic experiment in which he used a puzzle box (see fig. 1) to empirically test the laws of learning

Thorndike also conducted some of the first laboratory investigations of animal intelligence. A cat has been placed in a “puzzle-box.” The door of the box is held fast by a simple latch. Just outside the cage is a piece of salmon on a dish. The cat moves around the cage, sniffing at its corners. Suddenly, it sees the salmon, moves to the part of the cage closest to it, and begins extending its paws through the bars toward the fish. The fish is just out of its reach. The cat reaches more and more vigorously, and begins scratching at the bars. After a while these responses cease, and the cat begins to actively move around the cage. A few minutes later, it bumps against the latch. The door opens and the cat scampers out and eats the fish. The cat is placed back in the box and a new piece of fish is placed on the dish. The cat goes through the same responses as before and eventually, bumps into the latch once more.

This is repeated again and again. Gradually the cat stops extending its paws through the bars and spends more and more of its time near the latch. Next, the cat begins to direct almost all of its activity near the latch. Ultimately, the cat develops a quick and efficient series of movements for opening the latch.

Thorndike theorized that the cat learned to escape the “puzzle-box” by trial and error. That is, it performed various responses in a blind mechanical way until some action was effect in freeing it from the box. Thorndike postulated the Trial and Error learning to account for the behaviour of the cats.

Components/ stages  in the process of learning-

By analysing the above referred experiment the following components/ stages are evident-

Need- Every need has a quantum of energy  ,that force an organism to act for its fulfilment. Need leads an organism to the state of drive (the state of restlessness ).Here the hunger in cat represent need.

Goal.-The object suppose to satisfy the need .Here the piece of fish meat was acting as goal.

Block- a hindrances in between the organism and the goal, is an essentiality for intensive efforts by the organism to reach the goal. These efforts can also be termed as wrong response. Here the close doors of the puzzle box acts as hindrance.

Random movements- various responses in a blind mechanical way until some action was effect in reaching the goal.

Chance  success-out of blind mechanical responses the success is achieved by-chance. This effort can also be termed as right response. , Here the cat bumps against the latch. The door opens and the cat scampers out and eats the fish.

Gradual reduction in wrong response-here the cat stops extending its paws through the bars and spends more and more of its time near the latch.

Selection of the right response- ,Here  the cat begins to direct almost all of its activity near the latch. Ultimately, the cat develops a quick and efficient series of movements for opening the latch.

Fixation in the nervous system.- . When ultimately, the cat develops a quick and efficient series of movements for opening the latch.

On the basis of above analysis it can be concluded that-

  • The most basic form of learning is trial and error learning.
  • Learning is incremental not insightful.
  • Learning is not mediated by ideas.
  • All mammals learn in the same manner.

Primary/ Basic Laws of Learning

Thorndike first presented his theory in his book ‘Animal Learning’ published in 1968. Connectionism Theory or simply S-R or Stimulus-Response Theory by Thorndike is actually one of the most applied theories of learning. It gave three laws of learning in which is, most widely used theory in education. This theory states that learning is the outcome of the relationships or bonds between stimuli and responses. These relationships become habits and may be strengthened or weakened depending on the nature and the frequency of stimuli and responses themselves.  Learning or a behaviour is formed when  a certain meaningful stimulus to us or have the strong “connection” that we respond to them. These connections become strong and can be further explained by Thorndike’s Three Laws of Learning.

Writing on the subject of the importance of his laws in the action of learning Thorndike says, “Both theory and practice need emphatic and frequent reminders that man’s learning is frequently the action of the laws of readiness, exercise and effect.” Accordingly, in Thorndike’s opinion, man’s learning takes place according of these laws.

1.  Law of Exercise.

2. Law of Readiness.

3. Law of Effect.

Law of Exercise.

Practice makes perfect. This is the cliché that could best describe this law. This means that the more the practice of a certain behaviour, more it will be strengthened. Those things most often repeated are the best learned. This is the basis for practice and drill. The mind rarely retains, evaluates, and applies new concepts or practices after only one exposure. A student learns by applying what he has been taught. Every time he practices, his learning continues. There are many types of repetitions. These include student recall, review and summary and manual drill and physical applications. All of these serve to create learning habits.

Connections become strengthened with practice, and weaken when practice is discontinued

Laws of exercise are mainly those of respective habits, as in rote memorizing or the acquiring of muscular skills. Law of exercise has two sub–laws:

(a) Law of use and

(b) Law of disuse.

  • Law of use –“ When a modifiable connection is made between a situation and a response keeping other things equal, the strength of that connect is increased”.

Connections between a stimulus and a response are strengthened as they are used  .

(b) Law of disuse –“ When a modifiable connection is not made between a situation and a response over a period of time keeping other things equal, the strength of that connection is decreased” .

Connections between a stimulus and a response are weakened as they are not used .

Law of Readiness.

Proper mind set is the key word in this law. This law states that the more “ready” an individual to respond to a stimulus, the stronger will be the bond between them. And, if an individual is ready to respond but is not made to respond, it becomes frustrating and annoying to that person.

In Thorndike words “When a bond is ready to act ,to act gives satisfaction and not to act gives annoyance and  when a bond is not ready to act and is made to act annoyance is caused”.

In Thorndike’s the view law of readiness is active in three following conditions:

1. When a conducting unit is prepared to go into action, its work is quite satisfactory because nothing is done to alter its working.

2. When a conduction unit is forced to act while it is not prepared to do so its behaviour is of a nature calculated to excite anger.

3. The inactivity of a conduction unit which is ready to behave, may be unsatisfactory and any reaction may arise is connection with that deficiency.

Thus a series of responses can be chained together to satisfy some goal which will result in annoyance if blocked Interference with goal directed behaviour causes frustration and causing someone to do something they do not want to do is also frustrating.It means that-

a. When someone is ready to perform some act, to do so is satisfying.

b. When someone is ready to perform some act, not to do so is annoying.

c. When someone is not ready to perform some act and is forced to do so, it is annoying.

Law of Effect.

Law of effect means that the learning takes place properly when it results in satisfaction and the learner derives pleasure out of it . On the other hand, if the learner faces failure or get dissatisfaction, the progress on the path of learning is hampered. For example: When a child solves questions correctly he feels encouraged to do more. But if he fails repeatedly, he is unwilling to make subsequent attempts.

This law is based on the feelings of the learner. Learning is stronger when joined with a pleasing or satisfying feeling. It is weakened when linked with an unpleasant feeling. An experience that produces feelings of defeat, anger, frustration, futility, or confusion in a student is unpleasant for him. This will decrease his learning capabilities.

According to Thorndike “Those acts which gives us satisfaction are tends to be repeated and set and fixed in our nervous system and those acts which gives us annoyance are not repeated and so do not fixed.”

Connections are strengthened if the consequence or the effect is positive. In short, behaviour or learning will take place or be repeated if the result of such action is pleasant.. On the other hand, connection between the stimulus and response weakens when the effect is negative . However, Thorndike reiterated that negative consequences do not necessarily weaken the connections, same is true that positive consequences do not always guarantee the recurrence of behaviour.

In Thorndike words “—[to] a modifiable connection being  made —-between an S and an R and being accompanied or followed by a satisfying state of affairs man responds, other things being equal by an increase in the strength of that connection. To a connection similar, save that an annoying state of affairs goes with or follows it, man responds, other things being equal, by a decrease in the strength of the connection”.

Thus the Law of Effect states that:

• Responses to a situation that are followed by satisfaction are strengthened

• Responses that are followed by discomfort are weakened.

Secondary  laws  of Thorndike’s learning theory:

1. Multiple Response: in any given situation, the organism will respond in a variety of ways if the first response does not immediately lead to a more satisfying state of affairs. Problem solving is through trial and error.  A learner would keep trying multiple responses to solve a problem before it is actually solved

2. Set or Attitude:  What the learner already possesses, like prior learning experiences, present state of the learner, etc., while it begins learning a new task.There are predisposition’s to behave or react in a particular way. These are unique for species or groups of related species, and may be culturally determined in humans.

3. Pre-potency of Elements- Thorndike observed that a learner could filter out irrelevant aspects of a situation and respond only to significant (proponent) elements in a problem situation. : Different responses to the same environment would be evoked by different perceptions of the environment which act as the stimulus to the responses. Different perceptions would be subject to the pre-potency of different elements for different perceivers.

4. Response by Analogy -: New problems are solved by using solution techniques employed to solve analogous problems In a new context, responses from related or similar contexts may be transferred to the new context. This is sometimes referred to as the theory of identical elements.

5. Associative shifting -: Let stimulus S be paired with response R. Now, if stimulus Q is presented simultaneously with stimulus S repeatedly, then stimulus Q is likely to get paired with response R. It is possible to shift any response from one stimulus to another.

6. Belongingness: If there is a natural relationship between the need state of an organism and the effect caused by a response, learning is more effective than if the relationship is unnatural.

7. Polarity: which specifies that connections occur more easily in the direction in which they were originally formed than the opposite.

8. Spread of effect:- i.e., rewards affect not only the connection that produced them but temporally adjacent connections as well.

 

Thorndike’s Position on problems of Education.-

Thorndike discussed on six typical problems-

  • Capacity-Learning capacity depends upon the number of bonds and their availability. The difference  between bright and dull are quantitative rather than qualitative.
  • Practice-Repetition of situations does not itself modify connections. Repetition of connections leads to a negligible increase in strength, unless the connections are rewarded. Practice is important because it permits rewards to act upon connections.
  • Motivation- Rewards acts directly on neighbouring connections to strengthen them; punishment has no corresponding direct weakening effect. Punishment may work indirectly, however, through making the learner do something else which may confront him with a reward.
  • Understanding- The role of understanding is minimized, not because it is indemonstrable, but because it grows out of earlier habits. The best way to get understanding is to built a body of connections appropriate to that understanding. When situations are understood at once, it is a matter of transfer or assimilation, that is, there are enough elements in common with old situations to permit old habits to be used appropriately.
  • Transfer-The theory of identical elements is espoused. Reaction to new situations benefits by the identity of these new situations, in part with old situations, and also by a principle of analogy described as assimilation.
  • Forgetting- The original law of disuse assumed forgetting to take place in the absence of practice with accordance with the empirical findings.

Educational Implications:

Connectionism was meant to be a general theory of learning for animals and humans. Thorndike was especially interested in the application of his theory to education including mathematics (Thorndike, 1922), spelling and reading (Thorndike, 1921), measurement of intelligence (Thorndike et al., 1927) and adult learning (Thorndike at al., 1928).

Law of Readiness: Educational Implication

The teacher should make proper use of this law. Whenever we are physically sick or mentally disturbed and at that time if some thing is taught to us, we cannot pay attention to it and as a result do not learn it.

A person learns best when he has the necessary background, a good aptitude, and is ready to learn. .  A clear objective and a good reason for learning sometimes help to motivate students to learn. A student who is usually ready to learn meets the instructor halfway. Outside responsibilities, overcrowded schedules, health, finances, or family affairs can take away a student’s desire to learn.

Law of Exercise: Educational Implication-

Educational Implications of the law of exercise is great. It lays importance on the value of repetition, drill and practice for memorizing and mastering of any learnt material. It emphasizes that there should not be a long gap between one practice and the next one because long time disuse may lead to forgetting. Frequent test should be taken to make the students practice the subject learnt.

Those things most often repeated are the best learned. This is the basis for practice and drill. The mind rarely retains, evaluates, and applies new concepts or practices after only one exposure.. There are many types of repetitions. These include student recall, review and summary and manual drill and physical applications. All of these serve to create learning habits.

Law of effect : Educational Implications-

This law is based on the feelings of the learner. Learning is stronger when joined with a pleasing or satisfying feeling. It is weakened when linked with an unpleasant feeling. An experience that produces feelings of defeat, anger, frustration, futility, or confusion in a student is unpleasant for him. This will decrease his learning capabilities. A student’s chance of success is definitely increased if the learning experience is a pleasant one. This law has great educational importance. The teacher can apply it in the classroom situation by introducing the principles of pleasure and pain, reward and punishment. When the student does something wrong and he is punished for it, he will not do the work again because punishment gives him pain. On the other hand, if the student is rewarded for his success or any good work, it gives him pleasure and he wants to repeat the work, making it permanent.

 

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Macaulay’s Minute on Indian Education

Dr. V.K. Maheshwari, Former Principal

K.L.D.A.V(P.G) College, Roorkee, India

His idea of “a learned native” was of a native “familiar with the poetry of Milton, the metaphysics of Locke, and the physics of Newton”, i.e. Indian only in external features, but for all intellectual and practical purposes steeped in western, nay English philosophy, science and literature.

 

In the 18th century, Indian masses received religious education pertaining to Christianity through Christian missionaries.  However, when the East India Company came to India they did not allow the missionaries to propagate religious education to the common people in India. They felt that, the education from the missionaries would encourage religious sentiments among the people in India that could affect the business policy and the diplomatic role of East India Company.

It was through the Charter Act of 1813 that a state system of education was officially introduced in the Indian history. This clause of the Charter Act of 1813 compelled the East India Company to accept responsibility for the education of the Indian people. As a result, from 1813 to 1857, the company opened many schools and colleges under their control, which laid the foundation of the English system of education in India

In this clause, Governor-General-in-Council directed that a sum of one lakh of rupees, each year shall be set apart for the revival and improvement of literature and encouragement of the learned natives of India, and for the introduction and promotion of knowledge of the science among the inhabitants of the British territories in India. For the first time official money was allotted to expand the education of the Indians.

Macaulay’s Minute

Lord Macaulay landed in India on June 10, 1834 and was immediately appointed as president of General Committee of Public Instruction. Macaulay arrived in Madras on June 10, 1834, and proceeded to Ootacamund, Nilgiris, where the Governor General of India William Bentinck was camping for the summer. Macaulay wrote of his initial experience as follows: “To be on land after three months at sea is of itself a great change. But to be in such a land! The dark faces, with white turbans, and flowing robes: the trees not our trees: the very smell of atmosphere that of a hothouse, and the architecture as strange as the vegetation” (Trevelyan 1876: 334). There was a salute of fifteen guns when he set his foot on the beach! . Lord Macaulay wrote a minute on 2ndFebruary 1835, where he made the decision regarding the controversy. Macaulay always devoted his best to the job on hand. In his youth, Macaulay exhibited “vehemence, over-confidence, the inability to recognize that there are two sides to a question or two people in a dialogue,” just as other young men displayed (Trevelyan 1876; 112). While these traits were tempered in his later years, Macaulay was always a man of his own ideas. And he was greatly influenced in his ideals, ideas, and ideologies by the great achievements of Western civilization, sciences, philosophy, and theology. His nephew-biographer writes, “His speeches and essays teem with expressions of a far deeper than official interest in India and her people; and his minutes remain on record, to prove that he did not affect the sentiment for a literary or oratorical purpose” (Trevelyan 1876: 235).

In 1835, the arguments Orientalists were put before Lord Macaulay, who rejected the arguments of the Orientalists through a very forceful minute wherein he supported the education of the classes and made a vigorous plea for spreading Western learning through the medium of English.

On March 7, 1835,  Lord William Bentinck also accepted Macaulay‘s recommendations and sanctioned it officially. In 1837 English was made the court language and a Government Resolution of 1844 threw high posts open to Indians. These measures resulted in a rapid growth of English education. The missionaries also established a number of English schools and colleges

Macaulay wrote in his minute “we must at present do our best to form a class of persons Indian in blood and colour and English in taste, opinions in morals and in intellect,”

Macaulay’s arguments in favour of English: Macaulay rejected the claims of Arabic and Sanskrit as against English, because he considered that English was better than either of them. His arguments in favour of English were

1.      It is the key to modern knowledge and is therefore more useful than Arabic or Sanskrit.

2.      It stand pre eminent even among the language of the west in India, English is the language sponsored by the ruling class. It is likely to become the language of commerce throughout the seas of the east.

3.      It would bring about renaissance in India, just as Greek or Latin’s did in England  or just as the languages of western Europe in civilized Russia

4.      The natives are desirous of being taught English and are not eager to learn Sanskrit or Arabic.

5.      It is possible to make the natives of this country good English scholars, and to that end our efforts ought to be directed

6.      It was impossible to educate the body of people but it was possible through English education to bring about “a class of persons Indian in blood and colour and English in taste , opinions in morals and in intellect”, and that education was to filter down from them to the masses

 

Macaulay concluded his Minute with a characteristically dramatic flourish, threatening to resign from his position as President of the GCPI if his proposals were rejected. He knew that this was an empty threat, and, as he anticipated, Bentinck immediately gave his ‘entire concurrence’ to the Minute.

Bentinck appears to have been anxious to settle the education controversy before his departure from India . As noted above, he gave the Minute his immediate assent, and to effect its speedy implementation, he deliberately prevented any discussion of Macaulay’s scheme in the GCPI. Seed (1952) claims that Bentinck purposely withheld action on the education question until the very end of his term in office because he feared that the radical nature of the policy would arouse the opposition of the Court of Directors in London, upon whose blessing all policies ultimately depended. Seed further argues that the timing of Bentinck’s decision was shaped by his experience in Madras in 1807, when he was dismissed from the Governorship for his alleged insensitivity to Indian religions and customs.By introducing the controversial new policy on the eve of his departure, Bentinck perhaps calculated that he would succeed in avoiding a similar humiliation.

Bentinck’s underlying caution is evident in his Resolution of 7 March 1835 giving effect to the new policy. In accordance with Macaulay’s proposals, the Resolution stated that ‘the great object of the British Government ought to be the promotion of European literature and science among the natives of India, and that all the funds appropriated for the purpose of education would best be employed on English education alone’ . However, in a significant departure from theMinute, Bentinck disavowed any intention ‘to abolish any College or School of Native learning, while the Native Population shall appearto be inclined to avail themselves of the advantages which it affords’ . Although the Resolution stipulated that no further stipends be awarded for Oriental studies, it was careful to direct that native scholars already in receipt of government grants would continue to enjoy their allowances. Bentinck’s concessions on these points seem to have been prompted by pressure from influential groups in Calcutta’s Muslim and Hindu communities, who, upon hearing news of Macaulay’s scheme, submitted petitions to the government protesting against the new policy. The Governor-General’s softening stance towards Oriental studies a matter of weeks after expressing his ‘entire concurrence’ with the Minute would therefore appear to bear out Rosselli’s  contention that ‘Bentinck let Macaulay fire the rhetorical big guns while ensuring that vested interests suffered little actual damage’.

Macaulay left India in December 1837, apparently with satisfaction for the job he did in India

Analysis of Macaulay’s Minute

Since the decision to promote English education had been taken well before the Minute’s composition, Macaulay’s purpose was essentially to justify the policy which had already been agreed upon rather than to persuade Bentinck to support the Anglicist position. Macaulay was aware that in formulating its education policy the GCPI was bound by the Charter Act of 1813, which required the East India Company to encourage both Western and Oriental learning. While the Anglicists’ project accorded with the Act’s stipulation that funds be assigned for ‘the introduction and promotion of a knowledge of the sciences’, it was apparently at variance with its requirement that education policy should also be directed towards ‘the revival and improvement of literature, and the encouragement ofthe learned natives of India’. Though perhaps not an explicit statement of British intentions, it was generally accepted that this objective envisaged the revival and improvement of Arabic and Sanskrit literature ratherthan English literature.

Indeed, as Spear(1938 )notes, the flimsiness of Macaulay’s legal case accounts for the content and tone of the Minute: the withering attack on Indian learning, the source of its continuing notoriety, was intended to distract attention from the provisions of the Charter Act, which he knew provided the Orientalists with their strongest argument. Given the fragility of his case, it is not surprising that Macaulay addressed the legal issue in a perfunctory manner, brushing aside the arguments of the Orientalists with what Spear (1938: 84) describes as ‘an Olympian statement of opinion that the Act of 1813 intended the exact opposite of what its words implied’.

Having concluded that the grant at the Government’s disposal could be used to promote learning ‘in any way which may be thought most advisable’ ,Macaulay proceeded to discuss the most useful way of employing it. Since all parties agreed that the vernacular languages contained ‘neither literary nor scientific information’ and were thus too ‘poor and rude’ to be used as instructional media, the GCPI was faced with a straightforward choice between Sanskrit/Arabic and English, the central question being, according to Macaulay, ‘which language is the best worth knowing?’ (p. 1405). Macaulay’s case for English was founded on his belief in the intrinsic superiority of English literature and science over Indian learning, and on his conviction that a strong desire for English-language education existed among certain segments of the Indian population.

Macaulay maintained that his low estimate of the value of Indian learning was shared by his adversaries in the Orientalist camp: ‘I have never found one among them who could deny that a single shelf of a good European library was worth the whole native literature of India and Arabia’(p. 1405)

.According to Macaulay, the claims of English were hardly necessary to recapitulate. It stood pre-eminent among the languages of the West. Whoever knew English had ‘ready access to all the vast intellectual wealth which all the wisest nations of the earth have created and hoarded in the course of ninety generations’ . The important political and economic role which English was beginning to assume in India and in the emerging Empire also provided a strong justification for promoting education in the language. Thus, whether viewed from the perspective of Britain’s growing imperial interests, or its value as the repository of a superior body of knowledge and thought, English was the language which Macaulay believed would be ‘most useful to our native subjects’ (p. 1406). The simple question before the British authorities was whether, when it was in their power to teach English, they would instead teach languages in which there are no books on any subject which deserve to be compared to our own,whether, when we can teach European science, we shall teach systems which, by universal confession, wherever they differ from those of Europe differ for the worse, and whether, when we can patronise sound Philosophy and true history ,we shall countenance, at the public expense, medical doctrines which would disgrace an English furrier, astronomy which would move laughter in girls at an English boarding school, history abounding with kings thirty feet high and reigns thirty thousand years long, and geography made of seas of treacle and seas of butter.

Apart from extolling the virtues of English literature and science vis-à-vis traditional Indian learning, Macaulay sought justification for his plan by arguing that Indians evinced a far stronger desire to learn English than Sanskrit or Arabic. In setting out his case, Macaulay challenged the time-honoured Orientalist argument that the promotion of Oriental studies helped to conciliate the influential classes in Indian society. Macaulay contended that ‘unanswerable evidence’ existed to prove that ‘we are not at present securing the co-operation of the natives’; in fact, the policy of engraftment was having quite the opposite effect.

For Macaulay, the ‘state of the market’ should determine language policy (p.1409): We are withholding from them the learning which is palatable to them.We are forcing on them the mock learning which they nauseate. This is proved by the fact that we are forced to pay our Arabic and Sanskrit students while those who learn English are willing to pay us. (p. 1408)

Having presented his case for English, Macaulay advanced the idea of ‘downward filtration’, which proposed that the meagre parliamentary grant be used to cultivate a class of anglicised Indians who would not only serve as cultural brokers between the British and their Indian subjects, but who would also refine and enrich the vernacular languages, and thereby render them fit media for imparting Western learning to the masses:

In one point I fully agree with the gentlemen to whose general views I am opposed. I feel with them that it is impossible for us, with our limited means, to attempt to educate the body of the people. We must at present do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern – a class of persons Indian in blood and colour, but English in tastes, in opinions, in morals and in intellect. To that class we may leave it to refine the vernacular dialects of the country, to enrich those dialects with terms of science borrowed from the western nomenclature, and to render them by degrees fit vehicles for conveying knowledge to the great mass of the population.

While the sentence advocating the creation of an acculturated Indian elite is justifiably regarded as the epitome of cultural and linguistic imperialism, Macaulay’s critics have tended to overlook the significance of the preceding sentence, which indicates that his controversial scheme was entirely dictated by government parsimony, and have similarly chosen to ignore the import of the following sentence, which reveals that the development of vernacular education constituted an important element in the Anglicists’ project.

Macaulay accompanied his plan with three specific measures designed to ‘strike at the root of the bad system which has hitherto been fostered by us’ (p. 1412). Though careful to stress that existing interests should be respected, he nevertheless proposed that the CalcuttaMadrasa and Sanskrit College (Calcutta) be abolished,that the printing of Arabic and Sanskrit books be discontinued, and that no further stipends be awarded to students wishing to pursue Oriental studies at the Delhi Madrasa and Sanskrit College (Benares).

.It is important to note, however, that the authorities in Calcutta formulated and began implementing the new policy on their own initiative rather than seeking prior approval from the Court of Directors. In fact, the documents relating to the new policy did not reach the company’s London offices until January 1836, that is, almost a year after Bentinck had given his initial assent. It was not, however, until January 1841 that the controversy over Macaulay’s Minute was finally laid to rest, and it would be a further 13 years before the British produced, in the shape of Wood’s despatch, their definitive statement on language policy in India.

 

Critical Appraisal of Macaulay’s Minute

It was the knowledge of English  language, just like that of Persian or Arabic in the age of the Mughals, was and is, the surest way to better employment opportunities. English was and is a definitely and distinctively powerful language used by those in power. It is the surest, best and fastest way to achieve the mush coveted social mobility in India. Ironically, English is the paradigm modern language of political and economic power; …the factor responsible for disenfranchisement of a vast majority of populations in the third world . There are, in fact, two nations in our country today: one that is designated as Hindustan, and the other India.Hindustan speaks vernaculars and dreams of climbing the power and social ladder. The English speaking, rich and powerful section of our country are designated as India by thinkers today. The present paper is an attempt to trace the development of India and Hindustan from the pre-independence India. Its focus will be on Thomas Babington Macaulay’s Minute of the Educational Policy (the Minute), 2 February 1835, that is widely blamed or acclaimed as the foundation of the future education policies of India, hence of future India. Taking up such an old link in the chain of colonial policy and using the past as a parallel to the present is justified by the fact that the past continues to live with minor changes even today. Even today there exist in India the powerful elite who rules and the powerless masses that is ruled and exploited. Even from today’s free India, there is a huge drain of wealth, like its pre-independence colonial days, to both a parallel black economy and to various foreign bank accounts. The juggernaut set in motion in the nineteenth century crushes the bones of millions of Indians even today, although they are citizens of a free democracy with freedom to choose between a whole set of options between a life in perpetually powerless poverty and a slow but definite descent into death. It is also important because English Language Teaching (ELT) policies in India descended from those of the Raj era, just as many of the implicit assumptions regarding education and value of native civilization and languages. “It is education that plays the dominant role in suppressing local languages and forcing alien languages and cultural values onto people” (Kachru et al 306). InIndia, as Macaulay had planned, the system and medium of education planted in the past did their work perfectly.

Thomas Babington Macaulay’s Minute of the Educational Policy (the Minute), 2 February 1835, that Lord William Bentick had later assented to, was the cornerstone of the long term development of the education system of the Indian subcontinent as it “had the support of the powerful government lobby and was a classic example of using language as a vehicle for destabilizing a subjugate culture with the aim of creating a subculture” . Macaulay had written it, as a Member of the Council of India, in reaction to the policy of education being followed in India at his time. The 1813 Act of the British Parliament had set apart one lac rupees “for the revival and promotion of literature, and the encouragement of the learned natives ofIndia, and for the introduction and promotion of a knowledge of the sciences among the inhabitants of the British territories” (Macaulay). Macaulay was totally against the way the above mentioned amount was used. He was heavily critical and disapproving of the Arabic and Sanscrit literature. His idea of “a learned native” was of a native “familiar with the poetry ofMilton, the metaphysics of Locke, and the physics of Newton”, i.e. Indian only in external features, but for all intellectual and practical purposes steeped in western, nay English philosophy, science and literature. A scholar of the Sanskrit sacred books, Hindu rituals and philosophy was not to be called learned. Moreover, Macaulay based his strong plea for change in the educational policy on the explicit mention of the promotion of the knowledge of science among the colonized natives. The orientalists were campaigning for the maintenance of the status quo. Macaulay, on the other hand, was very sure of the uselessness of teaching “certain languages and certain sciences, though those languages may become useless, though those sciences may be exploded”. He claimed with certainty that the vernaculars would become useless with the passage of time, being replaced by the dominant language: English. Time proved him wrong. Hindi, Urdu, Bengali and Tamil are spoken by a very large proportion of the world’s population today. The number of people who call these languages their mother tongue is increasing day by day. Macaulay’s claim of the unscientific native sciences was not reached at through a scientifically valid research and analysis of only facts. It was based on baseless and immature opinions of an opinionated white man.

Macaulay’s confident assumption of the eventual exploding the native sciences was made with an arrogance that knew no bounds. It was with this very characteristic faith in his white racial supremacy that he declared: “We have a fund to be employed as Government shall direct for the intellectual improvement of the people of this country”. The unsaid yet widely believed opinion of his time was that the Orientals were beasts of natural impulses, given to the pleasures of flesh, and nothing else. His generalizations are so totalizing and confident that they leave one speechless with intellectual rage. He had the courage to pronounce: “All parties seem to be agreed on one point, that the dialects commonly spoken among the natives of this part of India contain neither literary nor scientific information”. He was not alone in explicitly or implicitly mentioning so. There were many, among the colonized too, who were of a similar opinion. They had, as Paranjape points out, an “insufficiency thesis” regarding their own culture and its products. Raja Ram Mohan Roy, a famous social reformer and enlightened Hindu who started Brahmo Samaj movement in Bengal, did not “have much use of traditional or Sanskrit learning”. He demanded for his countrymen the knowledge of the western sciences and the modern empirical method. It is this very “unqualified enthusiasm for techno-modernity” that Gandhi later opposed in his Hind Swaraj. “His Hind Swaraj …contains the anti-thesis of Rammohun’s insufficiency thesis. Gandhi advances what might be termed the complete self-sufficiency thesis. He says Indian civilization is superior to modern civilization” Macaulay was not making his assertions on his own authority, or in opposition to the claims of the point of view he opposed. In fact, one of his most infamous assertions is made on behalf of both Orientalists and Occidentaslists, as he had “never found one among them [the Orientalists] who could deny that a single shelf of a good European library was worth the whole native literature of India and Arabia. The intrinsic superiority of the Western literature is indeed fully admitted by those members of the committee who support the oriental plan of education”. It was their faith of their superiority, fed by their collective chauvinism, which made the colonizers blind to reason.

Macaulay mentions very clearly that even among the orientalists, the Sanskrit and Arabic poetry, the best and choicest fruit of these classical languages, was seen as inferior to the European one. The Minute had not a single idea that was “invented”. Macaulay was just presenting the then prevalent line of thought that had matured through the long struggle between the two major and contending views the colonizers held of the colonized of the East: the Orientalist versus Occidentalist controversy. It was the overall discourse, i.e. “large body of texts with a similar intent and set of protocols”, of contrapuntal positions . It had generated all the ideas and the heat, one part of which is strongly present in the Minute. Neither extreme of views was race exclusive, as they had both white and brown proponents, depending on the part of grand narrative they were interpellated with. Yet, they did constitute parts of a structure and could only function while belonging to it. The Minute only present a set of ideas, not essentially and exclusively related to either the content or the medium of education. It is very important to focus on the Minute in detail because it is from this point of origin that whole subsequent system is alleged to have come, especially by those who criticize it.

Macaulay made sweeping generalizations disregarding both common sense and specific examples that might have proven it otherwise. He claimed that the English had “to educate a people who cannot at present be educated by means of their mother-tongue”, while either ignoring or ignorant of the fact that in Bombay presidency vernacular was successfully used as the medium of instruction in schools. His linguistic chauvinism knows no bounds when he asserts confidently that English stood “pre-eminent even among the languages of the West”. His claim was neither unique nor uncharacteristic of his times. In addition to the obvious superior intrinsic value of English language, he was also presenting more concrete reasons:

Thus he was presenting a very strong case for the adoption of English as the medium of education and also for an insidious infiltration of young minds when they were the most impressionable. He knew that “language is a system of culture, not merely a system of communication. [and a]… culture is deeply embedded in a language” . Thus he was aiming at something much more significant than just the medium of instruction. His explicitly expressed objective, just like that of his race, was regarding “a great impulse given to the mind of a whole society, of prejudices overthrown, of knowledge diffused, of taste purified, of arts and sciences”. His race was there to civilize the ignorant barbarians of the East and he knew that the white man’s sacred burden ought to be shouldered with a dutiful faith. His arrogance, a very characteristic imperial arrogance, oozes out of the whole body of the text. He takes the implicit assumptions of his time as self-contained and self-sustaining axioms of the perfect Euclidean Empire. His certainty is amazing, as is his unshakeable faith in the superiority of his race. He opines that, “when a nation of high intellectual attainments undertakes to superintend the education of a nation comparatively ignorant”, the learners must be guided by their masters (pun intended), and not the other way round. His generalizations had no rational ground or support. He declared the literature, history, metaphysics and theology of  India as “absurd”.

With a very strongly chauvinistic assumption regarding his race and its culture, Macaulay asserted that the British must try to create a class of Indians who would act as interpreters between their countrymen and their white masters. He envisioned very shrewdly the creation of “a class of persons Indian in blood and colour, but English in tastes, in opinions, in morals and in intellect”. To a large extent he succeeded in his plan. The postcolonial theory very clearly states that it is impossible for an alien nation to colonize and exploit another nation until they get ample support from certain sections of the colonized people themselves. The collusion of the colonized with the Empire was one of the main reasons not only behind its successful entry into India, but also behind the sustenance of the colonial rule. Macaulay’s success was so complete that even today a whole set of counter currents run in the Indian system, as was mentioned in the beginning of this paper. The colonizers had created an elite and language was an important element in the successful execution of their plans as the colonizers were also in part linguistic codifiers, who were able to act as gatekeepers for those who wished to share in the economic and other benefits of becoming English users.

Macaulay’s confident assertions may be proven fallacious, illogical, and even ridiculous today, but, ironically, his prediction turned out to be true. English is the most coveted and the most popular medium of education in urban India. The hegemony of English language and literature is directly linked with the forces of globalization and polarization of powers – both military and monetary. As far as India is concerned, English happens to be the passport for securing gainful employment in the private sector. Thus, it acts as it did nearly two centuries ago, as is mentioned in that much detested and debated about document. Even poor people send their children to English medium schools in hope that learning English would definitely enhance their employability and will finally help in moving up from the social stratum they belong to. The same motivation was working exactly in the same manner in Macaulay’s time too. The language of power was creating market and learners at a very fast pace; just as it had done in past after the Muslim invasion and expansion in India. Macaulay had very incisively opined about the market demand for his language and its eventual spread in India: “Nothing is more certain than that it never can in any part of the world be necessary to pay men for doing what they think pleasant or profitable”. He had ample support favouring English against the classical languages of learning.

Analysing Macaulay’s premises, assumptions and claims leads one to a coherent and distinct attitude he had towards life and humanity. He appears to have a firm faith in the superiority of the West over the East – aesthetically and intellectually, arising implicitly out of its geopolitical superiority. He may have been proven wrong about the geopolitical and temporal strength and extent of the Empire, but he was accurate about the predictions he made regarding the strength and future of the linguistic entity called the Empire of English language. Two hundred years after the Minute was written Randolph Quirk expressed a similar confidence in the future and power of his language: “a language – the language – on which the sun does not set, whose users never sleep”. It is this very empire of English language of which South Asia is a part. Most of the erstwhile British colonies in South Asia, English stayed there, even after the Empire was done away with. It has now taken roots that have gone too deep to be uprooted in near future. Macaulay’s aim of creating an intermediary class was fulfilled. He did not know it fully that his prophesy would come true one day, especially when he was mentioning the future of English language in the world

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off